Young Writers Society

I read The Lottery this year, for class-reading. At the end, I was completely confused. And as a large class, we had the utmost difficulty trying to analyze the story. It was in our "utopian" unit. To this day, I still try to find out her overall message or theme.

I own the shirley jackson book, which is a collection of short stories. She really is a great plot writer--although characteristically dry in style.

The story is awesome, though.

It's delightfully disturbing.

Read this recently, and didn't like it. The story tries to build up the stoning to the highest point it will hold your interest. But the stoning is not innately interesting enough to stand up to the amount of drama Shirley Jackson puts on it. To little, to late. Nor is it weird or unique enough to justify this being a remarkable short story. It's just a natural, ugly fit. There is some nice foreshadowing, but I'm more of a reader on the rush, and I prefer to think about stories instead of researching them.

Of course, it's not a bad story, I just don't like it.

Oh I read this too (in the 8th grade). I loved it. The theme that we took from it was that traditions aren't always right. It left me totally speechless.

cool, thanks I'll check it out.

I read this in class just recently. It had a lot of symbolism and I thought it was very well written, and yes the ending did shock me. Overall I thought it was a really good story.

We had to analyze it and compare it to another story, The Lady or the Tiger, in English this year.

It's very well written.

I loved "the Lottery." Jackson wrote an amazing short story! I highly suggesting reading this.

BTW, if I remember correctly she wrote this for the New York Times. It caused chaos among readers, which I bet was the intention!

We had to do a small project on this in English a couple of months ago. Well, all we had to do was pick a phrase and draw a picture. Simple, but fun.
I kind of liked it. I have to say that i was kind of confused. It was the end of the day, though. I think the best part was the end. It was unexpected.


alicat

I read it in my 10th grade english class. We also watched the movie. It disturbed me and I would never like to read it again. Though I do recommend reading it once. It's a great story to make you contemplate society and such.

I've always really liked the story. We make a big deal out of it at my high school because Shirley Jackson went there. Every year the library puts up a display of alumni authors and she gets her special place...

I read this in class last year, or the year before. I didn't find It amazing, but it was an interesting read. The irony, of course, is that if it had been someone else she'd have gone along and hapily stonned them to death and ignored their cries. Self preservation and all that.

It's amazing, but in reality it's a sad truth that people can do just about anything without feeling it's right or wrong because they have been raised around it. I guess if you grow up with something, you get used to it and never think to question it.

It makes you think, so it's a pretty good read.

^_^ Keek

We had to interpret this story in theater. Our group did it as a "game show" where the "prize" was being stoned to death. scary. When I first read the story freshman year, it made me speechless. The thought of people setting up a system of "population control such as that is a terrifying thought. What really shocked me was the fact that the characters were completely fine with it. If you get chosen, you get chosen. No big deal. I wish I knew how the idea/necessity of population control came to the town. This story is a must read.

Thanks for the link, I love reading short stories so I'll probably pop over to the site at some point and rummage around.