Chapter One
Holly
I remember the day he left for work, his bag full of paper work, his flask in one hand and his keys in the other. He smiled at us, a different smile to one he would usually give, a smile that had doubt written all over it. Sadly I didn't know it then,I didn't know he wanted out of everything I thought was perfect. I was getting ready to head off to college. I remember putting my peach coloured lip gloss on in the living room mirror, he gave me a kiss on the cheek and wished me a good day. Suicide wasn't written on his agenda for the day, it wasn't on his breath after his lips left my cheek, it wasn't in the room with us. Even my mother didn't know, and she loved him, more than life itself. My mum and dad were the couple you saw on the cheesy dating website adverts, the couple you saw down the street holding hands, even though they were over fifty and had gone through lives struggles. They were happy, I envied them. I didn't know it then, that he was going to crash his car.
I was sat at the desk in class, writing about the importance of dignity when caring for patients, when I felt my phone buzz in my pocket. Not thinking anything of it, I ignored it. It rang and rang and rang, not once did I check to see who was calling. I left it, the call to tell me my whole world would collapse, I didn't even look. Two hours after that class, I looked at my phone, to see thirteen missed calls, six text messages and two voice mails from my mother. We didn't have a good relationship at the best of times, so me ignoring her calls was just another day really. We always argued, I remember that now, it was like we enjoyed it. I can't even write down what she said when I called. It is still so raw and it has been seven years. Yet I still remember it like the back of my hand, like it was yesterday. Just like I'm that seventeen year old student again.
Returning home was the worst. The police were sat with my mum, they were trying their hardest but she was in hysterics. I expected her to be, of course. I couldn't cry, I couldn't scream, I couldn't act in the way any other daughter would. In my gut, deep in my gut, I expected something to happen, not suicide or anything on the same level, but looking back, that morning was odd. I felt strange, seeing everyone gathered in the living room but the one person that held this family together.
Jess, my sister, fifteen at the time, curled up into the sofa sniffling into the cushion. We weren't close either, I didn't like her attitude towards life. She was happy to smoke and drink, and cause havoc in the household. What if she was to blame, I know that's wrong to say, but all the stress she caused. The arguments and frustration, they never knew where she was, or who she was with. They cared too much for someone who didn't care about themselves. Some could call it jealousy, as I grew older I became invisible.
“Holly, please sit down.” my mother requested, pointing to the leather arm chair metres away from me. “I don't want to.” I said with guilt, the last thing I wanted at the time was to cause any more arguments or to make the situation worse, but I didn't want to sit down and cry over him, he chose to leave. She frowned at me, in which I knew it meant to do as I was told. “Sweetie, your father has passed away in an accident, he was on his way..” she cried, holding her head in her hands. Something in me clicked and I ran over to her, holding her, letting her release every emotion she had in her onto the sleeve of my jumper.
“Holly, what time does your break finish?” Sarah asked. She was the head nurse on the ward I was working on. Farndale ward, the best ward in Harrogate Hospital, if I say so myself. All the staff are lovely and the patients are never too unwell when they are admitted. Unwell, but nothing I can't handle. “Now actually, thanks for the heads up” I grinned. Packing away my lunch items, I gave my hair a quick brush and sprayed my favourite perfume onto the collar of my uniform, “Ghost” it had such a light scent not overpowering at all.
“What do you mean she hasn't eaten yet?” I heard this manly voice shout. Leaving the staff room I looked towards reception and set my eyes on this tall, smartly dressed, what seemed to be arrogant man. “She needs to eat, she has diabetes!” he shouted again. I noticed the receptionist, Lisa trying to keep him calm, and asking him to lower his voice. It wasn't working so I stepped in.
“Excuse me Sir, this isn't the place to shout and bellow can you please explain to me what the problem is?” I smiled. “My mother is on this ward, Mrs Rightly?” he bulged his eyes out at me expecting me to know who he was talking about. “Yes, I know she, she hasn't eaten yet as she had to have a scan on her stomach to identify any infections, if she eats before the scan then it jeopardises the camera picking up the full image.” I touched his arm trying to reassure him. “I see, and who are you?” He frowned. Whoever he was, he was becoming more rude by the minute. “I'm Holly, a nurse on this ward.” I smiled, as you do. “Right I see, I apologise for raising my voice, but she needs to eat as soon as she gets back from the scan. Can you make that happen?” he asked. “Yes, of course. If you want to go visit her before she goes down to her scan, you can.” I smiled.
He gave me a little nod, grinned and walked towards his mothers side room.
He was good lucking, but damn he knew it.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
This may be a first draft, but it's very good. There were a ton of really long sentences, though, and I recommend shortening them or separating them. There were a few parts in here that confused me. For instance:
I ran over to her, holding her, letting her release every emotion she had in her onto the sleeve of my jumper.
“Holly, what time does your break finish?” Sarah asked.
I think this transition from scenes would be smoother if you indicated somehow that there was a scene change. Another thing to clarify for the readers would be the ending. Is the character simply stating the man was good looking or is there supposed to be a hint of a future relationship? How does the character know he thinks he is good looking? What does he look like?
I would recommend adding more actions to the dialogue. Does the character nod? Frown? What are the characters doing? Also, maybe a bit of clarification on who is speaking in the ending dialogue. There were a couple spelling errors, like "Good lucking" when I assume you meant "Good looking". Overall, very nice job for a first draft. Edit this a bit, revise a little, and you should be good to go! You're very talented.
Since you said this is just your first draft, I'll start by saying I really like the beginning so far! You've gotten just enough here to get me interested. I'll definitely like to see where your story ends up going!
That being said, I did notice a few technical things you might want to look into as you continue writing. The biggest thing that I noticed (which I sometimes have issues with as well) is that you have a lot of really long sentences. Your comma placement seems to be correct in all of them, but I feel it would read a lot better if you broke some of them down. Something that helps me with this issue is going back through and re-reading my work aloud. It helps to find the more natural flow of your writing and determine better where should be a comma and where should a period.[br]
Another thing I noticed is that you don't separate your dialogue out appropriately. The way I've always been taught, you should start a new paragraph any time a different character is speaking. As well as starting a new paragraph for every new idea, which you seemed to do that for the most part. The dialogue thing just makes it a lot easier to read and also to discern which characters are speaking and when.
There were a few other simple errors as far as forgotten punctuation and misspelled/wrong words. For example on the last sentence you said "good lucking" instead of "good looking". Those are just simple things I'm sure you just over looked since it's only a draft.
Over all though, this is well put together, in my opinion. I am curious to read some more. You can feel free to tag me if you post anything more and I'll be happy to read/review it for you! I hope I was helpful with this review, I'm still getting the hang of it, myself.
Thank you so much for your review! I'm so grateful you took the time to post some feedback onto here! This is my first time asking for feedback from anyone. Looking over my writing and what you have critiqued I have noticed a few errors, thank you for your time again and I will happily tag you in more samples! Xx
Hey there smiler20, and welcome to YWS
If you haven't already, go and introduce yourself in the [url=
viewforum.php?f=1]Welcome Mat[/url] forum! Reviews and feedback are a big deal on this here site too, so while you're waiting for feedback on this chapter you should go and have a look at some stuff people have posted. If you have any questions abou the site or anything, please don't hesitate to post on my wall, privately message me, reply to this comment, or whatever you prefer!
Anywho, I'll get onto this review!
So as a whole, I like what you've got going on here. This kind of plot, genre e.t.c is right up my street, so you've certainly caught my interest! Although we've not seen loads of her as this is just an extract, I like Holly. She seems like a fiery character who's quite closed off, but intriguing. I'd like to know more about her dad (and the rest of her family), but I'm sure that will come with time as the story moves along. In terms of writing style, yours is good: it flows well and it's nice to read. Your writing reminds me a lot of my own writing a few years, actually. Overall, you've got yourself a really neat draft here, one that's oozing with potential.
In regards to critiques, there are one or two things I picked up on throughout this that bothered me a little. I'll start with more of a personal preference because they way you have done it has nothing wrong with it at all, but I kind of want more mystery surrounding the dad's suicide. From the get go we know he committed suicide, and like I said there's nothing technically wrong with that at all, but I personally think it would have more of an impact if we didn't know what was happening straight away. You don't necessarily have to make Holly seem like she has no idea what's happened, but as opposed to saying what her dad did, maybe just hint at it. Let me give you an example...
This is the first instance you tell us her dad killed himself. You've not literally spelled it out, no, but it's obvious to anyone with common sense! What I'd suggest in this example is for you to just cut the line after Sadly I didn't know it then. We still get the idea that this guy's going to kick the bucket, but we don't know it's suicide. Like I said, this is a personal preference thing but I think it would be a great way of approaching this subject in your story.
Oh, I have two minor nit-picks too, why did Holly assume it was suicide after he crashed his car? I mean, most people would have just assumed it was an accident.This may be explained later on, I know, but if it isn't explained you should definitely do so! My other tiny issue is that it seems weird to me Holly wouldn't have looked at her phone. I couldn't ignore my phone at 17 (still can't), I just couldn't! If I was busy/couldn't be bothered I wouldn't answer it, but I couldn't not just have a look... Again, this is probably just me
Another thing that bothered me is Holly's notion that the suicide could've been her sister's fault. She would've been upset and angry, yes, but to suggest something like that is... pretty extreme. I realise she said how she knows she shouldn't think it, but I don't sense feeling of guilt from that. Even if it may have been true, to even think something like that about my sibling would make me feel like such a bad person! It's not so much Holly thinking that I have a problem with, but the fact she was sort of just like yeah, my sister's bad so it could definitely be her fault and leave it at that. Even if you just have her shake her head and shove the thoughts out of there as best she can as she realises what she's accusing her sister of, y'know?
Finally, the guy at the end's behaviour seemed a bit weird to me. He was angry because his mum was diabetic and what not, and that's cool. He calmed down soooooo suddenly, though. The reason she hadn't eaten was obviously very justifiable, and once he realised that I understand he'd chill out a little. It just felt a bit too sudden. One moment he was shouting the roof off and the next he was smiling and thanking people. In fact, seeing a bit more of a struggle for Holly while trying to calm him down wouldn't only be more realistic, but it would add some good character dimensions to both her and the man because right now, he is kind of just some random angry bloke in my mind.
Oh, and one more tiny nit-pick actually! The transition from the dad's suicide to present day is very blunt, and I didn't actually realise at first that 7 years (it was 7 years, right?) had passed... so I was very confused. I'm an easily confusable person, in fairness, but a smoother transition would go down a storm. You don't have to write anything else, simply inserting a symbol (like a # or a * or something similar) can do that wonderfully. It shows us readers that a significant amount of time has passed.
Sorry if this review sounded at all harsh, I did genuinely very much enjoy this extract. I really do think you have something with bucket loads of potential here. Based on the fact Holly's name was at the beginning of this extract, I'm guessing this story will be from several point of views, and if so that's super exciting. I love multiple POV stories! Like I said earlier, I'm intrigued by Holly and her personality is an interesting one, and I'm totally curious about what is going to happen between her and this guy. With a bit of editing here and there, I think this really could become something awesome.
Keep writing,
xoxo Skins
Wow long review!!!
Thank you for your feedback, ever so much! I didn't notice how the suicide would affect my audience, good job you mentioned it! Thank you for your time chick and will tag you in some more samples! Xx
No worries
Great, I look forward to it!