The Not-Very-Marvelous Fantastic Adventure of Tilly Tharp
A Note From the Author
You will find me a really weird child as you read this, I'm afraid. You see, I was not like other children then, when I went through this rather odd tale, nor am I like ordinary teenagers now. Writing is something I have come to only in the past year, although I very much enjoyed a book when I was younger. I'm sorry to say that you may not only find me bizarre, but perhaps even rather lacking in my writing, and this tale I have to tell not marvelous, not life-changing, but quite fantastic. A few years have passed between now and then, but I shall write to you, dear reader, as if it were in the present. I wish it were in the present. I shall also assure you that it is fully safe and secure and fine that I am writing this novel, because no one will come to danger for it. The whole of them have agreed that I may write this now, now that things are done.
Tilly Tharp
I
“Did you feed the cats?” Mother, the woman, is peering over the rotted recliner with her bulging eyes.
“I did. Three hours ago.”
“Then why is Sarge at the door?” Her lips are a thin dry fault line sinking into her face.
“Because, you’re eating Haagen-Dazs,” I say. The woman doesn’t quite get things. It occurs quite frequently and it is quite frustrating, but I am quite silent on the matter.
Sigmund walks in half-naked, shoving his fingers into his eyes to get the sleepies, like most seven-year-olds do when it’s one on a Saturday afternoon. I hand him the remote and walk outside. Sarge, the fat one, puts his paws up on my knees and stretches his rubber tummy. Then Rosa and Klein waddle over, the fraternal twins, and meow incessantly, because their cookie-sheet food trough is empty and I didn’t fill it three hours ago. As quietly as plausible, my knobby toes pat over to the shed, hands carry the fifty-pound bag, and arms cascade the brown nuggets into the pan.
“I hear that,” says the woman. She’s sucking on a cigarette now and Siggy’s coughing.
I head back inside, slip on sneakers and the burgundy sweater, because October is just setting in and the wind smells like wood fire but makes you shiver. The man, Father, is out working in the green shed to the east of our twenty-acre farm, and I tell him I’m going adventuring. He nods and stumbles back into the shed, whistling a heart-sick country ballad. I head south. South, past the vacant corn field and into the clearing of brown grass there. Klein, Matthieu, and Rosa are hurriedly bouncing after me. They hadn’t seen at first where I was headed, but they should’ve known already.
“Let’s go to the Tillpond,” I say. Klein catches up and chatters through the long knotted fur draping over his mouth.
I’m not the one who came up with the name, for the pond that is. That was Rhema. She’s off in college now, but when she was still here, she called it Tillpond because I was the one who gave the place the most attention, really all the attention it got. There aren’t fish anymore, but there weren’t fish when I started coming out here either. The man, Father, said there were fish when he was a kid growing up here. Bluegills mostly. It’s just a five minute hike up the hill from the farm, past a little creek that leads to another bigger pond, but I like this one the best. It’s at the top of the hills, the very low patchy hills you get in central Kansas, and from there you can see all the way to the city and over to the little town too, and to the Rohm’s farm. I like it because up there the wind is really strong and it kind of sounds like what I imagine the fall of a bomb would sound like.
Rosa, black fur that’s short and stiff, is climbing up the crooked tree over to the side. She’s struggling and making noises that interrupt the sound of the wind. “Shh!” I tell her and fall down on the mossy rock with my book. At first, I don’t open it. When I get up here, I like to take a moment to close my eyes and smell the autumn and the wild grass. I like to take in a few deep inhales and let my chest expand, and I like to think of places. Sometimes they are places I’ve seen before, sometimes they are entirely distant or entirely made up.
I started coming out here when I was six, just after I started school. I remember because I was so upset the Howe boy had taken my first kindergarten carton of chocolate milk. I was infuriated. The woman and the man and baby Siggy were in the city and Rhema was supposed to be watching me, but she was painting and she didn’t notice when I slipped out of the house. For hours I meandered around the hilly grasslands, the clusters of trees, the abandoned shack. I came out to the pond last, when it was almost dusk, and watched the little birds settle onto the branches of the trees and bubbles surface onto the top of the vacant pond. Somehow, being out here remedied the lost chocolate milk. Everything was resolved; from then on the land became my shaman.
Usually I bring out Doyle or one of the Brontës (I prefer British literature when reading), but this time it’s Buck, an American who wrote about China. Klein nestles into my lap, and I begin reading aloud to him as he purrs and kneads my foot.
I’m on page twenty-seven when Rosa has a conniption. She flies out of the nearby tree and lands on her feet with a cringe. My eyes look up to the swaying branches, not concerned in the least and expecting nothing. Nothing happens.
“Rosa, I swear you have a nervous condition. Come hear and listen to Pearl talk about Chinese farmers.”
She pounces over. I resume.
Page twenty-eight. Out of the corner of my eye, I see a sliver of orange and charcoal crash to the ground from the tree. It’s a gray fox, a kit, and it stands up with a waver, disoriented from the fall.
“Well hello there, Kit,” I call over. Honestly, I’d never seen him before, don’t see many foxes here. “Come for story time?”
He stands up straight at my voice and bolts off into the brush. I decide, it is time to go adventuring. I drop the book and scramble after him. The sun’s behind me as I sprint through the weeds and scratchy grass, and Klein and Rosa and Sarge are lounging back at Tillpond. But then I lose Kit. I stand there (I’m in the eastern trees now), breathing a little heavily and scratching my stomach under the burgundy sweater that the woman’s mother gave me for my eleventh birthday. I start to lose hope and then I hear a hiss and a coo and a growl from Kit. I’m certain it’s from him, because it’s no sound the cats would ever make.
I follow the sound. Hissing has turned to a sniffing motivated by curiosity. There he is. He’s just beyond the decaying oak Rhema used to climb before it snapped in two. He’s got his nose buried in a bed of slowly dying dandelions (because it’s October, but you remembered that, didn’t you reader?), and his tail is sticking straight up. I creep up, ever silently, like a fox, until I’m just a few feet behind him. I’m leaning in to touch my fingers to his fur and give him a good old pet when he vanishes.
It’s not really vanishing. Really, it’s a sort of snapping, popping, swooping. One second he’s there, the next he’s POP gone. I was real close to him when it happened, and out of surprise, I fall forward and my hand touches the dandelions. It’s peculiar. At first, they feel a bit warm and gooey and their color seems to change. Then, POP, I’m gone.
It’s a curious feeling, crossing over, because really, in that transitional stage, your body occupies two spaces at once and much in the same, but not the same. I didn’t know, of course, what was going on at the time. Excuse me, what is going on. I apologize, reader, I am a horrible writer, switching tenses. Anyways—
I’m here and I’m not quite sure what is going. My head is pounding and the tips of my fingers are sore and my vision is switching between double and triple for a minute. I can smell something, a curious smell I am not familiar with, and I strain my neck to peer around as my vision clears.
I’m in the eastern woods. Kit is over to the side of me, rolling around on his back in the dandelions and cooing like an infant. He’s hysterical. Perhaps he’s trying to get back, or perhaps he hasn’t even noticed a change and is simply relishing the dandelions. The purple dandelions. Are foxes colorblind? I stand up, still whoozy, and head out of the trees toward what I assume I know to be the clearing by Tillpond. I emerge and there is Tillpond, but Klein, Rosa, and Sarge are missing. I look around, and that smell persists. As of yet, I cannot define it. I trudge through the grass and into the sun. I throw up my chin and gaze at it. It’s odd, isn’t it? The round orb up just a little to the West is not really glowing like it should. My eyes aren’t burning from staring at it. It also has an underlayer of purple beneath the pale yellow. And wait, that’s not the West. Why is the sun leaning toward the East? It’s the afternoon, but I know that is the East, because I could never mistake directions in my own lands.
“Rosa? Klein! Sarge!” I yell out, staring down the undulating field of weeds. Nothing.
Oh, there! I see a mat of coarse brown and gray fur topped with cream. That’s Sarge! I run over to him. He’s halfway into a hole digging around for something, so I grab him to pull him out and give him a great old hug. And although he’s a fat cat, I know he’s not this heavy, but I still heave and huff until he comes out of that hole.
“In Damadei‘s nahm! Wit are you dun?”
I screech and drop the thing. He lands with a thud. He’s cursing in intangible words and phrases that are obviously derogatory but said in such a slow, drolling tone I start laughing.
“It you laff for mey?” The thing stands up on its two barrel-like legs and lets out a howl.
“You’re intriguing,” I say, reaching out to touch the fur.
He recoils and curses again. And then he’s backing away, heading toward the pond.
“Can I call you Tim, sir? Or how about Alfred. That’s better.”
He’s running toward Tillpond.
A/N: An awkward place to end this part, but I couldn't find a better one without going a few more pages in. This is a novel I began rather late and hurriedly for NaNoWriMo, and didn't come close to finishing on time. It is a practice in many things, and very unpolished, so I'd love your honest critique. Also, I am not Tilly Tharp. She is simply the fictional author of this fictional piece, something done by other contemporary authors, especially the wonderful Linda Barry. I will post more soon. Thanks :)
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hi there!
I noticed part of your novel is waiting to be reviewed so I came to the start to get a better feel for the story and the characters! I like what you have here; Tilly is really easy to read and to run along with. I know you have other comments, but I’m not going to read them until after I review, so I apologise if I cover things they've already covered!
While Tilly is an interesting character and narrator, the initial author’s note is incredibly distracting and really rather frustrating. I think I found it so because Tilly’s story is much more interesting without it, and without the little additions breaking the fourth wall. The fourth wall thing is pretty cool sometimes, but I think it takes away from your story because we’re moving at a pretty constant pace and then bam: awkward interjection. This will mean you need to alter that slip up of tense as well though.
The use of “The woman/Man/baby” is interesting but I hope you clarify why that’s happening. Perhaps because she feels disconnected from them? I’m not sure how I feel about it as a technique except that it is interesting. I like that she lied to her mum, as many children to, although I feel like considering it was a lie, her saying her mum is slow is a bit random? Or not justified.
The issue with first person present tense is that it becomes incredibly awkward sometimes. Some of your phrasing is awkward because of this. “and then he’s backing away” and such become really clunky in the action of a piece, and I’m not sure what you’re going to do when you hit some real, gritty action, although I’m not sure that will happen in your story anyway! Which isn't to say change the form of this story, because right now it’s working and we get an excellent for Tilly and her thoughts and how she views the world. Although her reaction to a talking animal is so weird I don’t even. Does she not even care that the creature is talking to her? I like that you typed the accent here also, because it just gives an excellent impression.
As I said, I like this story. I think you’ve got a good sense of where the story is going and you have a strong character. Your writing supports this, despite my little qualms, and I think that you have a pretty good system going. If you change this please hit me up, I’d love to see.
I look forward to the next part! Hit me up if you have any questions or queries or anything.
~ Pen.
Hi Naturegirl!
I’m Shear, I’ll be reviewing this piece. I like to go by segments so bear with me.
Writing:
Obviously, I enjoyed your writing style. There is something nostalgic about it and reminds me of my childhood days. Your descriptions are quite good and like Isha mentioned, I have a really hard time believing this is from a NaNo! Unless you edited it before you submitted it but still, it’s very nicely written.
I don’t have much to say about your grammar or punctuation, you seem to know where to place your commas and everything so there’s no point going into detail about that. I'm not going to pick out every comma and check to see if it's in it's right place, lol.
As for the topic of dragging, I don’t think it did drag very much. I think there were places where you could’ve added some more description to create an easily imaginable image for the reader instead of trying to be so vague and creative in the beginning. There were some parts where I was questioning who was who and what was a cat and what was a human if you know what I mean.
One of the things I do want to point out is the fact that you broke from the narrative with the voice of the writer and inserted little comments like “I apologize, reader, I am a horrible writer, switching tenses. Anyways-“ and I wasn’t exactly a big fan of this. Not saying you can’t do it but to me, it didn’t really add anything to the story and seemed to pointlessly break the reader from the flow you created. You can keep the author’s note in the beginning but breaking from the story in the middle seems unnecessary.
Characters:
As for the character, I can’t really say much about Tilly yet. Though I was questioning the gender? Was Tilly a boy or a girl? I know Tilly is girl because you said so in the end note but throughout my reading, I thought Tilly was a little boy and then I was confused again when you mentioned Rhema and how she named the pond Millpond for her and then I was confused about Tilly's age when you said Rhema was in college - was that in the present time, when Tilly is writing the story or during the past? I think this (Millpond) was a typo because the character’s name is Tilly and you’ve been calling it Tillpond so you might want to clarify that a little.
Story:
I agree that you broke the story off an awkward place. It seemed to be right in the middle of a conversation between some magical creature or his imagination(?). Don’t be afraid to add another paragraph into the mix if you feel it will help the reader settle down and not feel like someone shut off the TV while they were watching something.
Also, I get a very Alice in Wonderland feel/ Spiderwick Chronicles feel from this when I read the ending so I’m thinking that’s the sort of direction you’re going in -but it’s still early to tell. I haven't heard of Linda Barry but I'm guessing she does this similar style of writing?
Overall, I like this so far and you have some great aspects about your writing. Keep up the good work and holler if you have any questions.
All the best,
-S
Hey, Natures! Isha here to review. c:
Ooooh, now that was an interesting little read. Your narrator's (Tilly, her name is) voice was excellent. Your description was excellent, maybe a tad overbearing in some parts closer to the beginning, but it's rare and unnecessary to point out. Give it a quick scan, and I'm sure you'll find where I'm talking about.
Are you totally sure that this is a NaNo novel? Because it reads a heck of a lot better than a NaNo novel would. xD I'm quite impressed.
Now, I'm going to have to say that I disagree with Lycando when it's said that your beginning dragged on for too long. Had it hadn't been as well-written as it was, then yes, it probably would have, but it was well-written, and therefore, I found it enjoyable. It was a good introduction, a good way to ease into your characters' consciousness. I dislike it when people say that you should also start with action and excitement, and then proceed to introduce the, well, character of your character to the reader as time goes on. If it's well-executed, then by all means, take a page or two to give us a good feel of a setting, and of, at the very least, the first layer or two of your character (don't reveal everything at once, of course, because that is the worst kind of beginning. Characters are meant to be dissected and figured out over a time, not all at once. Or, at least, in novels and in my opinion).
So no, I did not find the beginning to drag on for too long. In fact, the only real problem I had with the piece was that you did flip your tenses around. I don't know, maybe someone else will like that, but I really didn't. It seemed like you'd messed up, and then through in the:
just to escape having to fix it up. Which might not have been the case, but that's what it felt like. I don't have a preference where tenses are concerned, I just prefer that if the story is happening within the same timeline,- if you don't flip between "now" and "back then"- that the tenses stay the same throughout.
And that's just my two cents.
Anyway.
Feel free to PM me with any questions!
Good job and keep writing,
-Isha.
Alright so after reading this, I have to say I'm pretty intrigued by this piece. It's unique on it's own, with the narration from the character being very descriptive and also addressing her parents as the Man, and the Woman. I find that to be interesting.

One thing about this story that I feel could be improved is the beginning. It's too long and also uninteresting. I would rather you shorten that part and skip straight to going to the lake. Also while at the lake, talk more about it, describe the waters, the plants, if there are any. Also describe the weather outside. Since you're out of the house the weather should have changed right?
After the dandelion part, it seems that things have changed. Take a while to describe those changes. During the process itself Tilly feels strange things happening to her body. But what after that? Any changes? It can give a reader a clue to what happened. Did she grow bigger, or were there marks left on her body?
At the last part, there was the part when she was trying to rescue one of her pets, Sarge. But then again, it turns out not to be him, but instead another creature that talks. But the way Tilly reacts to the new creature is very unexpected. Instead of being freaked out by this new alien creature in front of her, she treats it like a friend. I would suppose she would be more wary of the creature, especially when he curses at her and weighs quite a bit.
I do agree with you, it's an awkward place to end, the way the sentence was written makes it even more awkward. If you really would want to end that way. Rephrase the sentence as such.
"He gave no hint of recognition for that name, but instead sprinted towards Tillpond, his tail bouncing after him"
Still it seems a little abrupt a stop, so if you could write a few more sentences to conclude this chapter properly it would be better.
Hope my review helped!