It's Not Fair (part one)

PreviousNext

Part One-Where for art thou, manners?

The entire classroom erupted with chatter about last night’s American Idol winners. Ashlynn fell back in her seat behind a boy that had a name, she just couldn’t remember what it was; not that she’d actually greet him or anything. He was one of them, one of the popular kids in her school. She saw him hanging around those sporty tan girls that wear their lacrosse uniforms on game day. She didn’t wear a uniform; she hadn’t made the team.

Ashlynn tried to concentrate on what her teacher talked about, but when Ms. Sullivan got off topic, she stared out the window and fell asleep with her eyes open. It wasn’t Ashlynn’s fault: with her five page research paper due the next week and taking on extra shifts at the deli mart, sleep wasn’t her highest priority.

“I think Kris should definitely win,” Ms. Sullivan said to her class. A few of the girls sitting around her claimed their rebuttal all at once.

Ashlynn drowned them out, thinking of her paper. She hadn’t even touched it yet. She had to find three quotes to somehow throw into her opinion on if The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is appropriate for the classroom or not. She was good at writing, but mostly she just likes to rant about any topic in general. Her way of just letting go.

“I can’t tonight, baby,” Ashlynn heard a boy say behind her. Her ears twitched slightly at this new sound.

The girl he was speaking to whined, “But, Rex, you promised we’d go out.”

It was Rex and Robin, the little R and R action going on behind Ashlynn almost made bile rise to her throat.

“I have a new job for work that needs to get done this week.”

Ashlynn could almost hear Robin roll her eyes at her boyfriend. “Fine. Whatever.” She huffed and started talking to one of the people sitting near them. Ashlynn couldn’t hear that conversation. She did, however, hear Rex muttering under his breath.

“Why am I even with her?”

For a moment, as brief as it was, Ashlynn pitied Rex. Rex has had to put up with Robin’s constant need for attention and superficial things for almost three years. Ashlynn had seen them in the halls, her whiny voice and his hurt expression. She had never thought anything of it until she heard his pen tapping impatiently on his desk.

The boy sitting in front of Ashlynn turned to her, or turned to Rex, she couldn’t tell. He smiled as his gazed passed right by Ashlynn and towards Rex. Ashlynn knew exactly what that smile meant.

Behind her, Rex started laughing hysterically the same moment Ashlynn reached up and pinched her nose. Pity party was definitely over.

The crowd around them all moaned and moved away from Ashlynn and Rex.

“Nice, Darren,” Ms. Sullivan said with as much sarcasm in her voice as her preppy tone could allow.

Thankfully, Ms. Sullivan called the class to order and actually began teaching. Ashlynn got the chance to catch up on fifteen minutes of gas-filled sleep.

Ashlynn kicked at the rocks in front of her house before she made her way up the driveway. The landscaping truck was parked close to her garage in her driveway. She walked right past the trucks and stepped onto her grey porch. The front door was open a crack. Ashlynn nudged it with her toe and it swung open. Her jaw fell.

Standing next to her father was none other than the boy that sat behind Ashlynn in her English class. Rex shook her father's hand. Dad! She thought. He's corrupting my dad!

“Ashlynn,” her father said in an overenthusiastic voice he only used around company.

Ashlynn’s father was a business man. He was a suit and tie, by the books, always making complete stops at the stop sign kind of guy. His receding grey hairline and slight gut wasn't what drove mom away two years ago. It was his tendency to hide away in his office for hours doing God knows what, never paying attention to either Ashlynn or her mom.

“This is Rex. He will be working on our hedges and what not for the week.” Rex turned to Ashlynn, a half hearted smile on his face. She knew that face was just a façade he used; he wasn’t glad to see her at all.

She nodded and turned towards the stairs.

“Hey,” her father called behind her.

Ashlynn sighed. So close, she thought to herself. She stopped halfway up the white carpeted staircase and glanced at her father. "Yes?"

“How, uh, was school?” He scratched the back of his head. Ashlynn fought the urge to roll her eyes. Ever since her mother called, screaming at her father about neglecting Ashlynn, her father had been trying to bond with Ashlynn, doing things she didn't really care about.

Ashlynn didn’t mind the space her father gave her. Some days, she even enjoyed the alone time. She was related to her solitary father, after all.

“Fine,” she replied.

Behind her father, the front door opened as Rex nodded to her father, excusing himself.

“Dinner will be around five?” He said it as a question, as if dinner was at any other time of the day for the past year.

She nodded.

Ashlynn ran to her room as quickly as she could. She threw on her earphones, Framing Hanley blasting into her ears. Swaying her head from side to side, she paced her bedroom. A glance outside her window told her Rex was hard at work. He was by the edge of her yard, digging some dirt. With a sigh she closed her blinds and lay belly up on her bed.

After who knows how long, Ashlynn’s father was pulling out her earphones, an angry expression on his face. She sat up abruptly in shock of her father’s presence in her bedroom. She quickly glanced at the growing dirty clothes pile by the door and the overflowing closet. Her dresser was a mess; makeup and hair accessories lay scattered sporadically around her room as if a tornado went through it.

“I’ve been calling you for the past ten minutes. I thought I told you not to put these things so God damn loud.”

Ashlynn stood up to face him. “Sorry, Dad. I wasn’t really thinking.”

He threw down her Ipod on her dresser and crossed his arms. “That boy is working pretty hard out there. You should offer him some water or PowerAde or something.”

Without missing a beat, Ashlynn’s jaw dropped and she threw up her arms. “What? No way! He is supposed to be a professional, he should have his own.”

“Ash,” his tone suddenly gentle, “he is fixing our front yard. The least we can do is offer him refreshments.”

“Then why don’t you do it?”

Her father’s jaw clenched. “Because I asked you to do it.” His eyes tightened and that meant the final word had been said.

Ashlynn stomped down the stairs and into the kitchen. Throwing open the refrigerator door, she grabbed the last remaining water bottle off the top shelf and slammed the door shut.

“Don’t be rigid. It’s not a very attractive trait.”

Ashlynn swallowed as much air as she could and let out a belch in her father’s face.

“Nice,” her father said sarcastically as he stifled his laughter.

She smiled as she walked out onto the porch.

Ashlynn’s smile suddenly faded as she saw Rex shirtless digging in the same pile of dirt. His back was tan and perfectly ‘V’ shaped. She reminded herself who he was and walked over to him.

Ashlynn stood a foot from where he was kneeling and dropped the water bottle in his view. “Thought you’d be thirsty,” she said to him, putting as much venom in her voice as she could.

He put down the gardening rake and replaced it with the bottle of water. He faced her as he started chugging the water. Her vision fell on his perfect chest and abs. A well toned six pack that led…

Ashlynn wouldn’t let her thoughts go there.

Rex handed her back the empty bottle and wiped his lips on the back of his arm. A trail of dirt formed across his left cheek and Ashlynn stifled laughter.

He smiled at her. “What?”

She shook her head and turned towards her home. “Nothing,” she said over her shoulder.

Comments & reviews · 3
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

User avatar
EllyMelly
Review

Good Afternoon, Jasmine.

Here are some of my comments and/or suggestions:

1) When I got to the second paragraph I got really confused about something. This sentence:

Ashlynn tried to concentrate on what her teacher talked about, but when Ms. Sullivan got off topic, she stared out the window and fell asleep with her eyes open.
Is it Ashlynn who's sleeping or Ms. Sullivan? It didn't seem clear the way you wrote it, maybe rewriting it?

2) Okay, when you mentioned something that's known, wouldn't you italicize it? For instance:
*She had to find three quotes to somehow throw into her opinion on if The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is appropriate for the classroom or not.
*She threw on her earphones, Framing Hanley blasting into her ears.
You see how they're italicized? Because you mentioned them they should be italicized.

3) As I read on I noticed that Robin's whiny, Rex has a six-pack, Dad's clueless and weird, and Ashlynn has a attitude problem. Now is Ash (Is it okay if I shorten it?) always that rude and prejudice about the popular folk? I know it's like first impressions and all, but will she ever soften her feelings down?

4) Um, how the heck did her dad get to know Rex? Do they live in the same neighborhood? Man, no wonder Ash flipped.

5) Well, I would like to read more and get into the lives of these few characters. Interesting, enough and I wonder what will happen...

Melly

User avatar
Octave
Review
Octave wrote a review · Fri May 01, 2009 11:05 am

Hi jasmine12! I'm Kara and I'm going to review your work. I'm mostly a grammar and spelling person, if that's okay with you.


The entire classroom erupted with chatter about last nights American Idol winners


...last night's...


Ashlynn fell back in her seat behind a boy that has a name, she just couldn’t remember what it is, not that she’d actually greet him or anything.


...behind a boy whose name she couldn't remember, not that she'd actually greet him or anything.

You don't need to tell us he has a name - it's common sense. I've never met a nameless person before, although if I did that would be so awesome. ^^


She didn’t wear her uniform, she hadn’t made the team.


Eh? You mean Ashlynn didn't make the team? Who exactly is she? And you mean she tried out?

Oh, and not comma. Semicolon.


It wasn’t Ashlynn’s fault, with her five page research paper due next week and taking on extra shifts at the deli mart, sleep wasn’t her highest priority.


...fault: with her five page...

Colon, not comma.


“I think Chris should definitely win,” Ms. Sullivan said to her class. A few of the girls sitting around her started to rebuttal all at once.


...started to argue against her all at once. Not rebuttal. Rebuttal is a noun. You want a verb after to.


Ashlynn drowned them out with the thoughts of her paper


...drowned them out, thinking of her paper.

The way you said it, it's as if her paper was thinking. Amusing, but you weren't aiming for that, I'm sure.


She is good at writing, but mostly just likes to rant about any topic in general.


She was good at writing, but most of all she liked to rant about any topic in general.

Tenses, tenses.


It was Rex and Robin, the little R and R action going on behind Ashlynn almost made bile rise in her throat.


...almost made bile rise to her throat.

Bile is made in the pancreas (? I'm not sure, but I'm sure it's not the throat). So it rises to, not rises in.


She did, however, hear Rex muttering under his breathe.


...under his breath.

Breathe is a verb. Breath is the noun.


Ashlynn has seen them in the halls, her whiny voice and his hurt expression.


Had, not has.


The front door is open a crack as Ashlynn nudged it with her toe and it swings open, as well as her jaw.


...was open a crack. Ashlynn nudged it with her toe and it swung open. Her jaw fell.

When you say as well as her jaw, I visualized Ashlynn's jaw swinging wide open (not a pretty sight - I've been watching too much Resident Evil lately).


Standing next to her father was none other than the boy that sits behind Ashlynn in her English class.


...none other than the boy who sat behind Ashlynn in her English class.

Again, tenses. Keep them consistent.


Rex was shaking Ashlynn’s father’s hand. My father! She thought. He is corrupting my father!


Rex shook her father's hand. Dad! She thought. He's corrupting my dad!

Father is so formal. Ashlynn doesn't sound like a cold, formal sort of girl. She's likely to call her father something else.

And take out the was. Make the sentence active (see above correction). Passivity kills prose.


My father is a business man. He is a suit and tie, by the books, always makes complete stops at a stop sign, kind of guy. His receding grey hair line and slight gut isn’t what drove her mom away two years ago. It was the fact that he would hide away in his office for hours beyond hours doing God knows what and never paying attention to her mom or Ashlynn.


!! Abrupt POV switch! Big no no. You must continue to write in third person because you started it in third person. Do not use my.

...He was a suit and tie, by the books, always making complete stops at the stop sign kind of guy. His receding grey hairline and slight gut wasn't what drove mom away two years ago. It was his tendency to hide away in his office for hours doing God knows what, never paying attention to either Ashlynn or her mom.

I changed the wording a bit. In this area, it's all right to use the passive sentence form though. The "his tendency" part is optional - it's not so much a change due to a grammatical error as to one due to an awkward flow in the sentence. You can replace it but make sure it flows nicely.


She knew that face was just a façade he used, he wasn’t glad to see her in the least bit.


...he used; he wasn't glad to see her at all.

Prune unnecessary words. Never use two words where one will do.


I nodded and turned towards the stairs.
“Hey,” my father called behind me.


Tsk tsk. POV switch again. Make sure which POV you're writing in. Decide.


She stopped halfway up the white carpeted stair case and looked down at her father. “Yes?”


She stopped halfway up the white carpeted staircase and glanced at her father. "Yes?"

Don't say looked down. It's...degrading. And I doubt she was giving her father a condescending glance.


Ever since her mother called screaming at her father about neglecting Ashlynn, her father has been trying to bond and crap that Ashlynn didn’t really care about.


There are two things wrong with this sentence. One, the last part is strange. Bond and crap? No.

Ever since her mother called, screaming at her father about neglecting Ashlynn, her father had been trying to bond with Ashlynn, doing things she didn't really care about.

Two, it made me dislike Ashlynn immediately. It made her unsympathetic. You don't want that because if the reader don't like the main character, she won't continue to read. Besides, this is Ashlynn's point of view. Take the time to show why she doesn't appreciate her father's efforts. Maybe she thinks he's insincere?

But don't, just don't, say she hated the "crap" he did. It makes her seem so...whiny. >.<"


She is related to her father, after all.


She was related to her father, after all.

Okay, first she disliked him and wanted him to give her more space. So what does this sentence have in connection to that? It would mean she'd like to spend more time with him, not the other way around as the previous sentences said.


Behind her father, the front door opened as Rex silently nodded to his father in excusal.


Behind her father, the front door opened as Rex nodded to her father, excusing himself.


She threw in her earphones and blasted Framing Hanley. She glanced out her window and saw Rex already hard at work. He is by the edge of her yard digging in some dirt. She closed her shade and lay on her bed.


Whoa! Same sentence pattern! She (insert verb) and (insert verb). It's annoying. Rephrase some.

...She threw on her earphones, Framing Hanley blasting into her ears. A glance outside her window told her Rex was hard at work. He was by the edge of her yard, digging some dirt. With a sigh she closed her blinds (shade?) and lay on her bed.

See? Not as redundant. It doesn't have to be exactly like that, but you get my point more or less. And again, tenses. Keep them consistent.


After who knows how long, Ashlynn’s father was pulling out her earphones, an angry expression on her face.


...Ashlynn's father pulled out her earphones, an angry expression on his face.

He's the one angry, right?

Oh, and again, kill passivity.


Her dresser is a mess, makeup and hair accessories scattered sporadically as if a tornado went through her room


Her dresser was a mess; makeup and hair accessories lay scattered sporadically around her room as if a tornado went through it.


“Ash,” his tone was gentle, “he is fixing our front yard. The least we can do is offer him refreshments.”


He was angry a minute ago. The sudden change makes him seem bipolar.


His eyes tightened and that meant the final word has been said.


Tightened? Try another word. It doesn't fit, in my opinion.


“Don’t be ridged. It’s not a very attractive trait.”


...be rigid...


Ashlynn swallowed as much air as she could and let out a belch in her father’s face. She smiled as she walked out onto the porch.


As I read this, the seeds of annoyance gnaw at me. She sounds like a brat right now. I mean, yes, it's all right to be angry. But her father sounded as if he was trying to be nice to her. And she belches in his face. Maybe she could ignore him instead? Annoyance would grow into hatred if not treated right away. Help me love your character? :)


The smile suddenly faded as she saw Rex shirtless digging in the same pile of dirt.


Her smile faded when she saw Rex shirtless, digging the same pile of dirt.

Her, not the smile. And take out unnecessary words, again.


She remained herself who he was and walked over to him.


Reminded, not remained.


Ashlynn stood a foot from where he is kneeling and dropped the water bottle in his view. “Though you’d be thirsty,” she said to him, as much venom in her voice as she could.


...where he was kneeling...

Okay, by now I'm beginning to forget annoyance and starting to remember hate. She really sounds whiny and annoying. (no offense to you) Try to make her more sympathetic, please.


He stood and faced her as he started chugging the water.


He faced her as he started chugging the water.

The "stood and" is unnecessary.



OVERALL: Like I said, Ashlynn is NOT someone likeable. Maybe it's just me, but let's not take chances. You want to make her more sympathetic. Make me understand where she's coming from. Why she's being so bad. If she's a bad girl type, then make her fun. Make me love her, sympathize with her.

If you rewrite it and want it critiqued again, I'm here. PM me if you want me to critique again.

I'm sorry if I seemed utterly harsh up there with Ashlynn. I know you love her (as a writer we love all our characters because we created them). But I felt the need to tell you about how she came across to me.

Again, sorry if I offended you.

Sincerely,

Kara



If food is poetry, is not poetry also food?
— Joyce Carol Oates