Warning: This work has been rated 16+.
Author's Note: This is rough. I am well aware. But...I've been carrying this for way too long and finally was able to get it out. This was as "proper" as I could get it on my own.
you pleaded for one last day
with tears shining on your face;
and i, fool that i am, reluctantly agreed
because i was afraid of what it meant.
i wanted forever, not one last day.
--
you ran to our cluttered storehouse full of broken dreams,
the army bag still a virgin to battle
and my easel covered in layers of dust instead of paint.
you dug around and brought out that white picket fence
as i tore up the pristine ground for you to put it in.
the moment you grabbed my hand
i noticed its trembling;
i don’t think you did, though.
--
you threw up cardboard and called it walls,
insisted tattered sheets were silken curtains.
i was upset since they blotted out the sunlight
but you said it burned too brightly.
a cracked, leaking vase sat on a crooked table
and i watched fake flowers wilt as water pooled on the floor.
you distracted me with shiny things,
a ring for each of my fingers,
though the left hand was glaringly one short.
--
we played pretend in our collapsing house;
every night whispered “i love you”
and every day started with a kiss on both cheeks.
but my trembling only grew in the cardboard cage;
your treasured sentinels covering our windows
took on the shape of fanged shadows;
i could not see.
--
the seams holding me together split and
with a ragged cry i tore those sheets wide open.
you screamed at me and said i ruined our last day but
my reply was uncaring.
“you were right about the light.”
the sun did burn but i was sick of the umber,
and all our little props became trash again.
--
i saw things i didn’t in the dark:
like a love note you wrote
addressed to a name that wasn’t mine
and a lipstick smear on your neck.
your tears which i thought shone true
were plastic by the light of day.
--
i turned my back on you,
and we went our separate ways.
you glanced back once
with your arm tight on another’s waist
to see if i was looking back too.
but all you saw was a middle finger raised high
and me dancing in the sunlight
as i thanked God for our one last day.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
I liked it. I think it hides what the writer feels. It doesn't exactly tells us what's happening with you, that's what i thought of it. I like it like that, mysterious. Keep up the good job!
Hahahaha! Hey, there! GreenLight24 here with a review for you on this super Saturday morning!
This is my second review after a pretty long period of reviewing inactivity, so I'll be shaking the dust off a little bit here in the beginning.

*Clears throat*
First off, this poem is quite the thoughtful piece. In my opinion, poetry is the most artistic and emotional literary art form. What I always look for in a good poem are the same qualities that I might look for in a nice painting or sculpture. I'd ask myself, "What emotions is this piece attempting to convey?" "How is the artist trying to convey them and what sort of images and emotions does this invoke within my own mind and heart?" Lastly, I would ask myself whether or not they've succeeded in doing those things. With this narrative poem, I think you have.
The ver first thing that jumped out at me as I read and reread this one was the extended metaphor of the makeshift house you used in order to characterize the relationship between the narrator and the presumed ex.I love how you just kind of took that first step there in the first stanza and didn't look back. Sometimes, running with just one metaphor for the entirety of a poem can leave the piece feeling predictable, stagnant, and with themes that are a little to obvious. That's why it's important to be able to really delve into it and to get the most out of the metaphor in question. Here, you've done just that. Not only did you talk about the makeshift home, but also about the different aspects of it as well. (the curtain-walls, the crooked table, and the leaking vase). It was also cool that you were able to tie those things in with one another so well. Each of the things you mentioned (most notably the table and the rings on the narrator's fingers) seem to be building towards this whole idea of imbalance and nervous instability within the relationship. The fact that each of these objects which represent imbalance are things that would often characterize a loving and harmonious relationship adds a whole new layer of dramatic irony that really gives even more life to the frustration and other feelings you were aiming to convey.
Another thing I liked about this poem was the very blurry contrast between light and dark. (most notably represented here by the light of day and the night) Often in literature, light and darkness can be used to represent opposing forces ( those of good and evil or others), sickness and health, holiness and heresy, etc. Basically all kinds of very extreme juxtapositions. In this poem, I loved the way you used light and darkness to juxtapose the narrator's complacent imperceptiveness with their intuitive sense that something wasn't quite right with this relationship. My favorite line is the one in which the narrator mentions that they "Saw things they didn't in the dark." once the sun came back up. This line is especially cool because it conveys the idea that you can't ever truly see the light until you've had to live in a state of constant darkness. I think that idea is applicable not only to difficult relationships, but to life in general. When a poet can tie their own themes and ideas in with general big ideas about the world, it's nothing short of amazing.
As far as critiques that I have for you here, I think most of them have already been mentioned by the previous reviewers. I just wanted to give you some feedback on the stylistic and thematic elements here. Although your descriptive language and thematic elements are beautiful, I think there are some things that you could do to make this even better. I mean, let's be honest, there's ALWAYS room for improvements, even with something as awesome as this one. I guess what I'm saying is that I'd like to see you take this a step further with some of the big ideas in here. (light vs. dark and that whole dichotomy of ideas, trust vs. distrust which I think you could explore a little bit more here, and love vs. makeshift or feigned affection/mild attraction or infatuation.) Don't get me wrong, I'll be the first to tell you that I LOVE this poem. (and that's NOT makeshift or feigned affection XD) I guess suggesting you take it even further is just wishful thinking on my part. Even so, if you ever do consider editing this, I think you will find that this thing could reach greatness levels of OVER9000!!!!!
I hope this review is helpful for you going forward and I really do love the work you've done here. Great job, buddy and Never Stop Writing!
Hello, rhiasofia here to review!
I really like this a lot. It's very interesting, yet takes very common images which ties this piece down very well, allowing the reader to feel connected and involved, rather than a seperate part. The imagery was very vivid, you had a great flow and movement through the poem, and it was full of very strong emotional movement. Your grammar was also perfect.
All I'm going to do is try helping you reword a few sentences which I feel sort of stick and feel awkward. Use them or don't, I hope they'll at least help you figure out how you would like to change them.
You're using the past tense of the other verbs around this segment, which makes the wording of these lines feel wrong. I suggest changing it to "the army bag was still a virgin to battle".
I wouldn't use since here, it feels really off. I'd go with "that" instead.
This one's really nitpicky, but I think this line could be really high impact with a little tweaking. I would make the first line "a ring for each finger". It's shorter and less convoluted, and the brevity will emphasize the next line. The next line, I don't know, I would play around with how to say that. You could say something like "with the left hand at loss for one" or "but one left finger void of gleaming promise". It could just be a little more creative.
If the dialogue is the "uncaring reply", I reccommend putting a comma after the first line rather than a period. However, I don't feel like that line really fits as dialogue. I think it's a great line and should be kept, but I'm not sure that the best choice is to have it denoted as a quotation. That feels sort of faked.
The rest was great, keep it up!
Hey thebrightestfell.


Woah. This was really profound. I love how you arranged your poem (how you used more of a prose format). I do this with my poems a lot and it's nice to know that I'm not alone, haha.
The description was outstanding. Lines such as "you threw up cardboard and called it walls,
insisted tattered sheets were silken curtains.
i was upset since they blotted out the sunlight
but you said it burned too brightly.
a cracked, leaking vase sat on a crooked table
and i watched fake flowers wilt as water pooled on the floor" (which is pretty much a stanza, but don't mind me) really blew me away. It makes my imagination happy. ^^
I didn't see any grammar mistakes. I don't know about the lowercase...I also tried that recently, but I'm not sure about it. It didn't distract me, but I thought it was worth mentioning. One thing I didn't especially like was how you put quotation marks around “you were right about the light.” I know it's kind of dialogue, but as a reader of your poem, I think I would prefer it not to be in quotations; it makes it more personal to the reader.
I did NOT like the ending, but only because it made me sad and angry, which may be a good thing or bad thing, take it how you want.
Please keep writing. I really loved this!
Yours,
Sav
Thanks so much for the review!
And also thank you for mentioning the quotation marks because I was unsure if I wanted them or not (I mean I really didn't but I didn't want to confuse people about the statement or punctuation or whatever so I threw them it). If you, as a reader, like it better without then it just gives me permission to take it out. XD
I'm sorry you didn't like the ending but I'm glad you loved the poem!
-Bright
Haha. Your welcome, that's okay, and me too. If that makes any sense. XD