E - Everyone

The reverse Brain Drain

PreviousNext

India, as evidenced by economists all over the world, is not only the world's largest democracy but a country with untapped and unlimited economic potential. As an entrepreneur, I can boldly state that doing business in India is one of the many intangible treasures that few other countries can offer a "foreigner". As much as we like to criticize the red tape and the daily frustrations doing business brings about, the truth of the matter is that India encourages entrepreneurship and has untapped potential in virtually every sector in its economy.

India has the world's third largest GDP (by purchasing power parity) and with a middle class of nearly 300 million, is a preferred location for FDIs around the world to invest in.

NRIs are returning to India in what is being called the "reverse brain drain". The initial "brain drain" occurred in the 1990s when many IT students left for the west for possibly better education and employment opportunities. However, as the dot-com bubble burst, many were forced to return to India. At that time, it might have seemed to them that this was a misfortune.

However, in the past decade, something interesting has occurred: India's economy boomed while the US and other countries have suffered through struggling economies. In the past 10 years, the Sensex has appreciated 310 per cent while the Dow Jones Industrial Average (the equivalent to the Sensex in the US) has appreciated a meager 62 per cent.

The global meltdown in 2008 definitely contributed towards many NRIs returning to India; however, due to the mass exodus of Indians leaving the West and returning to India, the urge to return is only going to grow since the returnees have started and will continue to start thousands of companies which will provide equal or better opportunities than there are in the West.

In a recent study published by the Harvard Law School, 50 per cent of NRI returnees are doing so for entrepreneurship and business start-up reasons. Some key findings of the same study:

  • 10 per cent of Indians surveyed held senior management positions in the US, but 44 per cent found jobs at that level in India
  • 61 per cent of Indians found opportunities for professional advancement better at home than in the US
  • Most also found better opportunities to start a business in India
  • 79 per cent were motivated to return home because of growing demand for their skills in India
  • Just 6 per cent of Indian students surveyed would like to stay permanently in the US
  • Most fear the US economy will lag global growth rates in the near future
  • 86 per cent felt the best days for India's economy lay ahead
  • 53 per cent of respondents hope to start businesses in India

NRIs have returned to India for other reasons as well. Leveraging the education and experiences they gained abroad, they are applying their skills and contributing towards India's economy in numerous ways, across all sectors and walks of life. Whether it be business start-ups, non-profits, high-level positions at MNCs, or purely to be in a country that they can confidently call "home", NRIs have been returning in a massive scale ever since the US recession began. Indian scientists and engineers are returning due to better career and growth prospects in India versus the West. There is more job security, as well as the intangible benefits of better family and cultural ties.

Another startling reason as to why NRIs are returning to India is because they are unable to get their spouses, parents, and relatives visas abroad. In India, NR's are welcomed warmly since it is guaranteed that they will most likely contribute towards the economy in a meaningful way.

There is also another valid reason as to why NRIs are returning to India: they are unable to start up their own ventures and businesses. Due to recent immigration rule changes, students with an F1 Visa in the US are unable to get into entrepreneurship due to laws that forbid them from working on "outside jobs". They can work as an employee (within their domain of studies) or in internships with companies in his/her field of study, but they are not allowed to be self-employed in a business venture.

An irrational fear among Westerners, mostly due to the recession, that an accelerated growth of Indians in their countries will make it more difficult to obtain jobs has also contributed towards the "reverse brain drain". Thus, NRIs are being crowded out overseas and are looking at India for better employment and economic opportunities.

Among those NRIs that are returning to India, a special mention needs to be made to scientists, who are finding that better research opportunities and passion towards doing something for their home countries is luring them back to their motherland. Around 500 scientists have come back in the last seven years - and only six have gone back.

While the vast majority of the "reverse brain drain" has happened from the U.S., Germany and Britain, scientists have also started coming from South Korea and Japan. Schemes set up by the Indian government, including the setting up of The Ramanujam Fellowship, Innovation in Science Pursuit for Inspired Research (INSPIRE) Programme and the Ramalingaswamy Fellowship, are just a handful of programs that are being pushed by India to entice NRIs to return to India.

The tide has finally passed. Two decades ago, India was worried was about the "brain drain". Skilled Indian students were leaving the country and caused India concerns that they would not return.

Little did they know that they indeed, would, return.

After all, home is home, right?

Comments & reviews · 2
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

User avatar
DrFeelGood
Review

Interesting analysis Kabir! I can totally relate that because even I'm an Indian!

This is one of those rare articles here on YWS where everything written is directed towards the Indian reader. I take the honor of talking about it.

Well I have few of my relatives who have migrated to the U.S. after getting a big degree from a big college. No doubt the craze for leaving India is still high, but it is gradually decreasing.

I'd like to discuss more on your highlighted points.

1. 10 per cent of Indians surveyed held senior management positions in the US, but 44 per cent found jobs at that level in India

61 per cent of Indians found opportunities for professional advancement better at home than in the US


True there! It is hard to acquire senior positions in far land. You are always treated secondary and though you're paid high, you always get a secondary treatment.

2. Most also found better opportunities to start a business in India
79 per cent were motivated to return home because of growing demand for their skills in India
Just 6 per cent of Indian students surveyed would like to stay permanently in the US


Yeah, new age entrepreneurs are multiplying in quick succession. Have seen youngsters struggling for financiers but they are willing to face that but trying to do something themselves.

Most fear the US economy will lag global growth rates in the near future


I do get it that most of the top graduates migrate to the U.S. (Silicon Valley to be precise) but there are a host of people going into the Gulf or even Japan/Singapore. I think this essay totally ignores them and focuses much on US. But there are people I know who had come back in 2009 after the Great Depression.

Your essay is so strong in it's facts and descriptions that I can't really nitpick anything. Only major point like I said is, it is too much about the U.S. Overall a great job! Too good to critique!

Thanks for the review man. Will keep in mind the points provided by you. Will continue writing more.

User avatar
Wolfi
Review
Wolfi wrote a review · Sun Dec 28, 2014 7:44 am

Happy Review Day!!!

This looked like an interesting essay, so I decided to stop by. I've learned about the "brain drain" in school (Human Geography), so I wasn't completely clueless when reading this essay. Hopefully I can help out!

As an entrepreneur, I can boldly state that doing business in India is one of the many intangible treasures that few other countries can offer to a "foreigner".

Sometimes, flowery adjectives just get to be too much, especially when it comes to words like "intangible." These words tend to take away the true meaning you're trying to get across as your readers stumble over complicated sentences. You don't need to get rid of both adjectives I crossed out; rather, you should only get rid of one of them. Big words are impressive, but far from necessary. Also, that little "to" might help in this sentence.

GDP / FDIs / NRIs / MNCs

Umm... Out of all of these, I only know that "NRI" stands for "national rate increase." I think. Never mind, that can't be, when referring to how it is used in the text. So yeah, I don't know what any of those mean. And while it may be rare that a reader doesn't know what any of these things mean, here you have one. With the INSPIRE one, you actually explained what that stood for, which was good. Do that for all of them.

for the west for a possibly better education

I just think that sounds better.

Just 6 per cent of Indian students surveyed would like to stay permanently in the US

Really? That's fascinating!

In India, NR's are welcomed

Since I don't know what it stands for, I'm not sure if this is a typo or not.

Little did they know that they indeed, would, return.

I don't like how this is written. How about this: "Little did they know that they would, indeed, return."

That concludes the nitpicks!

This is an excellent essay, and you are an excellent writer. Everything flowed so nicely and hey, I learned a lot! True, much of it went over my head, but I was able to absorb all the important things. This is really quite interesting—India had been worried about the brain drain's damage to their economy, but now it has reversed, in their favor, and very quickly, too. All the explanations you offered made a lot of sense. And wow, that last sentence! That was the perfect ending to a superb essay!

Keep up the great work!!!

Thanks for the review. Will keep your points in mind.



The human heart has hidden treasures, in secret kept, in silence sealed...
— Charlotte Bronte