I was born in a family where much was expected. My father was the Duke of Naman, one of the biggest provinces of Galean. My mother was nonexistent. I did not even know whether she was alive or dead. I remember having asked my father about her. It was on a cold day, after the servants had laid out our supper.
“I…I want to know about my mother.”
My father looked up from his food, giving me his most solemn look, the one he gave when I had gotten into mischief.
I immediately rested my chin on my chest, looking intently into my soup.
“You want to know about your mother, why darling?” My father’s voice was calm and kind for one so big and strong. I’d heard the servants say that he used to sing when he was a boy, high and clear, sweet enough to charm the very birds from the trees.
I swallowed and lifted my head, “I just felt, that I ought to know sir.”
“Conrad,” My father addressed our butler, “Take it away, I’ve had my fill.”
Then Gregory of Naman, my father, came to me, knelt down at my feet and told me the one thing that I ever knew about the woman who was my mother.
“Your mother’s most beloved possession in this world… was you.”
That is all I knew at the time that I was twelve years old. I had given up making more attempts because my father would simply say the same thing each time, and then be unsociable and melancholy for at least a week.
I often found myself lonely and quite honestly bored due to the lack of siblings or peers of my own age. My only friend in the world was my father, but during the long months when he was away, I would retreat into my own sadness.
My afternoons were spent picking flowers in the garden, and watching the sea ebb as it draped the rocks below on the pier. I wasn’t allowed to go down; I think my father was afraid of the ocean. He called it the “destroyer”. Secretly, I thought it was beautiful, large and mysterious. I longed to touch that world.
My life went on, and my curiosity grew stronger. Each night was spent dreaming about running on the white beaches, feeling the spray on my face, and becoming completely immersed in the waves. I wondered if I would ever be allowed to come that close, knowing that my father would forbid it. After my sixteenth birthday, my father left for the longest time he ever had. A year passed, and I was afraid he was gone forever, until a messenger brought news of his return to Naman.
As I was staring at the ocean from my window, my maid Cynthia came in to dress me for my father’s return. She was always very prompt, her motions were mechanical, and I wondered whether she ever tired of dressing a seventeen year old girl, who was very capable. But she dressed me anyway, as she had always done. I suppose I could have told her I would do it on my own, but somehow didn’t want to break the ritual.
“This one is suitable, yes?” She held up a dress, long and flowing. It reminded me of the sea, its deep blue color, the silver stitching; simple, yet elegant.
“Yes, it’s perfect.” I smiled as she nodded.
“I thought it would be. It seems to suit you. It brings out your eyes miss.”
Indeed my eyes were blue. Like my father’s.
Almost hesitant, I glanced in the mirror. I was tall for a girl my age, nearly six inches below my father. The skin I had was slightly tanned from my incessant walks in the garden, and my cheeks were sun kissed red. I had small lips that I considered disproportioned. My father called them rosebuds, and said when I just born they were dark and pursed like a new flower. My cleft chin was the one thing I knew I could link to my mother, because my father clearly didn’t have one. Sometimes he called me Edeline, my mother’s name, and it scared me. The look on his face was so dark and wounded when he said that name. Somehow, I think part of me reminds him too much of her.
“My lady,”
Cynthia had returned and looked excited. Happiness was a rare emotion she carried.
“Your father is home.”
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Wow, this is really good. I don't have much to say that Rachel hasn't already covered, but I figured I'd give you my opinion. There were a few grammar errors, I'm not sure if you're interested in hearing them. Anyway, I'm just guessing, but it seems to imply by the way her father acts about the sea that the ocean had something to do with what happened to her mother.

There's not much I could suggest other than maybe a little more dialogue to let the readers get to know the characters a bit more.
Anyway, your writing is really great
Hi, Ash!
I liked this. Very different from the usual fantasy openings. Nice and calm, simple, soothing almost. A conflict not about the end of the world but something more human and personal, and not entirely conflicty either. Understated, really. Which is much different indeed from the typical fantasy, but in a good way.
I get the feeling he's going to come home with some sort of adventure or quest or bad news that spurs the story on, but for now... nice and calm. Also, the anticipation of what's to come is neatly out of the prose. By which I mean, I can't tell as a reader that something out of the usual is about to happen. You get the tone so even.
Strangely, this reminded me more of a Jane Austen novel, somewhat--18th or 19th century high society with estates more than a duchy. Is the estate isolated? I got this image of a grand manor surrounded by not much of anything. And the use of the term 'maid' made me think of a 19th century maid rather than the typical attendants gushing over everything. Not that any of this is bad at all. Just thought you'd want my thoughts.
On the nature of critique... this was short, so it's hard to say too much, and I want to see where you're going with this calm, melancholy tone before I say anything really.
I will point out this line, though, because it's nagging at me...
The reason it's nagging is that it's hanging out all by itself, and it's one short sentence and then a fragment. It makes the sentence sound so important, but I can't grasp yet why it would be all that important, so I'm left thinking that it's somehow ultra important that she has blue eyes and they're like her father's. Does that make sense? My point's that the way you have it draws a lot of attention to a detail that seems awfully minute.
Her description of herself... Character looking in the mirror is the oldest description in the book. You have a good description, mind, flavored with her view on things and other information that I stowed away neatly, but it's a disproportionate amount of detail compared to the otherwise minimalistic description from elsewhere. Again, not bad, but something to consider. Maybe she really is studying herself so closely in the mirror, maybe not. Only you know.
Another line that's nagging at me:
The way you have this grammatically, you're saying that she carries happiness, a rare emotion (with the implication that she's happy even though the duchy usually isn't.) I think you might have meant that happiness was a rare emotion for her to carry. Either way, you might want to reword, depending.
And... I think that's it for review. Let me know if you have any questions or comments! Just come bug me on my Wall. I'm always available to bounce ideas off of
Rach