Heya sugar. I promised to come and review your newest LMS project/novel and here I am, this October Review Day starting from the beginning, or Chapter 1. I will try my best to not repeat anyone that is under me, so that you get a wide-spread advice/feedback.
After reading this over 2 times, here are my notes in order from the beginning to the end.
1.- I think that the first paragraph “sets the scene” in an objective way, from the perspective of what Belon saw in the room. And that’s excellent because sometimes you just need those from the outside in perspectives.
2.-The thing that kind of broke a rule of thumb for my personally was your first sentence. I generally try to stay away from “weather” related sentences as hooks, because you don't want to begin in a monotonous tone about the temp. of the room, even if this good be the first feeling that the character gets when entering in. Although it is relevant, I would recommend that you introduce this coldish feeling a little bit later on in the scene. Work on strengthening your hook, because those are sometimes, first hooks, because you don't want to begin in a monotonous tone about the temp. of the room, even if this good be the first feeling that the character gets when entering in. Although it is relevant, I would recommend that you introduce this coldish feeling a little bit later on in the scene. Work on strengthening your hook, because sometimes, especially in the first chapter, this is essential.
3.-Okay, so I identified two conflicting emotions or themes in the first paragraph alone. First the father seems peaceful, and then the author displays him in a state of deteriorating mindset. I don't think that the emotions had enough flow, because it seems to me like you jumped from one to the other. At first, it's all broken and deteriorating, and then the King looks peaceful, until he hears his son's voice. And then his depression and state of deterioration comes out again. So there are mood swings, which is perfectly normal in a person, and you obviously can't control them in a person. But I'm sure that you could control this one in this particular scene,right??
4.-Next thing, is that I was pretty surprised that Belon still wanted to hold his reputation up. Wasn't he tired of hiding it or whatever? I was surprised about the reputation part, because you gave us no clues or hints that this was a King. I would never have guessed that he was a ruler, judging by his outlandish behaviour, I just thought that he acted like some freak. I would really work on quietly integrating some small things that would point the reader to this conclusion and direction; like I know you can do. I have seen you scatter hints before, and I know that you can do this in this special first chapter.
5.-Next thing, I wanted to compliment your sense of timing and give you my personal opinion on the introduction at the end of the flashback scene in italics. That introduction of the MC names and who he really is was so reveal-ant and in the perfect spot in my opinion. Formal intros in the first paragraph always bore me a bit, but at the end they always seem suitable. The reason why? Because I want to know more about the newly-introduced character, so that I could identify him better.
6.-Between those two separate scenes, I don't think one dot between two characters is enough. In fact, it seemed kind of ridiculous because I thought that you were introducing two separate character. The flow of that really seemed off, and when I read the first sentence of the second part I made a "whoa, what's happening here" kind of reaction to change. And you don't really want that reaction in a readers mind. So I would recommend bring it back from the past to the present in a graceful manner. So whatever memories Belon had from before, in the 2nd scene could start with him trying to concentrate on this difficult journey that he is facing and such. I believe that's a pretty important part here honestly.
7.-
he had stared at clouds as a boy and thought them painted onto the sky, so beautiful they couldn’t possibly be real. He had the uncanny feeling that he was part the painting too.
This is my favorite line out of this whole chapter, and I think that it is worthy of apprise here sugar. I adore the idea of the clouds in the sky being painted and that he was a part of the painting. Simply lovely, so I just thought that I would throw that out there.
8.
There were three obvious camps, and an empty place for his own party.
I just thought that it would be worth asking, what is the significance of describing the three camps in such detail in this paragraph. While, I do love your description sugar, and you should know this too, I think that this is a bit overdone. Why do we need to really know how each of the three tents looked like? Is it that important to actually develop this plotline?
9.-And lastly, I know that other reviewers have told you this as well, and given you some examples. And I honestly and really do hope that you are aware of this: Most of your sentences are too long. Even though they are lovely in prose, they can get tiring for the reader to read them. Don't worry though, I used to have this same problem, and I fixed it, although it's not an easy fix, because you have to catch yourself everytime and practice. (just like with the spaces in between sentences.)
10.-Here is just one nitpick/example:(also Pomp gave the longest sentence in their review)
The room was dim with early dawn, and there, standing where a shattered window had once been, was my father, silhouetted by the sliver of sun over the horizon.
I would divide it up a little bit, because since this is in your first paragraph, your new reader could be discouraged. Here is how I would break up the independent clauses.
Pretzelstick wrote:The room was dim with early dawn. There, standing where a shattered window had once been, was my father, silhouetted by the sliver of sun over the horizon.
Side Note: I also thing that the period makes the next sentence( the first appearance of his father) way more dramatic. But maybe that's just me.
Overall, your novel here is off to a great start and I am so encouraged by your persistence in writing. I believe in you, and I know that with determination and practice, you could surely learn to write "shorter" sentences, whatever that would mean to you.
I hope that this review really helps you, and if you have any questions regarding it, you know where to find me.
~Pretzel
Points: 37216
Reviews: 346
Donate