Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Well, truth be said I don't really have a burning inspiration for the short juvenile novellas, I'm rather doing it a bit mechanically, on autopilot. But I've meditated, I've outlined my deficiencies, inclinations and possible genre potentials, and am working on various projects, even if my heart isn't a 100% in all of them. I see it as an investment
. And that means I gotta write juvenile novellas, fantasy and sci-fi adventures, small town and big town horror scenarios, conspiracy thrillers and postmodernist transgressive texts, fairy tales and mystery stories, until little by little experience is accumulated and I stop feeling helpess in the face of the empty page. Or maybe that never goes away, time will tell, hehe.
Mastering the simple cliches of various genres in the end must be a good way of gathering experience. In order to compose a covincing heavy metal or rock song one must first learn the elementary rules of the Blues, etc.
...I want to become a top notch author by 2014. Better of course by 2011, but that's kinda unrealistic
...So I guess y'all feel the lack of a 100% inspiration in the story. But! As you know I place value on the internal logic of a narrative, and once this one is done you'll see that the elements of the story are not randomly collected, they do tie in together, and they are plausable. Once disbelief is suspended that is.
Hey, man. Yeah, like Gryphon said, it is highly unlikely that a mere dozen people could bring a foreign planet to life. It worked for the Bible. First Adam and Eve, and then Noah and his family. But in today's society, something like that is scoffed at. Moving on,
What exactly does a sheepish grin look like? And what prompted you to use such a hazy description? Normally you find genius ways to give life to your text, but that one word that describes a grin creasing over a person's lips is just mediocre.
I don't have much to say about the rest of your story really, other than finding the protagonists thoughts of the girls bodies annoying. Darn horny teenagers, they're so cliched. Stephen King himself, has over-done it.
Oh yeah, how exactly are the people going to build shelters? Did they bring a bunch of materials along? Does the planet have the necessary resources? All of it is left in smoke.
Thanx for the review, Seeminglymeaningless,
everything /more or less/ I think I'll be able to set straight as I really do finish this novella, but the style jump... well... In the beginning the style reflects a persona that travels in the /inner/space, and then as the MC wakes up and returns to his limited self, so does the style degenerate correspondingly. 'But why didn't you come up with a concept which wouldn't entail a degeneration of the style, Napalmerski?' Thank you for this question, nameless guy, and a good question it is. Mayhaps in the near future I will plot a story where the narrative style is more outlandish.
'Humanity awaits this offering with it's breath held, Napalmerski.'
Now, now, I am but a scribbler, no need for all the flowers, just throw the money at me. Anyway, there's a novel in the offing, 'Son of Nothing', it'll be fit to put into the 'advanced critiques' section in a month, maybe less. I think. And in this novel, one third of which will be third-person, and the other two thirds - two different POV's - there the style will again jump abruptly, but none of the three /four/ styles will be on the level of ole honorable Stine.
Hey
Comments in red.
All in all, a very interesting read. Would love to read about the backstory to this expedition, but I don't see why teenagers are involved in this. If they grew up on the voyage, like their parents were specialists and then they were brought up to fill out the specializations that were missing, then that would excuse his, perhaps, unprofessional thoughts. But because these teenagers were, what seems as if handpicked, then they should be of the utmost seriousness about their mission.
That's all I've got
I like it, I would like to read more.
- Jai
Ooh, aah, eeh, Griffinkeeper
Good points all, logical.
They only have resources for ships this size, they move along in a generational pace: send the first batch, when in twenty two years they receive confirmation by DMRadio that they are there and alive and cannibalizing their ship, they send the second batch. The second batch are mostly youths, in order to give a power+baby boost to the colony which they will find, which in theory should have doubled itself by this time. There is a slight gender imbalance in the numbers to offset the genetical inclination to have more babies in the other direction. Although they are just a few people, they have with them genetical material from thousands of types, to keep the local genepool from stagnating once everyone has put his/her heritage into circulation.
By plan this info dribbles down between the horniness in the second, third and fourth chapters.So there
The plot goes like this and not about massive terrafrming efforts with huge ships and thousands of people because I'm still a 'low budget' writer, I can't handle props that big. Or that genre. I can only use elements of it in a more straightforward, onesided adventure. Maybe in half a year or a year of writing I'll be able to do solemn star-spanning epics, but not yet, certainly not yet.
Let me get this straight:
"The story is about a horny young man, who after spending twenty two years in cryo, gets to start a colony with eleven other people, five of which are young women."
...
Let's talk about logistics.
1. Colony ships are expensive. The cryo equipment, a DMD, plus all the equipment needed to start a colony. That's very expensive stuff. Extremely expensive. All that, just so twelve people can colonize a planet. It hardly seems worth the effort. Usually people depict colony ships as carrying people by the hundreds, if not thousands. Because taming a planet is not an easy job. Because you need a lot of different skills.
2. About skills. Is there anyone there who is capable of actually building anything? They have two psychologists (god knows why, there is nothing to analyze during cryo, and they'd just get on each others nerves once they get on planet) but there are no carpenters, no civil engineers, no electricians or plumbers. You've got people that can genetically modify crops, but couldn't plow a field!
If there is one thing a colony needs, it's infrastructure. They'll want people that can actually build things, not psychoanalysts. I think this needs to be better thought out.