Published January 9, 2008
.
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
After not reading this for a while, then reading it again, I happen to agree with all of you. First of all, it does need to be longer in order to hold attention. I also need to evolve and actual story. This short piece should probably go towards the middle/end of the story. Thank you all for your helpful input. : D
this needs some added work. it is to short, and i cannot make a real review because of it
This seems like a clip, a short piece of a story. And post-climax at that. Well, we don't want an excerpt with no context, we want the story. Why so short?
Have to say I liked that line.Even this part could be longer. You might start and end the same way, but include a flashback, maybe hinting at why the narrator is crying, who "he" is and the horrible thing he did. What does the bridge and the water symbolize? What does the rain symbolize?
This needs to be fleshed out a lot. Fattened up with lots of Literary Candy and cooked in the Oven of Self-Editing.
-Colleen
I'm incredebly torn with this.
It was well written, that I can't entirely deny...But why not give us more? It's just a paragraph. I don't know who she is, I can only grab at straws that represent what her problem might be. You're leaning entirely on the fact that you think your audience will be able to pick up on it: but you're too vague. If it is as I guess, she's in a relationship with someone who abuses her. Give us more proof. Give us more than her thoughts. Where is the conflict in this? I almost want to say "why should I read more" only to realize there is no more to read, which was the first problem I mentioned. It's way to short to really enjoy. Your ending is good, but only a few moments later, I feel like I have been cheated by the writer. Why couldn't they have painted more of a picture for me, wove a better, longer story? You may have wanted it to be this short, but honestly it's just disappointing your reader, and me, to make it so short.
I suggest you present her problem with more evidence, and go deeper into it. Characterize her, give her conflict, something to solve, and by the end, solve it. Even though the emotions are good, emotions don't make a good story. I might feel bad for this nameless main character of yours, but at the end of the day, will I remember her story? No. I won't even know what to call her if I was going to remember her.
I think you get what I am saying. ^_~ Best of luck! if you have any questions feel free to PM me.
Hello and welcome to YWS.
I say, you are a Svede? How interesting.
Okay, like a lot of first posts we get on the YWS, this is pretty short and doesn't really constitute a story. In actuality, you have several paragraphs that could be displayed as below. You could also stand to punctuate your paragraph as below.
Okaaayy, I'm not saying that's the perfect way to divide the paragraphs, but it's a start. As a note, because someone will tell you if you don't, you should double-space your paragraphs when you post on this website. The font is like, 8 point and it's brutal on the eyes to read when it hasn't been broken up.
This was interesting as an introduction to a conversation about to be held.
I don't like to put thoughts in quotes, because it's easy to mistake them as dialogue that way. Try putting them in italics, that's what I do.
This sounded weird and I had to read it twice. Try it like,
Knowing that God isn't merciful, I set out at a quick pace towards home.
Can't say that I agree with the theology of your statement, but that's not what I'm critiquing, is it?
Cute. Actually, I wonder why someone would spontaneously stare at the sky, but whatever...
Acch, I made my critique like, eight times as long as your post, but anyway, keep up the good work.