Published March 9, 2010
~ Deleted from existence ~
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Yea you got that right, now that I've calmed down it looks pretty rude. I really do not know what to write about anymore, I've thought up many themes, I used them before and posted, everything was cliche, everything was used somewhere before... I feel like a bird in a cage, no proper idea what to write about anymore so it's original all the way. Irritates me to no end.
Thanks all though! I'm going to go and get a break from writing, it seems my mind just isn't fit to write original stories.
There is no point telling readers that what appears cliched is not actually cliched. An opening scene needs to seem original (among other things) to the reader. It can't rely on the author taking half a page to explain themselves. It can't rely on the reader being bored enough to read on despite the apparent cliches in the hope that the author will discover some originality later.
Also, "counter-attacking" unpaid volunteers who take time out of their busy lives solely to help you is a little ungrateful.
My apologies, snapped out of control.
Hey! I'm KitxKat, or Kit, and I'm gonna review your work.
Anything I our in purple is a grammar error. Anything blue is anthing else
Hey there! I haven't got the time now, but I'm saving this page to review later (offline). Keep a weather eye on this spot for a review!
Jenth
EDIT:
Let’s begin, Kyousuke!
Corrected:
Now this is just the beginning, and already I’ve found so many errors! You should use a spelling and grammar checker before submitting your work. YWS even supplies one right next to the reply box. Go ahead and use it next time; it’ll only take a few minutes and make your work that much better. Another thing about this is that the prose is quite cliché, and the verb, “revealing” just doesn’t work. How can wind reveal tears? Perhaps “passed over,” or “blew past,”.
When describing the city, I don’t think you need to mention the phrase ‘two-story’ so many times, as it becomes redundant. Just tell us that it’s a good-sized town, but please don’t go into detail about each and every building, and especially don’t info-dump.
Now, the part where Kyou talks to ‘the woman’ is not very thought-out. We don’t even learn her name until the very end (Lessa) and you refer to her as ‘the woman’ for the whole first part. You do, however, have Kyou say her name (Sera) but I’m not sure which of the two are hers (Lessa, Sera) so please choose one and stick with it.
The ‘plan’ turns out to be very sketchy, since the master in velvet doesn’t even seem to know what to do. Basically, they just fight each other a month from the meeting. I really think he should give more information, since he was the person that planned it, right?
Also, he keeps going on and on about the rules (which they’ll probably break anyways) but he fails to tell them the rules! Are they already well-known? Was there only one rule (no team fighting prior to the tourney)?
Overall, you have the basic, clichéd fantasy story plot. Master and guilds and fighting tournaments. You need to bring something in that makes your novel far different from the others. What you’re saying is, “Sure it’ll be like The Lord of The Rings/Harry Potter/Eragon/Random MMORPG, but I’m putting my own spin on it!” which is about the worst thing you could do for a fantasy story.
Don't worry if the above seems harsh, you've got what can be a good start, and you'll need this and many other harsh reviews to shape the story. Keep writing! And for heaven’s sake don’t ever mention fireballs! They are so cliché!