Is that her? Judd Germaine thought to himself.
If he's thinking to himself, it should either be quoted or in italics. I prefer italics, so the reader doesn't confuse it with actual out-loud dialogue.
He wouldn’t let the girl out of his sight.
He's not a her; he's a him. Haha.
His smile was as long as the Mississippi river though it soon shortened to as long as a puddle.
I just don't like the last part of this sentence. The beginning's good, but the end just doesn't seem right. Perhaps, "Though it soon became frozen over as the smile faded." or "Though it soon shortened to the size of a water droplet."
Judd’s bluish gray eyes became saucers and he slowly stepped away from the bench.
Judd's eyes didn't slowly step away from the bench, now did they?
“It's okay[/], Judd. I know you miss Lucy.” Ms. Lansky said.
[b]The "its" that was originally there was in the possessive form. And ok is correctly spelled either "Okay" or "O.K."
At that, Judd turned around and ran across the street back to his house. His mother was still sitting on the porch. Tears stung her eyes.
2.
The beach was officially closed, but one man still remained, looking out into the dark abysses of the ocean.
He mouthed the name over and over again, as if he said it a million times, his only daughter would appear right beside him.
Scott.
What you were doing with the name "Lucy" I understood, but throwing "Scott" in there, not part of the sentence, confused me. I feel it was sort of unnecessary.
He closed his eyes and it was like he was being transported into the past[b], into one of the several games of catch he played with his kids.
And the game started. At first, all you could hear was the whoosh when the ball was flying through the air and then the humph when the ball hit the next person’s palm or the splat if it hit the ground. It was musical. Whoosh, humph, whoosh, humph, whoosh, splat, whoosh, humph.
The "when" in "or the splat" didn't make sense. I really like the last part.
After awhile, voices were added to the mix of music.
There's no "h" in "were"
“Hey, Dad, I got an A on my math test!” Judd exclaimed happily between catching and throwing the ball.
“That’s great, son. Keep up the good work,” Scott would always say. He wasn’t the kind of father who put pressure on his kids to do well in school, but when they did, he always made the effort to congratulate them.
“Tomorrow, I’ll take you out for some ice cream as a celebration, ok?” Scott said.
“Ice cream, Lucy Goose. You’ve had it before, silly.” Scott said, gently throwing the ball Lucy’s way.
“Sweet? Sweet like you, Daddy?” Lucy asked, with a confused expression on her face.
Scott chuckled and said, “Yes, sweet like me. And sweet like you, too!” Scott said.
You should add a new line when Scott begins to talk.
Those were the days, he thought to himself.
Hi! I thought it was a very nice story! I really like the idea. I have a suggestion: Perhaps when Scott is remembering that game of catch, you'd italicize the whole thing? I've seen many books do that, and it may make flash-backs more clear to the reader.
Anyway, good story. I want to know what happened to Lucy! Haha.
Points: 890
Reviews: 152
Donate