~ Deleted from existence ~
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hello there, kyou!
Here to you-know-what.
Okay, I can see that you have improved things better. Taking the reviewer's suggestion into an account is really good, so it really tells us that you understand and accepted those errors of yours. Anyways, sorry to be a bit late because I thought you are going to notify me.
Anyways, back to the topic. You caught my attention to read this piece until the very last word. It's also a good thing how I like your descriptions, happening around your main character. Tenses are quite good but still some awkward sentences are kind of popping out again, which means you really need to fix those up again. Spellings are good and so with your characters. You placed their emotions and thought here very well.
Punctuation, I notice that you lack commas in a sentence wherein it's really needed. They are important so the flow won't be ruined, alright?
Example:
When we read this, we can't just possibly read it straight until the last word is said. but we need to tell the readers that there is a pause happening between 'life' and 'look'. Okay?
Overall:
I must say reading this interest me. It keeps me intrigue all the time so, it's really a good thing for you as well wiith your readers. PM me for questions.
Keep writing!
Peace out!
~yuri
I was going to review this when--- what the? 'under full revision?"
and I was like " oh noes!" when I saw Coco's review...
am I too late?
Thanks, I'll see what I can do ^^' Just the problem is that I'm the only one who knows English in my family and also many of 'awkward' or non-scenery-description moments are easily solvable with a knowledge of 1st chapter, where I described the surroundings, the people he fought in 2nd chapter and the girl. (F.e. you'd find out there why she was so desperate and so on). I'll take a look at all the things I can change thanks to your review, thanks =)
Though, thanks!
Kyou
Hiya Kyou! Coco here as requested. I hope I don't dissappoint!
Here goes...
This whole paragraph needs to be worked on. The sentences in red are the one's you need to work on, as for the rest the paragraph didn't seem to flow very well. I loved the beginning, it really got me intrigued, I mean, who isn't afraid of death? I think you should play with that more, maybe mention the eternal darkness, the never ending silence, the uncertainty of the next life (if your MC is religious). After doing this I think you should set out the scene. Where is your MC, in the forest, in the town, in a battlefield, just so the reader's have a picture in their heads, then you can move on to describe your MC's situation, I'm assuming the chain mail means he's a warrior or something along those lines - build on that.
I think you mean 'The' first one...
To me this sentence could be made so much more exciting. Why don't you describe the archer, perhaps he's hooded and all your MC can make out is the archer's cold, dark eyes piercing your MC's.
I found this sentence really confusing. What does your MC mean when he's saying 'it's up to you' - elaborate. Also, what does your MC mean when he mentions his 'other self'?
So after reading this I'd say that right now, your biggest problem is awkward sentences. You have loads of them but, luckily, they're easy to fix. All you have to do is read your piece aloud, or maybe to your friends and family and you'll definitely pick up any mistakes.
Another problem is the tone of your piece. At the beginning I got a sense of a noble Knight and a really epic battle scene, like the one's in the move 'Kingdom of Heaven', but that image was lost towards the end. If you feel the whole Knight-thing isn't for you, and you want to make a more believable character with a personality and flaws (like in the move 'A Knight's Tale') than make sure your readers get a feel of that in your character's personality constantly from beginning to end so that what your character feels, says and does seems more realistic.
One last point I'll make is that your piece is lacking scenery descriptions. I always find describing characters surroundings to be vital in any story because it set's the scene, gives the reader things to imagine and it can also set the time-period
So, I hope this review wasn't too harsh, I just think that by re-editing some of this you'll have a great story in your hands. I'm looking forward to reading what happens to your character, if he gets captured by the horsemen or not. I'm also intrigued about your MC's relationship with the girl - what can I say, I'm a sucker for romance
Keep writing!
*coco