Hi MythMaster! Lim here with a review.
First Impressions
I quite liked Fintan as a character! I could relate to his quiet, diplomatic demeanour and his fondness for Kemetar. I was definitely rooting for him when he was trying to convince the Sparken general. The chapter generally has an ominous feel. I like that it’s more focused on one point/ event, because that highlights the impact and also makes it easier for me as a reader to follow.
Characterisation
Fintan wore a simple black and white suit, his bright blonde hair was hidden under a top hat, meaning that his small badge was the only thing distinguishing him as royalty.
I like this character introduction. It shows in just one line that Fintan is a more low-key character than Aster is (and contrasting characters are neat!) and describes his appearance.
Their ship landed shortly, and walking down the boarding ramp Fintan noticed with sadness the absence of his usual welcome.
I also like this detail and the choice to use “sadness” there. To me, it kind of suggests he’s a more sentimental / ‘softer’ character than the others we’ve met so far.
Ilfor was also set up to be polite but intimidating, and I could guess that Fintan’s persuasion wasn’t going to work. I like the way their characters bounced off of each other here and created what felt like a natural consequence.
“I see your argument was very well thought out. However while the peace agreement may have been respected under Tilcor, he was stabbed one to many times by his wife . . .
^ This was a good line! The indirectness and the bit of dark humour makes him seem all the more intimidating a character.
Ending
I thought the ending was a little bit abrupt. Before the chapter ends, Fintan kind of rehashes something that we already know:
The Sparken empire would only grow, this was not a diplomatic temporary stay as Fintans father had told him, the Sparkens had begun an invasion of the Relia System.
I kind of feel like I’m missing a sense of what Fintan’s next action will be, or how he is going to fit into the story that’s already been kickstarted by Aster in the previous chapter. Something like that would be really nice to have and create momentum moving into the next part.
Setting and Atmosphere
Something I liked about this chapter was the ominous atmosphere and how that foreshadows the results of the meeting with Ilfor. Kemetar itself already seems rather bleak, with it having a “scarred surface” and only having one city. The part where Ilfor says the general stationed there had changed was already making me think hmm, something’s not quite right here. When both of them leave their guards at the gate was also a good moment of foreshadowing, especially because of Fintan’s remark that he couldn’t take Ilfor in a fight.
I think the paragraphing and layout of the chapter has improved a lot since the first one. I felt like the story flowed a lot better here and was able to appreciate the setting more. I find it interesting that the hall is described as being mainly silver with a “red trim” – that feels the opposite of big halls you’d usually find in the real world, and so that gave it a sci-fi vibe for me.
With more grinding clinks a door on the left wall opened revealing a stairway, atop of which was a landing that opened into a large room with windows on three walls and a long meeting table in the middle.
I also like this description of the meeting place. It feels very confining, and so creates an atmosphere of hopelessness for Fintan’s cause.
Overall
I enjoyed seeing another corner of the world that you’ve developed, and being introduced to this new character. I’m definitely eager to read on and find out what else is happening to do with the Sparken’s invasions and how Aster plans to stop them.
Hope this helps, and feel free to ask for more feedback!
-Lim
Points: 41664
Reviews: 542
Donate