I quickly walk to my father’s study and stop outside the door. I let out a nervous sigh and reach up to knock on the big red door. “Leave,” his voice barks from inside and my heartbeat quickens. He’s not in a good mood.
“I-I’ll come back later,” I rush as I quickly turn on my heel to leave but stop short once my father speaks.
“Lu!” He calls out my name is realization, his voice a little less aggressive. “Open the door Chong,” he barks and I groan as I hear his servant's footsteps get closer.
He opens the door and I’m met with a short bearded man. “Lu so nice to see-,” Chong starts but my father is quick to shut him up.
“Stop talking. Come in Lu,” he says sharply, and Chong lets out a quiet sigh.
“Yes father,” I comply automatically, and step past Chong after giving him an apologetic smile. His face stays clear of emotion and I frown. It’s like my father sucks the life out of everyone.
I walk to the large desk and patiently wait for my father to turn and face me. “You may stop,” he tells another one of his servants and the servant's hand quickly drops the quill and moves away from the paper. “Just warfare things,” he tells me as he sees my questioning look.
I nod. It’s silent as my father stares at me, waiting for me to state my business. “I um..” I start but trail off in a loss of words.
He huffs in annoyance and narrows his eyes. “I don’t have all day! I’m a busy man, what do you want-” he says in an aggravated tone but I cut him off.
“I want to be normal!” I snap, but the second the words leave my mouth my eyes widen at my mistake.
“That will never happen,” he answers and turns in his chair back to his desk, telling me the conversation is over.
My hands curl into fists and I internally scream. I silently leave the office, hearing the satisfying slam of his heavy door closing behind me. I rush to my room with my head spinning. It's time to leave. I can’t stay here. I can’t live like this anymore.
I rummage through my closet and yank out my bag. I grab robes and tunics and then run down the stairs to the kitchen. I pass servants and ignore their confused stares as I grab lot’s of food.
Once I grab as much things that will fit into my bag, I rush out of the door, and shove past the Imperial Guards that are waiting outside the palace. “Ms. Lu! Where do you think you’re going mam?” I ignore their calls and run down the courtyard.
I run through the garden and push open the gates. The second the gates open, the chatter of commoners fill my ears. The smells of rice, dumplings, and so many different foods clash together. I also notice the beautiful statues of Buddha, and busy marketplaces.
My eyes wonder around the city streets in awe, and then I notice the numerous stares I’m getting. I then realize that they probably aren’t used to someone dressing as exotically as me, so I decide to try and fit in.
“One of those please,” I ask politely as I point to the brown robe hanging in the back of the shop. The tall man who looks to be in his mid twenties at the front of the shop looks at me wearily and lifts a questioning eyebrow.
“You want to buy that when you have those,” he asks in a sickly sweet voice as he looks at my clothes.
“Yes,” I answer automatically and confidently. I’m completely sure that I want to be normal. It’s what I’ve wanted my whole life and if buying dirty robes is what it takes, I’m happy to do it.
He smiles. “Very well. Let’s go get it shall we?” He asks as he starts to walk to the back of the stoor. I follow with an excited smile on my face.
Once we get to the back of the shop, I reach up to get the robe but he quickly stops me. “No, no, no. First, I want to ask you a few questions. Like you know, how much you have to spend, where you came from. I do this with all my customers,” he elaborates as he notices my confused look.
“Oh of course! I don’t know anything about life outside of my palace, and I was questioning your ways, I’m so sorry,” I say with an ashamed smile.
His eyes widen and a smile creeps back onto his face. “Palace you say? Okay I have no more questions for you dear.” He reaches for something behind his back and I look back to the robe.
“Oh okay,” I say in confusion and start to reach up for the robe again when something is thrown over my head and tightly closed. I open my mouth to let out a scream, but a hand is firmly placed over my mouth.
I struggle in the person’s grasp, but his arm’s just tighten around me. when I realize he is no match for me, my body goes limp and I let him drag me away. “Stupid girl,” he whispers.
I couldn’t believe what was happening. I would have never ever expected this, and I still don’t even know what’s going on. I try to let out a sigh but of course it never comes out because of his hand firmly clamped over my mouth. Only I, being the stupid person I am, could get myself in a situation like this.
I was roughly thrown onto something and after feeling around with my hand I realized it was wood. A second later I started moving, and could hear the neigh of horses. I’m in a waggon, I thought to myself as I sat up and blindly reached around me to find something to support me.
I grab onto the side of the waggon and hold on tight as the rough bumps start to increase. “Are we no longer in the marketplace?” I call out once I remember that the marketplace had smooth streets.
“Guess your not so stupid,” is the reply I get from him and I frown at that. Of course I’m not stupid.
“I’m not. I know how to read,” I tell him confidently and I get no response. After a long time he finally speaks again. “Teach me.”
“No,” I answer right away. Why would I help a guy who just tricked me, kidnapped me, and called me stupid?
“I won’t kill you if you teach me,” he says smoothly and confidently and I sigh in aggravation.
Okay maybe that’s why I would. “What do you want from me,” I ask with narrowed eyes, which I know he won’t be able to see since I have a bag tied around my head.
“Well, at first when I realized you were obviously rich I wanted your money. But, I’ve always wanted to read and write and I guess I’ll just have to get both,” he says and I can picture the slick smile on his face.
“Take the bag off of my head and I might help you,” I say as I cross my arms and stare ahead of me, hoping that’s where he is.
“Okay,” he says and the waggon stops. “We’re here anyways.”
I eagerly get to my feet but stumble slightly. “Take it off,” I say. I hear him get out of the waggon and walk to the back where I am. I’m then easily lifted out of the waggon and placed on the ground. Then the bag is ripped off of my head and I let out a breath of air. “I was suffocating.”
“No, you weren’t. I put a few little holes on the top of the bag,” he elaborates as he throws the black bag into the back of the waggon.
“It’s called exaggerating,” I say as I roll my eyes. I notice his mouth twitch upwards; as if on the verge of smiling.
“My name is Lu,” I tell him and reach my hand out waiting for him to shake it. He ignores my hand and turns around.
“My name is Gao,” he says as he starts to walk away. I stay behind him, with a confused look on my face. “Follow me,” he calls over his shoulder.
“Where are we going?” I ask as I look around at the deserted and scary looking place. When I get no answer, I decide to just follow him. We end up walking to a log and sitting down.
He points to my bag, which is plopped on my lap. “You got learning stuff in there?” He asks with a hopeful look on his eyes.
I nod and pull out paper, ink and a quill. “Always bring it with me,” I tell him with a smile.
“You teach me, and I’ll bring you back home,” he says and I automatically nod, but then stop and start to think about it.
“Being here with you, even though you just kidnapped me and all, might be better than being cooped up at home,” I tell him with a shrug.
“I would give anything to have a life like yours,” he tells me and I realize what I said might have been selfish.
“Anyways, let’s get started. This here,” I say as I point to the first letter. “Is the letter A.”
Numerous hours were filled with me pointing to letters and telling him what they sound like. He was quite slow, and at times it was frustrating. But I realized that if my teacher could put up with me, I could put up with him.
After a while I put down the quill and looked up to him. “I want to go home,” I said.
He nodded and then sighed. “How about you stay a few days and teach me more?” He asks with a hopeful look.
I sternly shake my head. “I miss home. I never thought I would but I do. I think being on this trip with you has helped me realize that I should be grateful for what I have.
We soon arrive at my house after a much nicer trip in his wagon since I was up at the front with Gao, and I didn’t have a bag tied around my head. “I have an idea Gao,” I tell him as we pull to a stop.
“Yes?” He asks as we both step out of the waggon. He walks to my side of the passenger side and turns to face me,
“I will continue teaching you. I will write to you. Life won’t be as boring if I get to actually send the letters that I write to someone,” I tell him with an excited smile.
“Might take me a while to fully understand and read the letters you send but that sounds great,” he says with a smile of his own.
“Okay,” I say excitedly and turn around to leave but stop. I turn back around and hand him my bag, without a second of hesition. “It has food, and most importantly paper, ink, and quill. He gratefully smiles and gets back in the waggon. “I will stay in touch.”
“As shall I,” he say and wave as the wagon starts to move. I walk back inside the palace and give a sheepish grin to the Imperial Guards who sigh gratefully. “Your father would have killed us.”
I hurry inside and go straight up the stairs to my room. I push open the door and sit down on my desk to write Gao his first letter. After a few minutes pass of me writing away, my father and mother come in and giving me grateful hugs and scoldings.
Now my window is locked because they don’t fully trust me anymore but I don’t really care, because all I need to keep my entertained is Gao, paper, ink, and quills. I guess being the secret daughter isn’t so bad if you have a secret friend.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Ellie,
This is probably the best story I've read so far! Your plot was very compelling and interesting. It had me on the edge of my seat throughout the story. I particularly liked your paragraph intending. You knew when it was time to indent and that made the story all the more organizing and professional. Also loved the vocabulary. The way you described the characters' every bit of dialogue using the most descriptive adjectives made the story realistic, and I could easily set the scene. Lastly, with the acception of a few punctuation mistakes, your spelling and grammar was spot on. You truly have a gift for writing, and it shows here. Just one question: Is this the career you want to peruse? Just wondering...
- Cole Fowler
Cole,
I'm sorry I'm answering so late, but thank you so much Cole! Reading this made me really happy, and I'm really glad you enjoyed my story. Yes, this is a career I want to pursue! I love writing, and I've published a story on Wattpad and it's slowly getting more and more reads. I really hope I can make it as a writer, and again thank you.
-Ellie
Hi elliexoxo,
I read your story, and I noticed a few things.
First of all, I wanted to let you know that I love your story, and your style of writing is great. However, there are a few issues with this piece of writing. For one, I noticed several grammar issues, mainly with homonyms. I believe that it would be a good idea to have your story proofread by an adult, so you could fix those errors. Secondly, I think it was a bit weird that a girl would become friends with someone who had just kidnapped her. Another thing I noticed is that the kidnapper, Gao, told the girl he had kidnapped his name. Considering that this girl was some sort of princess, I don't think a kidnapper would do that, because she could have him fracked down and executed or imprisoned. Lastly, I don't think her strict father would allow her to receive letters from her kidnapper.
Thanks, loved your story.
Hi elliexoxo,
I read your story, and I noticed a few things.
First of all, I wanted to let you know that I love your story, and your style of writing is great. However, there are a few issues with this piece of writing. For one, I noticed several grammar issues, mainly with homonyms. I believe that it would be a good idea to have your story proofread by an adult, so you could fix those errors. Secondly, I think it was a bit weird that a girl would become friends with someone who had just kidnapped her. Another thing I noticed is that the kidnapper, Gao, told the girl he had kidnapped his name. Considering that this girl was some sort of princess, I don't think a kidnapper would do that, because she could have him fracked down and executed or imprisoned. Lastly, I don't think her strict father would allow her to receive letters from her kidnapper.
Thanks, loved your story.
I really liked the lot of the story and it's always good to make new friends. I wonder if you could add a little more detail in what is not the dialogue. Also a little less dialogue and more text. I wonder if you could have more interaction with other people. You should also talk more about her life before when she meets her parents. The historical content i thought was great. Overall it was a good story.
[ Edit ]
I liked your story a lot it was very detailed and had good historical content. I wonder if you could talk about why the father was so mean. I also wonder if you could us a little bit more show not tell and use less dialogue and more thinking.
I really liked the lot of the story and it's always good to make new friends. I wonder if you could add a little more detail in what is not the dialogue.The historical content i thought was great. Overall it was a good story.
Hello.
Welcome to YWS! I'm here to point out things I noticed in your story that you can improve on.
The first thing I really noticed was the way she's introduced to her father, and the servant. I'm not as familiar with Chinese culture as I would like to be, but a few things immediately read as off to me. Now, I could be wrong on this, but I would seriously do research into the following:
Expressing emotions can be different among cultures. So little things like smiling, looking apologetic, even anger and aggressiveness— all of those could be frowned upon in the culture at hand. That's why the father's snappishness reads as off, to me. It is part of East Asian cultures to hide emotions and be very difficult to read, because that's just how the culture works. I also doubt he'd be so dismissive, because of my next point.
Children and parents feel an extreme responsibility towards each other, so the concept of "wanting to be normal" is something very much out of place, and the concept of not providing for your child is also very out of place. This girl would have been raised to be part of the family and put family as a high priority, maybe even higher than herself, and selfishness is very frowned upon. The same would be said for her father, even though he would be the head of the household, his job is to provide and make sure those in his care are properly educated and have the necessities they need.
Palaces were also not exactly easy to run away from. There would be multiple levels of guards, and nobility would be kept deep inside. Children weren't necessarily given that much freedom, and she likely would have been caught.
Also, the language you use feels out of place in the East. Look up how children of nobility would be addressed in China and modify your dialogue accordingly. Syntax and how the dialogue is written is very important and reflects all the cultural values I mentioned above.
This might sound like a lot, and in a few ways it is! However, you really have to keep in mind the culture when writing historical fiction. Right now, the story simply uses China as a backdrop, and it doesn't feel like part of the culture itself.
Overall, this is a really interesting idea! I'd love to see it adjusted so it really reflects Chinese culture, so it feels like a historical fiction short story instead of just a story set somewhere.
Hope this helps. Let me know if you have any questions or comments!
~Rosey
Hey,

Thank you so much for your helpful response, but I just wanted to let you know that this was a seventh grade project that wasn't supposed to go in depth about the Chinese culture. I was just supposed to add ten historical facts about China, (which I did) and that was all. I know it would be hard to run away from a palace and that she would probably get caught, but this story was supposed to be from my imagination. It's a fictional story. Also, you had said something about the language, but I don't speak Chinese at all, and we never learned about how they addressed people in this project. And one more thing, you had also said that it wouldn't actually happen that the king wouldn't provide for his daughter, but he does. He definitely provides for her, he just doesn't let her leave the palace because he fears for her safety. He gives her clothes, and food, and everything a child at her age would need. Anyways, thank you again for your feedback, I just wanted to clear up some things and I guess in a way defend my story, even though you were just been very helpful
-Ellie
Thanks for the reply! I'd just like to clear up my own points.
About the language, I wasn't referring to actual Chinese terms. I was just referencing how the terms felt out of place, which is a slightly different issue. "Lady" would've been more appropriate, because it feels more royal.
And while I understand this was a class project it is fiction, it's also historical fiction which means a major part of whether or not the story is good or not is how historically accurate it is. If things are implausible, then it's a lot harder for readers to really get immersed in the story.
For her daughter providing, I didn't mean to imply that he wasn't giving her physical needs! I meant to say he should also be providing emotional needs, such as kindness, and making sure she's happy. The way he ignored her obvious hurt that she didn't like being a princess came across as really mean, when, culturally, he would've been more inclined to ask why she was unhappy.
Oh okay, I understand where you were coming from now.
The only thing I want to comment on is the father not providing for his daughter. It is true, that most parents will always be there for there family, but that doesn't mean there won't be times when their temper get's the best of them, or their busy. If I was able to make this a long story, (my teacher said it was only allowed to be three pages) I would have definitely touched on their back rounds and how the father really does care for her, it's just at the moment he was snappy and she was impulsive. I needed to make something happen that would cause her to make the impulsive decision to leave, and a fight with one of her parents made sense
I do hope you continue the story! It's a really interesting concept and I'd love to see it explored ^^ If you do revise it, let me know and I'll review it again!
Hey, Jay here, your friendly neighborhood critic!
so, this is an interesting story. Reminds me of a mixture of a novella that my favorite author wrote called "The Emperor's Soul" and a full novel that he wrote called "Warbreaker" when--in Warbreaker--Vivenna was betrayed by Denth.
Great grammar, great characters, great EVERYTHING!
I simply have three things I want to point out:
A simple typo. You don't say "mam", you say "ma'am".
This sentence just feels drawn out. Try turning it into multiple sentences, so it looks something like this:
#BF0000 ">"Oh, of course! I don't know anything about life outside the palace--and I was questioning your ways! I'm so sorry!"
AAANNNNNDDDD Final thing.
There are two of these. You got the wrong one--but that's okay. It's a mistake everyone makes. 'Your' or 'yours' is for possession. If I were to say "Those shoes belong to you", I could also say, "Those shoes are yours."
Then there's you're. That's the abbreviation for 'you are'. It'd be odd if I said, "Those shoes are you're's," because I'd be saying those shoes are 'you are's.' And unless the character is named You Are, you shouldn't be saying that. It'd also be odd for me to say "Guess your not stupid," because that's me saying that I own 'not stupid'? Or. . . Something like that.
You'd say:
#BF0000 ">Guess you're not stupid.
Other than that? Great job! Keep writing great works like this.
Thank you so much for your feedback, that was really helpful! I'll make sure to not make those three mistakes in my future stories.
-Ellie