Published June 17, 2010
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
hey there! well you already know that i emailed my review to you. I also think it would help you to get more reviews on this if you posted this in chapters, like they said, or perhaps do some reviews yourself! remember that there is a 2 review rule for everything you post, so make sure to spend time and help other writers. email me if you have any questions, I'd be glad to help
Hey there! Today I am going to review everything by chapter. I'm sorry if I am harsh, I don't want to hurt your feelings, (:
Editing will be in red.
Blue is highliting a sentence.
#FF0000 ">Okay, the only problem I have with this is that it shouldn't be moving so fast, (Don't worry, I sometimes do it too) and you throw the reader into it, and its overwhelming. Also, everything is telling which may annoy your reader.
Chapter two:
#FF0000 ">Again, everything seems rushed. The reader feels like they are sprinting through it instead of enjoying the story. Also try adding more description in everything.
#FF0000 ">Overall:
I like where this is going, I really do. I really want to read more. Good start, just needs more looking over. (:
I'm sorry, I can't edit more at the moment. I will look over the rest later. I'm sorry if I hurt your feelings in any way, it's not my intention. (:
Hello Tinkerfee! I am here to review your novel. I must first say, though, that I only read Chapter One. You might consider splitting up their chapters on their own? It'll be a lot easier for people to read, keep up with, and review your novel that way. I'd first like to say that I think you've got some interesting stuff thrown into the mix. The fact that a king kidnapped an Elvin princess, cut down a whole forest... that's some heavy conflict you're laying down! I do have a few things I'd like to point out to you about the writing, and hopefully it'll help you more in the end.
Hello, My Name is...Character
I'd like to talk about the way you introduced us to your character:
The way you wrote this is interesting, to me at the least. You write it as if she's looking at someone else in the mirror - not herself. Which was just strange. But my larger point is that you should cut this entirely. I know you may feel the great desire to have your reader know exactly how your character looks ASAP - and it's true, when we meet someone in person, we know exactly how they look right away - but that doesn't flow so well in writing. Especially when you're doing it by having your character look into the mirror. Think about it: when you look at yourself in the mirror, do you examine every part of yourself? You might look at yourself, but you're probably looking at yourself to check your teeth, fix your hair, put make up on... You're not doing it analyze your eye color, your hair color, etc etc... So it seems really weird and unnatural to write your character that way. (Okay, so I will admit I have looked at myself in the mirror and intently analyzed my eye color - but that's still weird!)
In my own stories, I generally don't describe the way my characters look physically. Maybe I'll describe some item of clothes, but it'll be in the context of describing an action, or something, and I make sure it's smooth and not blatantly annoying. Other than that though, my reader doesn't know their hair, eye color, etc. I just find it muddles up my prose, and generally speaking, how they look isn't as important as who they are. You'll need to get across that she's an elf, but maybe you can find some other, smoother way to go about doing that.
Now... if who they are is the important part, how do you get that across? I'd like to suggest you check out Snoink's Character Development Usergroup. It'll help you give an idea of how to flesh your character out so they're realistic, lively, and help you develop more of your story's plot and conflict.
Fast and Furious...but not too Fast
You wrote a lot in chapter one even though it's only a bit under 1,000 words. That your chapter is only 1,000 words is a problem, but you have way too much crammed into that little space. It's hard for me to follow what is happening because it's happening so fast. Your first paragraph, where she gets kidnapped, could all be one scene unto itself - there's a lot there you could be doing. Hooking the reader, introducing us to your character, to the main conflict, her being kidnapped, the worry... I think what you really need to learn is how to craft a proper scene. It's a little challenging at first, and in fact for the longest time I wrote without concern to what a scene is or isn't because they confused me. I'm trying to find an article online about how to write a scene, but it's actually proving rather difficult.
Basically a scene has a beginning, middle, and end. And among all that, there is also the "focal point" of the scene. What is the most important part of it? Why does this scene have to be in your novel? You need to keep that focal point write with that focal point in mind. Also, an ending doesn't mean a complete resolution of whatever conflict is in the scene - and not all scenes have to have conflict, though most should. You can also end on cliff hangers, and such, but they're still endings.
Honestly, the best thing that may help you with this? Open your favorite book. Read the first chapter, or the first few chapters. You'll notice that they take the time to show what is happening, to paint a picture, to settle the reader into it before rushing off real quickly through the story. Get an idea of how your favorite writer creates a scene, starts the novel. It might give you an idea of how to write yours.
I hope all this helps! Best of luck!