Hi mcar, comrie here and I'm gonna write up a review
I think you have a nice idea here. Unity among the people against one common threat. I liked that a lot.
I understand that the Taoist man was not liked, but that is all I know about him. Does he have a family? Is he a newcomer to the town? What did the rest of the town believe in? I get that this being a short story, you probably didn't want to add too much information because it might spiral into something bigger, but I think adding little bits of information of the Taoist man in regards to his character, his personal life would help readers be more connected to him. Just sprinkle bits and pieces on who he was would be helpful. Right now, I only know him as the Taoist man and the stuff you're telling me he is, not really showing. Use the senses! The environment around him! Use it all to your advantage.
And the man in charge of the town -- I'd personally like to know more about him. I know he's not the center of the story, but for now, I just see him as a man. What was he like before? Was he always power-hungry? How did he even get to power? These are questions I kept asking myself when reading this. You don't have to answer these questions in your story just to accommodate me but I think you should consider questions *like* these when you write any story. Ask yourself, "What else is there to this person/place?" and go from there.
When the Taoist man went to gather them (after the war), why did they not resist? Didn't they not like him? Did something happen during the war that made them like him better? If something did, I think you should add that here. I just couldn't believe that they would considering their thoughts/behavior toward him before the war. Did the Taoist man do something to save them during the war? Insert that information here.
I did find some problems in grammar, and I'll go ahead and point them out to you along with suggestions on how you could go about fixing them It's up to you if you want to or not!
The thing that was special about this man is that he lived in a town full of very hostile and aggressive people, so he was the only Taoist in that town.
There's something awkward about this sentence every time I read over it. I think you should probably separate this into two separate sentences. Maybe: The special thing about this man was that, in a town filled with hostile and aggressive people, he was the only Taoist there. Or something along those lines. I was thinking maybe take out the part about the town being hostile and aggressive, and inserting it somewhere else, like before revealing that the man is a Taoist. It's up to you.
“What just happened was very devastating,” he said, “But we must rebuild this town, and stay strong. If you are willing to help me rebuild this town, stand behind me, if not, you can get what's left of your belongings and leave.”
The sentences can be separated here. Also, some capitalization errors. Maybe: "What just happened was very devastating," he said, "but we must rebuild this town and stay strong. If you are willing to help me rebuild this town, stand behind me. If not, you can get what's left of your belongings and leave."
6 years had passed since the attack, and the town had gone from around 15, 13 people to over 200 people!
Are you trying to say 15 to 13 people? If so, I think you should switch it around to 13 to 15 people.
I noticed a few capitalization errors, like when you wrote that the town was the 3rd largest in the country. You should capitalize the "c" in china. Also when you introduced the evil guy, the "m" in man should not have been capitalized. I did notice some unnecessary commas during the read. If you can find them, I'd remove them. If you need help looking for them, just PM me and I can help.
But all in all, I think the idea was nice. I think you should slow down in terms of the events. It was kind of like, "This happened, and this happened, and this--" never slowing down to explain the hows. Don't rush. If it ends up being longer, just let it happen It's the story's way of telling you, "Hey, there's more to me than you think!" Silly, but that's how I see it. But anyway, I think you could go deeper with things like the Taoist man, the evil man, the town. Just to make the story more plump and lively. PM me if you have any questions! Keep writing!
-comrie
Points: 4429
Reviews: 104
Donate