Young Writers Society

At least I'm getting there.

I agree with snoink, and I also think your poetry is improving noticably - it's really great the way you take people's suggestions and constructive criticism and work with it. My own suggestion for this poem would be to enhance the parts of the poem where you're describing the campfire - those were the bits that were the most powerful, I thought, but they lacked reality a little. They seemed almost too perfect to be real. At the campfires and bonfires my family has, everyone isn't always smiling, we're usually teasing someone about something, someone is typically wandering around in the dark bumping into things looking for a marshmallow stick, my pessimistic uncle is probably reminding us that it'll rain tonight and we should pack up soon, and while we do lots of singing, especially when my sister brings her violin and my dad's got his guitar, it rarely happens that we all sit around clapping to the beat, since someone's goofing off and my grandpa is tone deaf and my cousin and aunt can't sing worth beans, or even clap a simple rhythm. More specific details would paint for us a less generic picture, and I think that would lend emphasis to your poem.


^^^Sorry that's so long, I got a little distracted from the point...

I'll try that next time, thanks.

Don't be so preachy. This is just reeking of "I'm going to tell you how you should feel and how you should look at life." For poetry, this is a big no-no. Instead of telling us what you want to say, tell us what reminds you of what you want to say. If the image, memory, smell, sense, etc., is strong enough, we'll get the hint without you pounding a sledge hammer on our heads, as you're doing now.