Runs in the Blood (Ch. 2)

PreviousNext

About a week later, I noticed Arthur after school, staring out a window. We'd continued to share the same table at lunch but hadn't tossed a single phrase in the other's direction. I think we were both disgusted with each other. However, curiosity has its squirmish way of overwhelming softly held feelings, and I wanted to know what he was up to.

"Hey," I said, moving to stand next to him. "What're you looking at?"

He didn't turn away from the window. "Nothing. Or everything. Take your pick."

I had to stretch to see out the window properly. The view was not worth the effort. The parking lot, in all its crumbling glory, stretched out until it was penned in by the tennis courts. Surrounding those were cozy little houses with comfy little lawns. Absolutely unimpressive. I turned to look at him instead, but that view wasn't much better.

"This is why they think you're a freak."

"No, it's not. I know why they don't like me." His voice was young, but held the weight of an old soul. It must have been exhausting, to bear so much, even in his speech.

"This isn't exactly helping, is it?"

"What do you want?"

"You're avoiding that Justin kid, aren't you?"

He shrugged. "His last name's Jopp. Mine's Josam. Our lockers are next to each other."

"So you hide out of the way until he's left." I thought him a coward, and I did nothing to hide my disapproval.

He looked at me for a moment, then turned back to his window. "Get over yourself. You're no better."

"What's that supposed to mean?"

He had a way of recoiling without moving. It came from his eyes, his shoulders, the tilt of his head. Like he was folding in on himself. "Nothing. Never mind."

"I will mind. What?"

"You're avoiding people too. You're just more showy about it." He glanced down the hallway, which was mostly clear now but for a few stragglers, and shuffled off. Arthur might never have thrown a punch, but the truth can hurt too.

I headed to my own locker and walked out of school. By then, my dad had pulled up in his minivan. Ellie my sister had already claimed the front seat, which I kicked her out of, as was my right, being the oldest. Ellie repaid me by kicking the back of my seat the entire ride to her new dance classes.

"Okay, kiddo," Dad said after pulling into a parking spot. He smiled at Ellie in the rear view mirror. "Have fun." Ellie looked at the new studio, her smile faltering. It must have loomed grand and terrible in her mind.

"It'll be fine, Ellie," I said. "You're their type of person. You're lovable." She smiled at me, kicked my seat again, and hopped out. The moment of fear had passed; she forged forward with gusto.

I watched her flit into the dance studio with a stab of jealousy puncturing my lungs. I think all siblings are jealous of each other at some point along the way. Mine came from Ellie's bright and airy spirit, the way she flitted through life, like she was fluttering above it. If I was a grumpy troll who found 'small talk' to be a daunting type of daily riddle, she was a fairy, with a magical laugh, a mischievous smile, and a frizzy sort of grace.

I expected Dad to drive off after Ellie had slipped inside the building, but he left the car in park. I turned to face him.

"Maude," he said in that uncomfortable voice that children hate to hear from their parents, "We need to have a talk."

"Okay."

"Well. Your teacher called. You're not in trouble, but she was concerned about... your choice in friends." He smiled sympathetically. "I know Mom and I have been encouraging you to use this move to start over, make some friends, and I'm very proud of you for making an effort. But this Arthur Josam, he's... not the right friend for you."

"How do you know? Have you ever met him?"

"No, but I've met you, and I love you, sweetie. I want what's best for you. I want you to be safe." That's part of the reason we left Minneapolis- because the cities had grown so unsafe. Too much violence. Crime rates had spiked in all the big cities across the country in the last few decades, and no one knew what to do. Some blamed economic stagnation, some blamed the weather, or technological advancement, or the polarization of politics, but none of those things had quick, simple fixes, so no one wanted to fix them. Then someone had suggested it might be genetics. Maybe a gene mutation had created aggressive individuals who were more mentally and morally capable of crimes. Suddenly, scientists were hunting for evidence of such a gene, desperate to be the first to find the Murderer Gene. They hadn't- yet. But that didn't mean people couldn't speculate. It rarely takes evidence to convince people of a theory they find convenient.

"You see, the thing is," Dad said, "Arthur has inherited violent tendencies. His father killed-"

I crossed my arms. "Arthur hasn't inherited anything! He's a joke- he wouldn't hurt anyone if his life depended on it. I know- I've met him."

"Maude, calm down," he said sternly, breaking out the 'Father Voice', "They say the gene expresses itself suddenly, unexpectedly. Just because there's no evidence of it yet doesn't mean that it's not true. Violence runs in his blood."

I sighed. I could never win battles against my dad. He stayed too calm. "I'm not even friends with him. We just sit at the same lunch table."

"Maybe you could find a different lunch table?"

I looked out the window. I honestly didn't know if I could. I was no Ellie. "Sure. Whatever."

"That's my girl. Now let's get home. Do you have any homework?"

Comments & reviews · 2
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

User avatar
Morrigan
Review

Hi there! I'm here to rescue this from the Green Room!

I didn't read the first chapter, but I can tell what's going on.

I like this. It's intriguing, and it makes me wonder what's going to happen next, and what has happened already. Maude, while not the most tactful person in the world, seems to be straightforward and honest, and I like that in a main character.

That being said, there are a few things that caught my attention.

After Arthur tells Maude that she's no better, I feel like the transition between that and Maude going to her locker was really abrupt. I thought that the two had been sitting at the lunch table, but it seems as if they were in a hallway? I would make the setting more clear than it is now. I do like the dialogue between the two, though.

I don't know who "they" is that is talking about this murdering gene, but it seems a little unrealistic. I think it would be more realistic if Dad was basing his argument on his own personal worries and biases because it would be more realistic.

Altogether, I enjoyed reading this. I wonder what will happen next! I hope that this review proves useful to you. Happy writing, and happy review day!

Hi tgirly,

I'd like like to say that I haven't read any of the previous chapters and I'm entering in blind. This is somewhat desirable, actually, as many people will turn to a random chapter in a story in a bookstore to see if the book is to their liking. Assume I've done that.

That said, critique sandwich time.

1. What did I like about this piece?
> You have a neat and flowing writing style that keeps the reader captivated in your work. Sometimes I'll read something and be impatient for the ending. Not so with your chapter. I did want to read more and I would have been pleased if the chapter did continue a little.

> I liked the dialogue between the Maude and Arthur. I like the names that you've chosen. You write dialogue in a manner that makes the characters sound comfortable with each other and attuned to the other's mood. They are likable characters and by the mere structure of their sentences and the small actions that accompany their speech, they are fleshed out and relatable.

2. What specific points need improvement?
> I don't like Ellie. I'm wondering if she's integral to the plot of if she's just there to fill a void. Would the story be better if Maude is an only child and thus attaches herself to Arthur more thoroughly because of the need to be close to someone? Does this sibling need to exist just to point out the fact that Maude isn't one who makes friends easily and that a little girl is more socially acceptable? I'm sure you can convey this in other means that doesn't leave you with a one-dimensional kid sister who does kid things like kick chairs.

> Teachers don't call home about student friendships unless the friendship is literally something that is tearing apart a classroom. Trust me, I'm a teacher.

> You need an enter space between the father's dialogue and the Minneapolis info dump.

> The info dump. Could you instead wind this through the story? It's at such odds with the rest of the chapter which flows and twists and turns, the info dump is like a road block that forced me to slow down and comprehend a bunch of facts that I didn't actually even care about. Instead, wouldn't it be more interesting if her father spouted this nonsense to her?

"I want you to be safe." He glanced at her quickly, taking his eyes off the road, "Latest news story, you know, they're getting closer to identifying the Murderer Gene."

Maude repressed the urge to scoff.

"It just makes sense - killers breed killers.."

> "I could never win battles against my dad. He stayed too calm" ... this doesn't really sound right to me. He's talking about a theory that is a little dubious. He doesn't sound calm at all, he sounds zealous.

3. What are my concluding thoughts?
> I enjoyed reading this chapter and I'm intrigued about what Arthur's father did and why. I'd also like to know how Arthur feels, being the child of a known murderer. It seems like an issue that is rarely discussed or written about.

I hope this review helped in some way!

All the best,
Jai

Thank you so much for this review; it was incredibly helpful. I'll work on fixing those problem areas, especially the big info dump and the phrasing that doesn't sound right. I've never thought about how the story would work without Ellie- at least not since the plot structure was very different. It's true that her central role for the majority of the novel is just to foil her sister, and as a foil she is a bit one-note. I might be able to transfer her one big moment where she IS central to the plot to a different character. That's a suggestion I'm going to be mulling over for awhile.
Reviews this thorough and knowledgeable are so appreciated.
-tgirly



We are great at fearing the wrong things.
— Hank Green