User avatar

Em16

  • Novel / Chapter » Fanfiction, General Re: Severus's adventure

    First off, I want to say this was one of the wackiest, craziest things I’ve read on YWS, and I love it. It’s just so many levels of weird and ...

    May 26, 2020
  • Art » Realistic, General Re: The last triumph

    Wow. This was heartbreaking. You really were able to show the world of the characters, and create that image in my head. I love how you move back and forth ...

    May 25, 2020
  • Lyrics » Lyrical, Narrative Re: bird watching

    Specific Comments: Stanza 2, Line 4: I love the way you say “these broken bodies are only vessels”. I don’t exactly know why that line is so good, but it ...

    May 25, 2020
  • Short Story » Mystery / Suspense, Teen Fiction Re: Detective Duo

    Nice job with the opening paragraph! The suspense immediately drew me into the story and I wanted to know more. However, I was left wondering who the narrator is. They ...

    May 25, 2020
  • Poetry » Dramatic, Horror Re: Poetry Of A Living Nightmare. Yes? No? Like A Flower Petal.

    Hi, I’m Em16! First off, I’d like to say you did a great job with the tone of this poem. It felt so unreal and ethereal, almost like a ghost ...

    May 25, 2020
  • Poetry » Realistic, Health Re: My life in the lockdown

    First off, nice job with the rhyme scheme! A rhyme scheme can often feel forced and constricted, but I felt this rhyme scheme flowed quite naturally. You also did a ...

    May 25, 2020
  • Poetry » Dramatic, General Re: Shadow Days

    Hey! Nice job on this piece. I’m super impressed that you were able to write such a beautiful, and coherent sestina. Sestinas are hard. I also loved the way you ...

    May 23, 2020
  • Short Story » Science Fiction, Romantic Re: I. L.O.V.E. Y.O.U.

    Hey! This piece was great. I love the way you started out talking about advertisements, and then quickly shifted to love. It’s so ominous. Advertisements represent commercialism, which should be ...

    May 23, 2020
  • Poetry » General, Fantasy Re: Inner-me

    I love the first line. It’s so enticing, and immediately draws in the reader. I also love the way you describe how your thoughts take over your body and mind. ...

    May 19, 2020
  • Poetry » General, Romantic Re: "Scars to your beautiful"

    Hey! I love the descriptions in this piece. “Her eyes- / they look like pearls in the throes of the ocean” is a particularly beautiful description. I also love the ...

    May 16, 2020
  • Poetry » Realistic, Satire Re: Perfect

    Specific Comments: Stanza 1, Line 2: Nice alliteration! Stanza 1, Lines 3-5: I love the imagery here. It brings to my mind a pottery vase or bowl, being shaped by ...

    Apr 7, 2020
  • Short Story » General, General Re: The Girl with a Thousand Cranes

    I liked this story. It was very unique, definitely unlike anything I’ve ever read before. I liked the descriptions, and the way you lead the reader through the whole story. ...

    Mar 31, 2020
  • Novel / Chapter » Literature, Fantasy Re: Heroes of Valtome, Chapter 3

    Specific Comments: Paragraph 1, Line 1: What happened to the thing Marxei needed help with? Did it get resolved? Also, why are she and Rhysive chatting? They barely know each ...

    Mar 31, 2020
  • Novel / Chapter » Fantasy, Literature Re: Heroes of Valtome, Chapter 2

    Specific Comments: Paragraph 1, Line 1: You start the story by saying “across town was a bard performing a song”. You then reveal this bard is Rhysive; why don’t you ...

    Mar 31, 2020
  • Art » Historical Fiction, Realistic Re: Prologue for a book about war.

    Specific Comments: Part 1, Paragraph 1: Your opening paragraph is very interesting, and philosophical. However, for the opening paragraph of a novel, I felt it was a little too vague. ...

    Mar 31, 2020


constant state of confuzzle
— Quillfeather