Published May 18, 2010
The heels of her red stilettos clicked against the marble flooring of the million dollar building. Her attitude was beaming with positivity but was concealed behind a warm smile that made her eyes appear more the bluish green. It was her turn to shine and if there was any obstacle in her way she would simply find a way to maneuver around the obstacle or remove it with brute force of her polished attitude. Stepping into the elevator she noticed mark alright standing beside her and gave him a very friendly hello. Although he was attracted to her and had asked her out on numerous occasions she had only been able to see him strictly on the friendship level. He was charming sure but there was no spark between them and he failed to see that. As the elevator came to a halt on the twenty-second floor she took a steady breath and stepped out and into her brand new opportunity.
She came to a set of double doors in polished gold.
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hey, BMagic.
First of all, airbear gave you a good line-by-line critique; I agree with all of her points, so follow her advice. I'll mainly focus on overall stuff.
Aside from the odd description about the smile enhancing her eye color, I'm wondering why you have the "but" here. It hints that, even though she's super happy, she's hiding it...with a smile? You normally don't hide happiness by smiling warmly. If she was concealing her positive attitude, she wouldn't be showing it, and she wouldn't be smiling.
All this confusion because of one wrong word choice! Just be sure you say what you mean, and what makes sense within the context. Word choice is incredibly important.
We don't need a name from this character-- vagueness there is perfectly alright. But what's not alright is that this has no clear point. Okay, so, she's happy. Good for her. But why should I care? I don't know anything about her as a character except for that she doesn't want to go out with Mark, who is, I admit, oddly placed and stands out as an afterthought.
Think about what you're trying to say with this. If the message is that you can overcome any obstacle and walk into a brand new opportunity, show us that. What obstacles did she overcome? There's your conflict. How did she emerge victorious? There's your characterization. What is she going to do with her life now? There's your conclusion. I'm not asking for a life story-- but this flash needs more direction.
Show, don't tell.
Best of luck, keep writing, and PM me for anything!
~Evi
Hi! I think this is a good, intriguing start but it needs some work. How about we go through sentence by sentence, since this is pretty short?
The number one rule in description is show don't tell. You're telling us it's a million dollar building. Why not show us? Are there fountains in the lobby or expensive rugs? Mahogany tables? Chandeliers? Show us it's a million dollar building.
I'm not sure how an attitude can "beam". Also, the whole thing about her smile changing the color of her eyes is kind of strange. Why not say, "She was beaming with positivity, but concealed it behind a warm smile. The only tell was her shining bluish green eyes." That's a bad example, but you get the idea.
Okay, I have no idea what "it" is. I'm assuming your talking about whatever experience that's brought her to this fancy building. So maybe say "This was her chance to shine."
Then there's one too many obstacles in this sentence. I'd suggest breaking this up into two sentences so it would be- "This was her change to shine and if there was any obstacle in her way she would simple find a way to maneuver around it. Or remove it with the brute force of her polished attitude."
Capitalize Mark's name. Also, if you have any chance to use dialogue, I'd say do it. Have her actually say "Hello" and then you can this will give you a chance to show the reader how positive or happy she's feeling.
You could add this into the dialogue of the previous sentence. Say she was in such a good mood that not even seeing him could bring her down or something. And then you could just leave it at that. This is verging on an info dump. Just let the readers know that there's some thing between them, but you don't have to reaveal it right away.
This is a great sentence. Don't change a thing.
Change "in" to "of".
Also, you haven't mentioned your MC's name or what she looks like. I don't know if you do that later or not, but I'd like to know what your MC looks like. Maybe when you're describing the building you could show us how she dressed up to look her best and to fit into the building. That way readers can start putting a face on the MC. Then if you choose to add dialogue in the elevator you could have Mark mention her name.
Then there's the title. It's called "The Brand New Attitude." So she probably didn't always have this shiny happy attitude? Maybe hint at that a little. Say how she's turning over a new leaf or something.
Overall
So, I'm curious, is this part of a bigger piece? I hope so, because I want to know what your MC is so excited for! Is it a new job or something? Anyway, I like it so far. It just needs some polishing and then it'll be awesome!
Feel free to PM me with any questions.