If I wasn't such a light sleeper, the bawl of the buffalo calf would have drifted past dead ears.
That evening on the beach was especially cold. I could see the faint wisps of my breath as the frosty wind carried it away, making me shiver as I walked. The ebony sky wasn’t very welcoming; it didn’t even care to provide me with the soft light of the moon. The water was as black as the sky, and only the tips of the waves caught the meager sources of light from the houses above. Everyone was asleep but I was awake, trudging through the sand.
The authoritative wind drove against me, fighting my onward movement. I could have turned around and allowed the wind to propel me safely home, but I pressed on, in a sort of trance, pressing the warm palms of my hands to my ice-cold cheeks. I remember wishing that I had donned two sweatshirts instead of one, with Ugg boots on my feet instead of sandals.
Ever since my family and I first moved here two years ago, I have been invigorated by the salty gusts of air that paired with the soft hiss of the tide. I used to walk every day, picking my way through sun-bleached rocks and finding a desolate place to read, normally a spot where I could stick my feet into the cool saltwater. Even on busy days, I’d find a way to spend some time by the shore and far from other humans. I’ve never enjoyed the ocean itself, for I have never been very good at swimming or body surfing, but the environment that surrounds the mid-Californian tide—rocks, tawny sand, and pine trees—is delicious.
At least during the day.
It’s almost as if the sun is the earth’s mother. When she drifts off to sleep and allows the darkness of the night to take over, the disobedient world has her own plans. She unleashes the obtrusive winds and the bitter cold, granting liberty to the darkness.
I had been trekking along the shore for less than ten minutes when a faint rustling settled over my ears. The sound appeared to be coming from a clump of reeds and coastal brush to my right. The branches quivered, but I wasn’t sure if they shook only because of the wind or because a creature was concealed within.
At first, I thought that it might be one of those adorable ground squirrels that burrowed under the earth and popped up when food-bearing humans were near. When I’m walking home from school, I see those little guys everywhere.
The heather gray blur that bounded out of the brush, however, was far from little. I staggered backwards with surprise as the creature galloped across the sand. My immediate assumption was that it was a wolf— I could see the gray fur, four paws, and a long tail.
The canine was gone as soon as it appeared. My senses gradually returned as a fresh gust of wind picked up and jerked the hood of my sweatshirt off my head. I glanced toward the shore, but saw nothing except for the tips of the waves. That had to have been a lost dog, I reasoned to myself, tugging the hood back on. It had been way too dark and far too fast for me to have noticed a leash or collar, but I knew it had to be a dog. A big one, yes, but a dog all the same. Wolves don’t live in California, anyway, and a coyote is too small to fit the profile of that creature.
Yes, I decided, a dog. A dog who had lost its owner.
It was then that I heard the sound that had woken me up in the first place: a low bawl, drawn out for several seconds. It was much closer now, and in the direction that the canine had gone: the ocean.
I crouched to the ground and surveyed the sand for tracks, but it was too dark to see a thing. I could go back to the house and find a flashlight, but I didn’t want to lose my place; my phone had a flashlight, but I had left it in my room. I stood up again and crossed my arms, turning my head towards the ocean, only about thirty yards away. I wanted to help the dog and find out what the bawling noise was- there was a good chance that they were connected- but I was at a loss at what to do. Maybe I could wait until my eyes had completely adjusted.
The waves surged and receded, catching flecks of topaz from the streetlamps above. I looked up at the blank sky, wishing that the moon would appear.
Within a few moments, something did appear. It wasn’t the moon, or anything in the sky. It was the dog’s silhouette, framed against the water. I could make out its thin tail and broad, shaggy mouth as it paused for a moment, then walked out, into the tide. Then it was gone.
I blinked. The dog had calmly walked into the water, without making a splash, and disappeared.
Something weird was going on.
I didn’t need the dog’s trail anymore, so I hurried to the shore, deciding that my eyes had deceived me and the dog had just jumped into the water. But as I scanned the ocean, as far as the darkness would let me, but there was nothing. Just the black waves. But, wait- the waves…
The waves in front of me just looked wrong. The section of water in front of me moved at a different pace than the other sections, and the way the waves crashed just looked, well, fake. The differences were subtle, but they were there.
I shook my head, deciding that I was going crazy.
I took a few steps backward and glanced at the row of dark houses behind me. One of them was mine, and it was to there that I had an fleeting urge to run. I could picture myself bursting into my parents’ room, yelling, There’s a big dog out there! And it just ran into the water and disappeared! And the ocean looks funny! They would think that I was delirious, and maybe I was.
But what happened next made me completely forget about escaping to my house.
My eyes, which had mostly adjusted to the darkness by then, spotted a section of the sand that appeared to be pressed down in a rectangular shape, right around where the dog had dissolved from view. The water surged forward, but instead of filling into the impression, it flowed around it. Puzzled, I waited for the water to retreat, then stuck my foot out to investigate. Instead of landing on sand, my foot landed on wood. A plank of wood, that had appeared when I had touched it. The plank was a foot in width, but stretched a few yards out, hovering above the water. I stared at it, astounded. When I lifted my foot, it disappeared, like the dog. I stepped back, oblivious to the wind that tugged at my sweatshirt and ignorant of the goosebumps that peppered my legs.
But, more than anything, I was curious. There was certainly more to it than just a wooden board. I took a deep breath and stepped onto the plank.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
James, it is not letting me reply to your review, so I will try this instead...

I look forward to meeting you at our café!
Now it's my turn to start reviewing! Go Team Black Knights!!!!
If you see two similar replies to this review, that is because I sent one earlier but it didn't show up, so I shall gladly write another one!
Aaaawwwwwwwwwww!!!!!! James, you can't imagine how happy this made me! You certainly know the best ways to make me smile and say "awww!" out loud. I never had expected to receive reviews like this one when I joined this site on April 19th! I remember waiting for someone to comment on my prologue for a good two hours before I finally went to bed, and what a surprise I had waiting for me in the morning! You're just the best, James!!!
I approve of the color-coding method you used; nice thinking! And of course, I appreciate your ratings at the end
especially when there are five stars. I am always impressed by the minute things you pick up on, such as the ebony sky and that darn "an" (I think I originally had "an urge" and when I added "fleeting" I forgot to change it).Thank you so much James, and congratulations on earning your fourth star!
Salutations, Wolfie!
When first you mentioned this short story, I was every excited to read, and I was even mroe excited when you posted the link to it; however, I had somehow forgotten about it, and for that, I apologise.
Nevertheless, I am here now, and what a joyous occasion it is! You remember that I had earned my previous star by reviewing one of your works? Well, I am currently standing at 149 reviews, so that event will now be repeated!
Also, I remember that you previously mentioned you want me to rate your pieces after reviewing them, so I shall do exactly that, but I am going to try something else as well: I have recently begun experimenting with colours in my reviews, and I find them quite useful. I am sure you will not mind if I employ them here as well.
My Legend:
Red - corrections
Orange - suggestions
Green - additions
Blue - removals
I see you have split your short story "The Iridescence of the Past" in two - that is wise. I shan't ramble on about why, since we both know why.
Your use of bawl clearly conveys the distress the calf is experiencing, especially since the onomatopoeia which would normally have been used would be something like low or bellow. Such minor differences differentiate your work from that of others.
Such lovely imagery... I can perfectly visualise the scene.
Excellent use of the semi-colon - I am so proud of you! And saying ebony instead of black indicates your wish for variety; however, I am not sure if ebony is really the best choice. You see, when I think of the night, I usually think of two combinations: when the night is dark and the moon yellow, I associate the night with the colours black and gold. When the night is lighter and the moon is full, as well as a brilliant white, I associate the night with the colours indigo and silver. If I had to describe the night sky as ebony, then I would do so when the conditions of the first set are being met. Outside of that, not really. So, if your night is ominous and the light ahs a yellow tinge, then ebony would be the most appropriate. If not, then I would say stick with either black or indigo.
Overall, your first paragraph is absolutely beautiful. If I was one of the judges (or your English teacher, depending on whether it was an assignment or entry to a competition), I would definitely be impressed, as long as the imagery is present throughout the entire piece.
<3
This is such a lovely sentence, but something about that have kept nagging at me, and I could not understand why. It appeared to be in the past tense, yet it still seemed wrong. Then I realised it was because that subordinate clause was written in the persent perfect tense. It needs to be in the past perfect tense.
Desolate is such a negative word. It makes me think of something as bare and unfriendly. Therefore, I suggest exchanging it for a word like serene or tranquil.
The conjunction in parenthesis (and) disrupts the flow of the sentence.
The words which you had written in the present perfect tense has to be changed to past perfect, but the underlined words I had left unchanged because I considered them to be written in the historic present. (Even if that wasn't your intention, just go along with it.
A perfect example of how you can make a sentence potent by placing it in a paragraph of its own - when circumstances permit it, of course.
Once again, I changed the first auxilary verb so that it is in the past tense, but left the second unchanged so as to establish the historic present again. Because of this, it is acceptable to leave the rest of the paragraph in the present.
Remember, maintaining the historic present either means indicating that the events have already occured, or continuously re-establishing it.
And besides, you only find super-coyotes in Eastern USA, particularly in New York.
As much as I support the idea that animals have souls and are itnelligent to a certain extent, they are still referred to through use of the pronouns which and that. That can be used to refer to humans, animals or objects, so I would choose it above which, which is sued exclusively for animals or objects.
Are your streetlamps really that bright that they can illumminate the ocean thirty yards away? Wow.
The indefinite article "an" we only use when the word which follows begins with a vowel, or when the sound with which that word begins is pronounced like a vowel. Otherwise, we use "a".
Now that I have finished reading part one of this enthralling short story, I want to continue with part two. Alas, part two has yet to be released. Please tag me once you have finished writing and submitting it - I shall get to it soon afterwards.
Once again, I am impressed by your skill. I am reminded of that first day when I was stumbling through the Green Room, looking for a work to review, when a prologue loomed out of the mysterious vapours. It being exactly for what I had been searching, I explored its depths and found myself transfixed. Ever since that day, the creator of the prologue, you, and I - we - have been great friends on YWS. I am once again honoured that I may review such extraordinary literature.
One day, when we are both best-selling authors, perhaps we may share a drink at a café and look back on the days when we first joined YWS, a nostalgic smile playing on our lips. Or we may be writing out of our parents' basements and have but a few coins to our name. Who knows? Either way, I am better off for having known you - even if it is jsut as Wolfie36.
Spoiler
Rating for this Text: five stars (Absolutely Superlative!)
Hi! Cricket here for a review!
I don't think I've reviewed anything for you before, so when I saw this work of yours, I couldn't resist and decided to take a look. And also seeing that this is the first part, I'm glad I showed up in time.
As KatGirl mentioned, this has a lot of description. Normally I don't like that, as I think my style usuallyleans towards an even mix of thought, description, dialogue, ect,. But here, I found that I did in fact love that there was so much description here. It was like its defining characteristic and I think you pulled it off very well.
What I was wondering though... not to seem nosy or like a stalker, but do you live in California? You're not required to answer that of course, but have you at least been there? I personally have, but have never been down near the coast at night, so I wouldn't know how it acts during the night hours. BUT, I thought it might be good to just remind you that if something so small as what the weather is like at night is messed up on, then it will stick out and somebody will catch it. Just a thought.
This line I just don't get. Like Raging was talking about, is something that I think is indeed a problem. I'm wondering, are buffalo calves common in California or something? Also, drifted past dead ears doesn't make much sense to me, but perhaps if you placed a my before dead ears it might make some more sense to me. Make sense to you at all?
Soo, here I'm really not sure if this is a typo or just a misuse of the n-dash. After tide were you meaning to have the n-dash, or the comma? I could see it as a possible typo, so just asking.
Hmm, I don't the colon was used properly here. How about an m-dash instead?
What I'm curious about here, is if this is a bit of thought process? It isn't really clear from what I can see, but I thought that perhaps it was. If it is, then the ideal way that everyone always differentiates between thought process and everything else, is putting the actual thought itself into italics. So there are a few mores spots throughout that I thought for sure were thought process, but you can be the judge and decide that.
Oh geez, noo duh...
I would have liked a little more development here, of the idea that she (?) might be going crazy. Like she's turning the idea over in her mind, trying to figure out what is going on, and then also begins to consider the idea that maybe she's going crazy. But slow it down and build it up to the fact that maybe she's going crazy. Don't just say it outright, I don't think. Not at first at least, when first presenting the idea. Just my take on it, is all.
OK, I thought that this might be a good example to use when bringing up my last issue.
Alright and that's it from me I think. What I mainly liked about this, was really the description. It's funny how it is that way, as I usually don't like the pieces that have description all throughout, but this one I do. Also, some of the descriptions were extremely cool. The way you intermixed tips of the waves and ebony sky was very well done, and I applaud you for that. It almost seemed like prose really, in some parts. Keep it up! You got this. Please tell me when you post the next part though! I'm super curious to see what's going to happen next. ^-^
Keep writing!
~Cricket
Wow, thank you so so so much, Cricket!!! This review is incredibly helpful!
Sorry about that first "buffalo calf" line. It's supposed to be a hook, but of course it will confuse you because it seems completely random, and the first part ends before its meaning can be revealed.
I can't tell you where I live, but I have visited the mid-Californian coast before. It was very cold in the evening, so I can assume that it is very, very cold at night.
What are n and m dashes? I usually try to avoid using dashes all together because I'm not really sure how to use them. I'm glad that you liked the descriptions and I will certainly work on your advice! My goal for the second part is to try to stay consistent with this one.
And yes, the main character is a she. That's another thing that could not be revealed in the first part.
Thank you so much for taking the time to read and review this!!! This is a wonderful review.
I did some research on the m and n-dashes, and I now understand what you were referring to. I did my best to edit it (using -- for n and --- for m) but I don't think I did it correctly... Aren't dashes supposed to be a complete, uninterrupted line? Like "__" except in the middle? Thanks for your help!
Yes, they are supposed to be a complete uninterrupted line. It doesn't work on here I don't think, but in Microsoft word if you do "--" and then write a word after it--after you put a space after it, it should make it a complete line. Does that help?
Ah, okay. Thank you very much!
Talk about AWESOME! This had a massive pull to it that ever mystery/suspense story should have! I found next to none in the area of improvement as the details and dry humor gave it it's third dimension! I especially like "The authoritative wind" The one thing I didn't understand was "The bawl of the buffalo calf" Where did that come from? Or did I miss something before?
~RagingLive
Thank you so much!!!
DESCRIPTIVE MUCH? I love it! xD
Haha thank you for reading it!