Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hi! This is quite a nice poem.
Overall: You write some very pretty images in very short lines, so they're almost like fleeting implications. Which I really like! I do wish that you had included something less conventional about this girl's beauty. The words you use evoke a pretty classical view of physical beauty; grace, delicacy, nice skin and hair. I like the way you use those images, but I would also like to know what sets her apart from them.
Title: I like it. It's like a reversal of Snow White, which is cool because that's a folktale about a beautiful girl. So using the same words kind of calls up the image of Snow White, but switching them sets apart your subject with the fairytale.
Stanza 1: Great! I like the sand simile, it's quite unconventional, but effective. xD Which is of course, the best kind. I'm not a huge fan of the "more than I can stand" but it's alright.
Stanza 2: My favorite. I like how the narrator admits that his perception/description of the girl is faulty, and the last line was unexpected. I like it.
Stanza 3: It's good that you change the first line here from the first line of the poem. I like the bird simile to show her delicacy, but "I won't let go" reads kind of awkwardly. The same goes for "for this reason, I was born".
Stanza 4: I love the first line. The second is alright, but a little confusing, because does it imply that the narrator only sees her beauty during those times? I also love the third, it's a strong image from so few words, and a beautiful one. And the last ties it together nicely.
Hey Phantom!
That's a nice poem you've got here. ^^ It's kind of different, comparing a girl to snow. The only weird thing was that, you called the poem "WHITE snow". The thing is, when you say "snow", it already appears white in the image the reader thinks. Which is what made it more confusing, but never mind! =)
Now, let's first move onto the formatting of the poem since, I'm supposed to be reviewing the poem in publishing basis. What was wrong is that, you don't really have to capitalize every letter of a new line. Its not really necessary. I know, in textbooks and all, it comes like that but it is mainly because of the program they print through or something of that sort. But since, I see no punctuation (i.e; comma's or full-stops), it's okay.
Secondly, on to the nitpicks. What I felt is that, I think you kind of lacked some flow there. Sometimes, its smooth but in the middle, it's like a break and then again it comes back. But I like how you made the stanza's number of lines even. 4 in the first, 5 in the followed by stanza and again 4 at the last! ^^ Though, I think it would be nice if you would have rhymed the whole thing together instead of tiny bits there and here.
Now here:
I don't think you need "She" after "snow". It looked a little disturbing. :3 And plus, after "prickling thorns", I think you missed a beat there or something? Like, the flow. It lacked. :S
Overall: I loved the poem! I wouldn't say it was bad. It was good. 8D Just need to work on the things I told you. But I loved the way you relate snow to the girl. It's quite a scene when you imagine it. Its wonderful actually.
Keep Writing ~
Cookie
Beautiful, amazing poem, Phantom. I love it!
My favorite thing about this poem is the image it forms in my mind.
When I read this, I see snow gathering around, forming, a girl. It's just what I see, it's most likely everyone sees it different.
Also, when you mention you see a girl pure what as snow, I think of a person with only good in there soul. Referencing that her soul is pure white as snow.
I like how the last two lines rhyme extremely well together, but the third and second lines don't go well together. I think they don't do this poem justice, truly.
~~~
I love how you composed this poem, and all I see is a few minor rough spots in your rhyming. Very well done, Phantom, very well done.
~Rainn