Deleted

PreviousNext

Deleted

Comments & reviews · 4
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

User avatar
Kale
Review
Kale wrote a review · Sun Dec 30, 2012 6:20 pm

Hello there naturesgirl! I, Kyllorac, will be reviewing you today on this very fine Review Day.

With that said, onto the review!

I had thought about reconnecting with Haiden after Wes and I sort of ended. We hadn’t talked in almost three years. Haiden and I had gone out a few months, and we had been friends after that, but then I found Wes. I didn’t have to try and contact him back in August; he texted me two days after the first break-up. I didn’t really want to hang out with him again but I did.

There are too many pronouns in this paragraph, and on first read-through, it read like Wes was the one contacting Constance instead of Haiden. This might also benefit from a paragraph break at the "I didn't have to..." sentence, since finding Wes and being contacted by Haiden has a whole relationship worth of time passing in between.

I left my Oyster card (prepaid card you can use for buses, the Tube, etc.) at home

The parentheticals really killed the flow of the piece, and they're quite unnecessary. I'd recommend killing them entirely and just leaving the Oyster card as it is, without explanation. It's not that difficult to infer what an Oyster card is for based on the text, and it's really not so important to the story what an Oyster card is so much as Constance doesn't have it with her.

I should probably head back now. It’s gotten dark and I haven’t arrived anywhere.

The tense shift here was very sudden and felt forced, which made it stick out like a sore thumb, especially since the other shifts were so smoothly executed. I'd recommend cutting out these two lines and maybe working in the details later on. The being lost in the present would really tie in with the being lost in the past, and so make the transition smoother.

That said, overall, this was an excellent piece. You really did a good job in relaying Constance's emotions and listlessness and general dissatisfaction with everything without falling into the dark pit of navel gazing. I also particularly enjoyed the descriptions of art in this, particularly her frustration in creating and the description of the painting. Everything was wonderfully concrete and real.

Random avatar
jefferyffe
Review

I absolutely loved the build up of tension when she's looking at the painting. I could feel the tension which is wonderful, of course. I also found myself rooting for your character. I wanted her to come to an epiphany of things.

I didn't like the ending. I don't want her to get back with Wes, nor do I want her with Haiden. I want her to be on her own in Grad school by the last paragraph reflecting existentially on the changes in her life and how she's awesome at art.

This is my only craft complaint: "...I breathe a breath of grimy, open air." It's redundant.

Overall, wonderful absolutely wonderful. Even not knowing anything about London, I felt as if I could be watch this in my mind. Very good job! :)

User avatar
StoryWeaver13
Comment

I'm sorry, I really don't have time to review this. It doesn't need one anyway.

Beautiful.

***side-note: I *did* in fact have time to read this all, but don't have time to analyse right now. I'll try to get back to this soon. Best wishes!



Let yourself be silently drawn by the strange pull of what you really love. It will not lead you astray.
— Rumi