Published December 28, 2008
This needs work too. Oh well, It's good to keep learning! I'm never giving up. :^)
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Thanks Jigs! I'm grateful for your comments. They're just what I needed! This an old piece that I wrote before I learned about not using "to be" and words like "began." I have a past editor to thank for that. ^_^
Hey, SH, just a few quick things:
Reads better without that. Or if you'd like to keep it, I suggest changing 'beaming' to 'beamed' and 'resurrected' to 'resurrecting' -- but I think it works better without.
missing period.
I had a lot of trouble connecting with Rune. A lot of the actions are disconnected and short, and while technically sound its not only boring to read such uniformity of sentence structure, it also has the effect of distancing the reader from what's occuring as every action seems separate. You need to make this messier, mix it up a whole lot more.
I suggest in the above instance you should delete 'No. He can't be dead' - its just a cliche thought. Sounds wrong, I know, but just about every character in these situations has that thought apparently and I mean, the dialogue actively shows us in a more emphatically emotional way what that dull thought told us. It's more effective without it.
Here's an example of those short sentences, mixing these up into slighter longer sentences would work better in my opinion. There's just one too many and while it can be effective in short doses, its too choppy here.
'Rune's head turned to his direction' - clunky and unnecessary. It's an example of overwriting simple action. 'She turned' would have sufficed. In this case, I think the dialogue is enough though and the action is unnecessary.
Hm. Was it you who lectured me on words such as began? XD. Again with the overwriting here; simply say 'She was sweating'. Don't overdo it.
unintentional line break.
That's a ridiculous promise/idea. It's almost silly enough to warrant deleting. Think on that. She comes off as naive and stupid.
*
I'm going to leave it there. Generally, this was very well written. It was easy to read but I as I said before, I had a problem connecting with the piece. Given the short, choppy sentences it was hard to get a real feel for the character beyond what you told us in the info-dumps. I think, on that note, that for a sci fi you kept that under a good degree of control but when it did come out in came in chunks, just after the last quote I indicated above. I didn't really think it was necessary - this isn't a sci-fi, nor was it in the last one you wrote, a world so unique we need great blocks of back-information. It's one of those worlds and settings that's fairly common to the genre, so we infer a lot from that.
That's perfectly fine, so long as the actual story rises above the setting. In this case, I didn't really think it did. Girl's home gets destroyed so she decides in a fit of rage to join the armed forces for revenge - eh. It's a boring and very cliche plot-line for both sci-fi and fantasy stories.
The ending didn't do much for me either, I pretty much expected it. Don't get me wrong, this was a really well executed piece but nothing new was covered in it, if you know what I mean? No new ground, or new ideas were portrayed. And the ending was a little less suspenseful/dramatic because really, there was no guaranteed escape. A lowly escape pod isn't going to stand up to some warships after all. In any case, it was still a good read! Sometimes its just a relief to be able to get through something that doesn't have a tonne of errors, you know? Kudos on that.
Cheers
I cut this in half so it would be easier to read. Please review! Thanks. I appreciate any feedback whatsoever. :^)