Madder had almost finished stuffing her clothes into a sack when someone knocked on her door. She froze, her uninjured hand still hunting for stray clothes in her drawer.
“Madder? You okay?”
Percy’s voice, higher than usual with concern. The iron vice around Madder’s lungs eased open, and her heart slowed to a less frenetic pace. “I’m fine,” she called back, and then winced as the door slid open. Of course Percy would take that as permission to enter. Under normal circumstances, it would’ve been.
“You weren’t at dinner,” Percy said. She had a tray of food balanced in her arms—borogove legs and some kind of hash—and looked vaguely ashamed of herself, although Madder couldn’t imagine why. “I, um… Are you going somewhere?”
Madder dragged her last pair of trousers out of the drawer and let them fall into her sack. It sounded louder than it should have. “I’m leaving,” she said. “I’m done with this place. I’ll never be able to do anything if I stay.”
She made the mistake of trying to clench her hands into fist, and a hot spring of pain shot up from the mangled palm of her right hand. Though she tried, Madder couldn’t suppress her flinch. She stared at the floor while Percy set the tray down on her bedside table, her face aflame with embarrassment.
“Is this about what happened in training this morning?”
If her cheeks had been burning before, now they were practically nuclear. “You know about that?!”
“I know you got hurt,” Percy said, her tone gentle. “Not how, or how bad. Uh.” Her gaze flicked down to the fresh bandages swaddling Madder’s hand, and then to the side. Madder shuffled, digging the toes of her left foot into the ground. Frostbite had destroyed the end of her big toe, leaving a nub of dead bone and tissue that cut her like a razor-blade whenever she touched it. The sharp, electric pain of that pressure was something familiar, and it helped her focus on not sinking into the ground out of sheer humiliation.
“Carmine thinks I might have a disease,” Madder said. Her voice came out flat, almost clinical, an imitation of the healer’s tone when he raised this possibility. “Something making my skin weak, easy to tear, so it’s too dangerous for me to—I’d never be able to do anything. I’d just sit in Queensquare all day, being waited on by nurses and… watching.”
Her eyes felt like melting; for a moment, she entertained the notion that they’d turn to wax and dribble down her face instead of tears. Maybe the rest of her would follow, and the world would look better from the inside of a puddle.
Madder shook the thought from her head and wheeled around to drag a shirt out of her dresser at random. She would not cry in front of Percy, would not ruin the one scrap of dignity she still had left.
“...And your solution is to run away?”
“Yes!”
“Madder—” Percy let out a quiet, frustrated growl and before Madder could even blink, she’d crossed the room and pulled Madder around to face her. “You’ll get killed out there if you go out alone. It’s dangerous.”
“I don’t care.”
Madder was aware that she sounded petulant, but it didn’t matter. For seven months she’d endured bed rest and coddling because there was an end date, a time when she would be better, but if Healer Carmine’s blood tests and biopsies returned a positive result, she’d never be better enough.
“There are bandersnatches and, and barmaglots and—”
“I don’t care, I’m not going to stay here and just be—breakable, Percy, I’m not.” Madder shook herself out of the other girl’s grip—easily enough, since Percy was almost a head shorter—and glared. “I’m not delicate.”
“I know you’re not, Madder,” Percy said. “But even the Chessers get killed by monsters, and you’re...”
“Weak,” Madder muttered.
“Just a kid,” Percy said, folding her arms. “You’re thirteen, Madder, and untrained.” She took a deep breath, and added, “Which is why I’m going with you.”
“...What?”
“I’m not going to let you go off on your own and get killed,” Percy said, in brisk tones startlingly reminiscent of the Red Queen. Madder blinked hard.
“You’re not trained either,” Madder said.
“I’ve got seven months on you,” Percy replied with a shrug. “Besides, I grew up on the board and Nonli’s taught me a few things. I know what squares to avoid and how to run really fast if we need to get away from something.”
“I know how to run too, Perce,” Madder said after a moment’s hesitation. Granted, her still-healing feet and Healer Carmine’s fretting had prevented her from ever actually running, but if it came to fleeing for her life, Madder thought she’d figure it out just fine on her own. Percy rolled her eyes.
“Red Queens have a special way of running from point to point without having to muddle through all the space in between,” she said, as if this sort of thing ought to be obvious. “Nonli taught me how to do it in case of emergencies.” Her gaze sharpened until Madder felt in danger of being impaled. “I’m coming with you, Madder, or else I’ll tell Nonli and she’ll stop you.”
“Fine,” Madder muttered. “Pack something and meet me by the stables.”
“Not the gardens? It’s easier to slip out through—”
“Not the gardens,” Madder said. Her skin prickled just thinking about it; the gardens grew right beneath the Looking Glass, and she had no intention of going anywhere she risked meeting her reflection again.
She still had nightmares about the first time.
“Not the gardens,” Madder said again, softer. “Half an hour, or I’m leaving without you. I don’t want to get caught.”
Percy gave her a little half-smile and began to retreat. “Eat your dinner,” she said. “See you in a bit.”
Madder waited for the door to slide shut behind Percy before she moved. A few more pieces of clothing found their way into her sack while she moved on automatic; she toyed with the idea of taking what she had now and making a run for it alone. Percy deserved better than to get caught up in all this.
Her stomach grumbling put that thought to rest by drawing her attention to the pinched feeling in her midriff. The last thing she’d eaten was a skimpy lunch of bland hospital fare, and that had been hours ago. And she didn’t have time to eat and leave without Percy, so selfish or not, she’d have to accept the other girl’s help. She didn’t want to escape the doldrums here only to collapse of hunger in the middle of the board, after all.
All the same, a cold, guilty feeling coiled in her gut as she tore into the food Percy had left her.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Here we go again.
Yes this is one of my Biggest Pet Peeves in fantasy: using modern terms in very non modern settings. If this is meant to foreshadow Madder is from Earth, it's doing a rather poor job of it because it's already established she has no memory of home. This line doesn't come with any wondering what nuclear is; she simply uses the word to describe herself (yes I know this is third person, not first, but it's limited third so it's like Madder is describing herself).
I think it's particularly jarring because this world feels very modern already. You're talking with very high level medical works, things that sound like they come straight from an earth hospital in 2014. It's already difficult at times to tell exactly what time period and place this is, so something very clearly of the modern world really gets me right out of the story.
Past that, the dialogue feels a tad stilted. I'm not sure if you've established their relationship over the past seven months, and I didn't really feel any history between the two. There's nothing in the conversation that tells me "they're close enough Percy would go with her" and, instead, I'm sitting here going "she's going to join in this is how things go", and I end up right.
It feels kid-like, which I'll give you props for, but I'm not sure you've got a kid relationship done. They've had seven months, and maybe I'm horribly jaded, but I don't know if I really feel a level of closeness I'd expected. Maybe it's because you have a seven month jump that's completely unaccounted for and we don't get to see a development, but it almost felt... infodumpy. Like Percy's dialogue was meant to give world mechanics instead of show compassion and caring.
I'm probably way off the mark. There just seems like a lot of information in here that should be redundant. It's not, obviously, because we're brand new to it, but just the fact Madder should probably know it, and all of this is an "I know"... there can be a sense we're only hearing this information because we need to know it, and if we weren't actually there the conversation would've gone differently. I'm not sure how you can change it, unfortunately, and I am aware you've rewritten this already so this could be completely irrelevant.
You know where to find me.
~Rosey
Hi dear!
Remember what I said about commas?
Okay! So I assume Noni is the Red Queen? Is that the fancy, Queensland way of saying "aunt"?
First off, I love that you're using the squares concept from Looking Glass. I read the book a long time ago and vaguely remember it, but I do recall the squares and how Alice had to keep moving, lest she get lost? Or something like that? Hopefully you'll recap/explain it more for the readers so I can remember all of it. ^^
But anyways, I love that you used that. What a great obstacle; I can't wait to see how they overcome it.
I like Percy already; she's sweet. You could do better with focusing on their relationship; if Percy is willing to come with Madder, then she clearly must care a lot about the other girl. Elaborate more on this. What happened? What brought them so close together? How close are they? You're doing great with imagery but you tend to be vague when it comes to certain things. Be careful about that; we are eager and greedy readers. We want to know all the stuffz!
Other than that, this is going well. I'm a bit disappointed that Madder is already trying to leave. Though I get it. The condition she supposedly has is hard to hear D: don't already kill off our heroine! At least have her wait around to hear the verdict.
Those two on the run should be exciting. At least we get to see more about this Queensland. I can't wait to read more so do keep me updated! Hope this helped.
~Iggy
*distant sounds of cackling* kill her off? nope. Madder gets run through the mill... multiple times... that's all. there is no death in her future. none. whatsoever. 8D
as to the rest:
nonli is a gender neutral term for aunt/uncle because queenie is nonbinary and needed one; that's also why pronouns. (and this, i don't intend to go into detail about in the narrative itself, because such things are completely normalized in my!wonderland)
and yep, more details about how the glassland works and fleshing out of relationships to follow in upcoming chapters.
thanks for the reviews!
Hey! I'm back to review part 2.
I didn't expect that. Is it a nickname?
Percy is a girl?
This is sad but beautiful. I love the imagery you've used.
Was the Red Queen in the Prologue? I haven't read that and I've no idea who this queen is.
There is nothing else to review, it's an amazing story and I really do love it!
Thanks!
Percy's short for Persephone, although that... might not end up in the narrative for a while yet. And the Red Queen is introduced in the prologue/maybe chapter one I don't know what's going to happen with that quite yet, yes.
Glad you enjoyed! If you'd like I can tag you when the next chapter goes up.
Okay, I feel like I tell everyone this, but:

--Madder had almost finished stuffing her clothes into a sack when someone knocked on her door. She froze, her uninjured hand still hunting for stray clothes in her drawer.
That's your first sentence/paragraph. You have to hook the reader with that first sentence--it's what a lot of people use to decide whether or not they're going to continue reading. I know that seems a bit unfair to the rest of the book, but it has to really pop. I would tweak it a bit. Write that first sentence as interesting as you possibly can.
I really like the interaction between the characters. I think you could add another layer in the description though and give us a bit more descriptions with character action/feelings. Other than her cheeks blushing, nothing else really popped out at me.
Is this about Alice in Wonderland? Red queens and looking glasses! Aaaaah! That's such a fun world to play with. The details are really great--you toss them in without a lot of explanation so I have to ask: Will you describe them more later? I'm guessing the board is a chessboard they have to cross? But remember, in world building, your readers don't know these things.
Either way, great work here! Keep it up!
Hi! Thanks for the review!
This isn't actually the beginning of the chapter. That's here-> Monachopsis | Chapter One: The Fall (1/2), I divided it up because length. (There's also a... sort of prologue, sort of chapter one that will probably not actually make the final cut but which I haven't quite decided what to do with yet. That's here->https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work.php?id=114555 and it happens seven months before this chapter.)
You are so welcome, darlin! And I apparently did not pay enough attention. When I just reclicked the link to read your comment, I noticed that. I am going to go read part uno!
nooo worries xD Thanks again!
Again--you are so welcome. I live for reviewing!
And wonderland? *dreamy*