........................................
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hi! Sorry this has taken me so long to get to, but here I am now
Oh second person, excellent! That's not something you see every day, I'm looking forward to this. However, you need to make the transition between these two sentences more smooth. There are two ways you could do this, either by linking them with a comma, or by rephrasing the beginning of that second sentence.Specifics
1.
I would suggest something like: '...trails and endless fields. You see nothing but the turning...' which would flow much better. The repetition of you're/ you would also help to further engage the reader.
2. Normally I'd say don't change perspective, but you make the change so smoothly that I actually enjoyed it. Very nicely done!
3. The flash-back was dull to be honest with you. It was over dramatic, the dialogue could have been better and it was sloppy. The typos also tell me you didn't spend long on editing this. Don't throw away a good beginning like that. Instead, take some time to read this through and to think about what you're writing. It might be more interesting to make the flash back a series of disconnected memories. Keep this in the present tense and then have her thinking some of the lines of dialogue and show her getting angrier and revving the bike more the more she thinks about it. We don't want the full story, just a glimpse of it because that way you'll build intrigue and actually make us want to know what happened. It's better to not tell us and for us to want to know, than to tell us and make us feel we'd have rather not known.
4. I like the flashback with the family better. That one feels much more smooth and I'm interested in it because you're introducing a new element to the plot: the baby. The other two aren't interesting enough for me. They don't feel dynamic or important enough. I can see why you have them now and I like the idea of integrating the brief flash-backs and the present. But you need to work on the first two.
5. Be careful about repeating an uncommon phrase too many times. You've said drunken stupor at least twice now, maybe even three times and it's too much. It's an awkward phrase already so to have it in even once is enough. Instead, describe him being drunk. Describe his bleary eyes, the smell of alcohol on his breath or congealing in his beard. Describe him stumbling or walking into objects.
6. Careful with the cop - it's not realistic for them to say drunk driving accident. They would more likely say a car accident because they don't reveal those kinds of details right away and they have more tact than that.
Overall
I really like the themes you're working with here and I actually found the ending unexpected. I thought this was going in an entirely different direction so great work there! You need to take more care on your dialogue and with some of the sections in general - there's a huge difference between that really strong opening and that first flash-back. But if you put as much time into ironing out the weaker sections as you have the strongest, I think you'll have a powerful story.
Good luck!
Heather xx
How’s it going Helovedme?
Guess what… ilovedyou, too.
As your first short story, this is really good. I assume you were writing before this, because you've done really well here. I got a feel for all of the senses, which is something that is commonly overlooked in writing. I feel like your narration is strong. I find it the best part about the story. There was a recurring theme throughout, which was cool. I also liked Emily's self-conflict at the very end, showing that her life goes beyond just this story. I thought mostly the characters were solid.
As far as dialogue goes, it is okay, but seemed a bit rushed in parts. You could break up some of the sentences to add more feelings, thoughts, and actions to the characters – and like ArcticMonkey said, it could be more natural and realistic.
I don’t have any other points to touch on that the previous poster hasn't already. I have a feeling you will only continue to improve from here. I’ll be keeping an eye out for more of your writing. Awesome job, and keep it up!
Kora
Hi helovedme13! Firstly, welcome to YWS!

Anyways, onto the review. Nitpicks in the spoiler, my comments are in bold:
Spoiler
Okay, so starting with your characters. Obviously by the end of this story you want the readers to feel empathy for your MC, Emily, however I don't think there was enough back story earlier on in the story for us to feel this. What was her relationship with Sean like? Were there lots of ups and downs? Did they fight a lot or was it all hunky dory? Secondly the MC's friend is slightly stereo-typical as one of those girls who is just all about her reputation and nothing else. In all honesty, those people aren't really like that, or they have more to them. And yeah, I think you need to add more to Emily's character to make her more relatable to the readers.
I mentioned briefly in the nitpicks that some of your dialogue didn't seem very natural. Especially when Emily is talking to her parents. I found that to make dialogue more natural, just pay closer attention to how people talk in real life because that is your best source of 'realistic' characters. I know that it's hard and you want to fit certain things into your story, but just make it slightly more authentic and it will be great
What I particularly liked about your story was the metaphor used with the gears and switching from different gears. I thought it was a really clever metaphor and it represented your story really well. however, I think you could've added more to the setting, for example what was school like? What was home like?
Finally, I've found that your tenses messed up at times. It's not really a major issue, I'd say just read over it and polish it up so that all the tenses are the same and correct.
I hope this review helped, please PM me with any questions or if you'd like another revewi.
Keep Writing!
-Arc
I made a few changes to it because I agreed with almost all you said, let me know if this sounds any better when you get a chance please(: