Heya steam, Pretzel here as promised to review this next part of your series for this lovely October Review Day. I know that many people have praised you for this, but I absolutely know the idea that this whole thing was written based on a dream, because I honestly think that this is so so so amazing.
Anyways, let's get into my points, shall we?
1.- That first sentence though. I loved it for it's child-like simple curiosity, even though things were much more complicated than that what had happened honestly. So in a way, even though I do like the wording, I think that you may have over-simplified things a little bit, to make it seem like she forgot what had just happened???
2.-
“Get a grip on yourself, Kastyn,” I told myself firmly.
I was confused here for a moment, so I practically concluded that I think that you should really italicize this. Just like authors italicize things in people's thoughts, this is an instance where talking to yourself should be italicized to make it more clear.
3.- Torn between taking the baby or leaving it, huh? I honestly thought that this was pretty cliche, because all adventurers have to face this choice. They know that a baby will hinder and be in their way of survival. What makes her want to become a "good Mummy" and take the baby under her wing. To be honest, I was appalled at the way that Kastyn treated the baby. I felt like she has absolutely no sense of how to properly take her of a baby.
She put her on the pavement of the street, left her unattended on the couch for five minutes, and wanted to stuff her in a backpack of a not safe child sling?
Personally, as a child caregiver who is also extremely cautious, I would never ever do any of these things when I was taking care of a baby. It's just safe, so I really see Kastyn as an immature person here. That characteristic/quality really comes out in this part, so for me that cancels out the hero part of actually taking the baby out of the car and such.
4.- I think that it was pretty strange that Kastyn had no emotions described when she saw how much her house had been devastated. Oh yeah, she see it and you described it and all, but how did she feel when she saw this catastrophe of her building. I see another quality in here, maybe it didn't matter to her about her house, maybe she didn't care about a physical place but more about her survival the most. I don't know, but I would really hope that you could make this clear, so that I'm not stuck on the edge of deciding which one it actually is.
5-. I also don't understand why this chapter seems so peaceful and still after an action-packed part before. It just really seems like this a blank space part of the dream, where the MC is just doing busy work, nothing that's actually concrete or adds to the story. I know that other readers and reviewers (like Candy) can disagree and say that a pause is good. But when I actually started reading and reviewing this, I wasn't looking for a pause. I was looking to what going to happen next, and what is the overall condition and situation of this imaginary world that you have created.
6.-
Or was it really a case of technology having turned against us?
This really is a great cliffhanger that I appreciate. There is just one thing that I would wish that you could actually clarify. What time period is this happening in? I assume this is in the future because it's in the dream, or it could be in the present. It seems like the technology is advanced enough or something, because if you machine could destroy everything then... Still, to actually fully understand this sentence, I think hat you should tell us what level or what kind of technology actually existed. If they are familiar things that we can identify with, then great. If they are new and futuristic things that we can use our imagination. I just want to know which one to better understand these questions as to the reason of why/how this happened. Because believe me, I want the answer as much as Kastyn does at this point.
This really makes me want to keep on reading, but I obviously can't because I have a whole list of things that I want to review for Review Day this month. That's ok though, because I promise that I will come back and pick up exactly where I left off, because I am eager to see where this dream of yours was going.
Overall, I really enjoyed this because it made me feel like it was actually my dream inside my head. You have a way with writing that makes people experience it in their heads by using a little bit of imagination. I hope that this review helps, and if you have any questions/comment about it, then you know where to find me.
~Pretzel.
Points: 37216
Reviews: 346
Donate