Untitled

Hey! This is my first post on a draft I've written. Feel free to critique or, better yet, go to my website: www.shylanott.webs.com for more of my book's draft and leave any comments there too!

------------------

IF I HAD known I would die in less than one month’s time, I might have done things a little differently. Said a few more I love you’s, gone skiing, maybe an only visit to the Statue of Liberty. But that’s the thing about death; none of us really know when we’re nearing our expiration dates. We’re all meant to check out in one form or another, if it be in a car crash or choking on a Starburst, or everybody’s favorite – natural causes. Nobody goes on living forever and when we get right down to it, death, for most, is a hard verity to digest. Some of us never do. So the question isn’t how or where or even why, but when will we finally keel over? And did we do all that we could with the time we were given? Or was our time wasted converting oxygen into carbon dioxide just that, sucking the oxygen right out of the air like unending vacuums and pushing out a byproduct of CO2 remnants.

Were we just going through the motions: wake up, eat, sleep, and eventually die? Are the lives we lead a complete waste?

It’s true not all of us were roaming the earth waiting for Death to knock at our doors trying to figure out what to make out of life and what to do with ourselves. No, some became scientists, heroes, revolutionaries, artists, and entertainers; and if you were one of the very few who made it that far…congrats.

What about the other ninety-five percent of the population out there suffering to make ends meet? You know the ones without Einstein’s brain or Gandhi’s insight or Michelangelo’s stature.

What about me?

From a medical standpoint, most of the human body is made of six simple elements: carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen, phosphorous, and calcium. Knowing this, it amazes me how the human body works, is able to produce emotion, thought, and feeling from things like carbon and nitrogen and such.

I guess maybe I’m scared of death too. What will happen when I die? Assuming that I get bored easily in church and never ‘talk’ to Him outside of it, my best bet is that I will end up on the straight shot express to Hell Island.

Kidding. I’m sure it’s not an island.

Comments & reviews · 4
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

User avatar
kaitlyn
Review
kaitlyn wrote a review · Sun Dec 11, 2022 3:40 pm

Good Morning/Afternoon/Evening/Night(whichever one it is in your part of the world),

Hi! I'm here to leave a quick review!!

Anyway let's get right to it,

IF I HAD known I would die in less than one month’s time, I might have done things a little differently. Said a few more I love you’s, gone skiing, maybe an only visit to the Statue of Liberty. But that’s the thing about death; none of us really know when we’re nearing our expiration dates. We’re all meant to check out in one form or another, if it be in a car crash or choking on a Starburst, or everybody’s favorite – natural causes. Nobody goes on living forever and when we get right down to it, death, for most, is a hard verity to digest. Some of us never do. So the question isn’t how or where or even why, but when will we finally keel over? And did we do all that we could with the time we were given? Or was our time wasted converting oxygen into carbon dioxide just that, sucking the oxygen right out of the air like unending vacuums and pushing out a byproduct of CO2 remnants.

Were we just going through the motions: wake up, eat, sleep, and eventually die? Are the lives we lead a complete waste?


Well..that's quite the start there. I think you've got quite the powerful piece there, talking about death especially in quite this manner definitely tends to get our attention pretty quickly and pretty powerfully here. I think you've gone and really pulled that off quite nicely, the only thing I'd say is to either try and trim that opening down a little or perhaps split it into smaller paragraphs because it is a bit of a chunk of text at the moment.

It’s true not all of us were roaming the earth waiting for Death to knock at our doors trying to figure out what to make out of life and what to do with ourselves. No, some became scientists, heroes, revolutionaries, artists, and entertainers; and if you were one of the very few who made it that far…congrats.

What about the other ninety-five percent of the population out there suffering to make ends meet? You know the ones without Einstein’s brain or Gandhi’s insight or Michelangelo’s stature.

What about me?


Okayy well this is an interesting point to approach that with. I don't quite know what to feel on that. On one hand this is an interesting little exploration which does makes sense for a person in this position to be having here, but at the same time I feel like going on for quite this long about it with no mention back we've got ourselves to a point where the massive attention grabbing declaration at the start really ends up being almost forgotten in pursuit of a totally different story.

From a medical standpoint, most of the human body is made of six simple elements: carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen, phosphorous, and calcium. Knowing this, it amazes me how the human body works, is able to produce emotion, thought, and feeling from things like carbon and nitrogen and such.

I guess maybe I’m scared of death too. What will happen when I die? Assuming that I get bored easily in church and never ‘talk’ to Him outside of it, my best bet is that I will end up on the straight shot express to Hell Island.

Kidding. I’m sure it’s not an island.


Well I do like the ending though. There's the right balance of dark humor there and exploration of this person's own fears in this situation. I think we've got a strong case there as well, so really I think all we need for this to work to its full potential is for that middle point to have a little more connection to the declaration at the very start there.

Aaaaand that's it for this one.

As always remember to take what you think was helpful and forget the rest.

Stay Safe
Harry

User avatar
railway
Review
railway wrote a review · Thu Jul 02, 2009 4:41 pm

I have decided to review your story, which I enjoy very much, but there were a few things I found with this that I decided to point out to you for future reference which would be useful.

none of us really know when we’re nearing our expiration dates

Near our expiry dates. :B

[quote]Kidding. I’m sure it’s not an island.[/qupte]
For some reason, I don't think the kidding bit is really appropriate. Maybe a 'I doubt it's an island in reality' would fit more?

Plot
Well, as far as I can tell from this small extract, the plot is rather good. All I know is it's about death, but it seems pretty interesting with the whole wondering 'if I'd known I was going to die...' because it makes me wonder what the protagonist actually did before she died.

Characters
Well, this character doesn't seem Mary-Sueish so far. Her P.O.V takes on a nice tone and she seems like a strong character, the normal sort of person perhaps with quirky traits, just like the average person with her own character, so I like it.

Overall, I really like the tone in the writing, how it's not too descriptive but at the same time gives enough information and the casual voice it takes on, as if it's a person really talking about their experiences. Make sure you keep it up, since aside the few errors and the things the people above mentioned, it truly is an excellent piece of writing which leaves me hungry for more. [:

User avatar
lilymoore
Review

Hey there shy! So, I checked out the site first of all and it looks awesome. There’s not much there, but it looks very cool. Anyway, on to the review.

IF I HAD known I would die in less than one month’s time…


So, this is a bit wordy, and as an opening line, there has to be a lot of short, fast, sharp impact. It’s about hooking, grabbing, and pulling. Try shortening it up to: If I had known that I would be dead in less then a month…”

Said a few more I love you’s, gone skiing, maybe an only visit to the Statue of Liberty.


My problem here is that this is an incomplete sentence. Try: “I’d have said a few more “I love you’s,” gone skiing, made a visit to the Statue of Liberty.”

…and feeling from things like carbon and nitrogen and such.


I’ve got an issue with the bolded portion for a reason and that’s because of your use of the words ‘and such.’ It’s sloppy and can show a lack of creativity. Obviously listing all six of the elements again would just appear repetitive so why not just replace the bolded portion with: “those six simple substances.” (I’m a geek for alliteration. ^^)

Overall, this isn’t bad and I like the way you executed the one-on-one tone of writing. Other then that I don’t have much else to say.

Any questions or comments, just send me a PM.

~lilymoore



Why should Caesar just get to stomp around like a giant while the rest of us try not to get smushed under his big feet? Brutus is just as cute as Caesar, right? Brutus is just as smart as Caesar, people totally like Brutus just as much as they like Caesar, and when did it become okay for one person to be the boss of everybody because that's not what Rome is about! We should totally just stab Caesar!
— Gretchen Wieners