Hey, Vil! Thanks for requesting a review <3 Let's take a look at this, shall we?
I remember reading a wall post about you extensively revising this? I believe that's true. Reading your author's notes, I definitely agree; reading old stuff is extremely cringey xD I applaud you for being able to get through revising it haha; one story I wrote in second grade is unbearable for me to read cx I'm actually pretty excited to read this because I'd love to see how you've revised this!
I agree with Lee that there's too much exposition for the first chapter, but I suppose that's pretty understandable, seeing how this is an old revised work! I'd recommend going back and checking that out. Thinning out the information a bit would be great and wow, you've planned out so much for this, like America Gone. 49 races? You're a very dedicated writer!
old Wrenwater and Salazar would love to see you disappear
It was true that she was the best Healer and smithy to be found in the North-- even among the Dwarves, her skill was unequaled-- but the Guild Masters would not dare move against her.
Ooh okay, so I like your capitalization of "Healer" - this really shows its importance. And from this, we get to know that Dwarves are amazing healers. Good to know xD
“When leaves fell during winter’s eve,
Daethdr fought the dragon old.
He slew it with his sword Eleve,
Inside the forge of gold."
Gold and a dragon and a song? This is giving me The Hobbit vibes, which is pretty cool
pulling th ribbon
Just a small little thing, you're missing the "e" of "the"
Okay so we are already going to an inn. I feel like before the characters go to an inn, you could slow down a bit and describe what is happening more and the characters more. I feel like the pace is a bit fast. And to be quite honest, with all the names and places, I'm a bit confused to what is actually going on right now xD
they waved first, calling, “Savire!”.
You don't need a period at the end of this
I feel that the ending was a bit abrupt. Maybe the Centaur is a big deal and would make for a great ending, but since the reader doesn't know much, I can't really say anything
And that's it! My main pieces of advice would be to slow down a bit, explain the characters more, but not give a lot of information about the actual world yet. Other than that, I quite enjoyed this! You've planned out another detailed world, which I'm not surprised about because I know you're great at world building c: The names you've given the characters and places are pretty neat! I love how thought-out everything is. Overall, this is a pretty cool first chapter, and I hope this helped!
Points: 29825
Reviews: 465
Donate