I appreciate the expansion of clubs! I've always felt like clubs had potential to be fun hubs of more niche activities but were a little clunky and had performance issues. The updates to them will help with that absolutely.
I do think I am still going to struggle justifying using activity in clubs personally when forums are there. I say this because:
- Forum posts show up on the front page whereas club topic posts do not
- You can like a forum to broadcast it on people's feed. Unless you're subscribed to clubs it doesn't show up in the feed. There's also no club alternative to "liking" a topic to advertise it.
- -- perhaps club admins can have an option to "Post to People" when they make club announcements and it would share it to people feed on "All Members" and as if they were in the club
