gone

by kcglitter

Published March 16, 2011

I am the forest and you are the trees.
Now you are gone and I am empty.
No longer lush and green.
But dry and brown.
Without you I am nothing.
And the worst is the thing.
I no longer wish to see.
It’s not you but me.

Comments & reviews · 4
User avatar
kcglitter Comment
kcglitter commented Comment · Mar 25, 2011

it's my first one I'm not much of a poet but i'll work on it thankx

User avatar
Teardrop
Review
Teardrop wrote a review Review · Mar 19, 2011

Hey! Teardrop here.

First of all, I liked this, but I thought it could use a little work.

kcglitter wrote:I am the forest and you are the trees.
Now you are gone and I am empty.
No longer lush and green. try a comma instead of a period, and then don't capitilize but in the next line.
But dry and brown.
Without you I am nothing. Comma instead. Also, why? Explain and ellaborate.
And the worst is the thing.
I no longer wish to see.
It’s not you but me.


I think you need to fix the punctuation, and also make the poem flow. It's short, maybe you could add to it, or give it another stnaza or two. Just my opinion. Also, the last three lines are confusing, and I suggest possibly rewording them. : )

Make sure you ellaborate, check punctuation and capitilization too. I think if you add to it, you might also be able to put more raw emotion in there, so the reader feels what you feel. Overall, nice job, just remember punctuation!

Keep Writing and working on this!

~Tear

User avatar
misstoria
Review
misstoria wrote a review Review · Mar 17, 2011

This was nice but all too short. It seemed like as soon as the feelings got deep you took everything away. I agree of Gracie on the line "without you i am nothing", it is quite cliche. Another suggestion is to look at your puncation. It may work better if you use commas instead of some of the periods.

User avatar
Gracie
Review
Gracie wrote a review Review · Mar 16, 2011

Hi there.

This has potential but needs some work.

Firstly, it is very, very short. I don't think you can convey enough of an impact in such short a piece. I recommend you make it longer.

Secondly, I have a real problem with the line

"Without you I am nothing."

It is a very overused line. You see lines like this a lot in love and heartbreak poetry. It is kind of a cliché and very worn out line.

So I suggest you keep working on it.



I am deeply disturbed by your ability to meow.
— Carina