Hi there! Lim here with a review. I’m just going to focus on the ‘character’s mind’ aspect you mentioned in this work’s summary, since this seems to be a piece of internal monologue and there’s not enough here to discern the plot, character goals, etc.
General Impressions
The atmosphere of this piece definitely feels very lonely. I can tell the main character Hiba feels like he doesn’t have anyone to turn to and no help is available for his situation. The way his mind/dreams are described sounds very otherworldly. I’m not clear if the hunting imagery is meant to be taken literally or as a metaphor. At the moment, it feels like it could be both, since we know the character is being held captive somewhere.
Descriptions
While reading this short extract, I enjoyed some of the individual descriptions. For example “fear that vibrated his core” was interesting because it compares fear, an emotion, to a sound/movement. I don’t think I’ve seen this comparison made before, so it drew my attention. Also, “This dream was layered like an onion and laden with deep complexities” was another interesting image, especially when you continued it with the “swirl” description. Expressions like these give the narration a poetic feel and also create the fearful atmosphere. I personally enjoy that type of flair to the writing from time to time, though it can get a bit heavy and distract from the plot if overused. For example:
Each day they came closer to catching him, feeding on every ounce of emotion and wringing them out like tears, but so far, their quarry had remained elusive.
The main sentence here already seems to be metaphorical (the dreams are being compared to wolves) but then there is a further comparison (emotions to tears) within it. And tears don’t immediately link to wolves to me as well, so it’s doubly heavy to figure out.
Character
I think the main idea to consider here is the way Hiba’s “ruminations” are written. I can’t really get a sense of who he is reading those paragraphs. It kind of feels like they could have either been a lot shorter, or that they could have been clearer in content. For example, I mentioned that while figurative language and description can be interesting to read, they can also be obscure in some contexts:
For his ruminations would be with him until his death. They were untraceable and omnipresent at the same time and hunted him with the ferocity of wolves, and like wolves, they attacked him with similar ferocity.
At this point, I know he has ruminations and nightmares, but no idea what he’s ruminating about, since it is summarised for me as this long extended metaphor. Usually in stories, a character’s inner thoughts would maybe be represented in italics, like maybe ‘They’re going to get me, Hiba thought’. In your piece, I see that the thoughts are bothering him but I don’t see the thoughts themselves, which makes it harder to understand the context of what’s going on in Hiba’s mind at the moment.
Maybe what you’re aiming to do is only to hint at what he’s dreaming about to give that ‘horror beyond words’ effect. In that case, I think the context would still need to be established – maybe with a line saying that Hiba couldn’t remember exactly what fearful things he was going through because they were so terrible, or that he couldn’t articulate it and didn’t want to think about it. That would have helped me understand what was going on a bit better, if this was your intention.
Overall
I think a scene like this would build up tension in the story. My guess/ expectation is at some point Hiba is going to have to tell Nagasaki what’s been going on with him, or his lack of doing so is going to get him into trouble. My main suggestions in terms of revising the scene (if that’s what you’re planning to do) would be to clarify the context of the dream descriptions.
Hope this helps – let me know if you’d like more feedback on something specific!
-Lim
Points: 19640
Reviews: 430
Donate