Hi there! I just have a couple of notes on this chapter for you.
And, actually, on the prologue and “part 1” as well, because I skimmed them last night so I wouldn’t be lost when I read this part today. Part 1 should be part of the prologue, not the first chapter, since it deals with characters outside the main story and is presumably there to show you that Jigoku Tsuushin works. I’m guessing the girl from the prologue put the boy’s name from part 1into the website and that’s why he was hit while riding his bike and then went straight to hell. But I didn’t get that until I read this chapter. I was just kind of like, “who is this kid” when I got to part 1, because (having seen the names of your main characters while I copied these into Word so I could review them at work) he didn’t seem to have anything to do with the main story. If he had been part of the prologue—for example, after a scene break like you used in the middle of this chapter—I wouldn’t have questioned it.
Okay, so that’s it for the other two chapters. Which I guess I could have actually left reviews on, but whatever. It was short, so I might as well include it here.
It’s really cool that you’ve combined Japanese culture and something that seems like demons/voodoo with the Internet. It’s a nice mix of old and modern.
It was a little weird to me to name the Japanese demons, let’s call them, before Paul knew their names, since we appeared to be in his POV more than in an omniscient POV for this chapter. It was fine after their names were mentioned.
Also, I was confused during Paul’s conversation with the demons when it came out that Lucy had not yet made the decision to get an abortion but rather was strongly considering it. Because at the beginning of this chapter, when Paul is thinking about it, it sounds as if she’s already gotten the abortion. If you make the first mention of it clearer, that would solve the problem.
A final note is that the conversation between Paul and Masaya about Jigoku Shoujo seemed too easy. I’m having difficulty explaining just what I mean, but I’ll try my best.
One thing was that Masaya told Paul all about this website he didn’t think Paul should use before it occurred to him to ask if Paul hated someone and was planning to do something about it. That was a little dense. Why would Paul even ask if he didn’t have a reason? “Have you ever hated anyone” is an awfully weird conversation starter if you aren’t thinking of someone you hate yourself.
Which wouldn’t matter, except if Masaya is so worried about other people using the website and going to hell, he should probably make sure they’re not asking so they can actually use it.
Also, Paul’s acceptance of everything was really quick. If I knew more about him at this point in the story, maybe this would make sense to me. He might be superstitious or a big believer in the supernatural. But as it stands right now, I see an ordinary college boy believing right off the bat in a website that will work some voodoo magic stuff on someone he hates. There’s not a single moment of disbelief, and for someone I know very little about, he also seems incredibly concerned about the him going to hell after he dies…which for all he knows is a long way off, plus he doesn’t know that this will work.
Of course, after reading the prologue, WE know it’ll work, which would make his disbelief and almost casual use of the site a lot creepier because he wouldn’t be worried about it at all, while meanwhile the reader is going: “Don’t do it! Do you hear me? DON’T DO IT.”
I don’t know if that bothered any other readers, but it’s just something I wanted to mention because his belief happened too quickly for me. Additionally, Paul’s hatred of his own girlfriend at the fact that she’s merely considering abortion (even if it does seem like her mind is made up) is so quick that it makes me wonder how much he ever actually loved her. But I guess that remains to be seen as I read on.
On to the next chapter!
BlueAfrica
Points: 91980
Reviews: 1737
Donate