this is an essay that i wrote for my English 100 class. the assignment was to take a memory that i had of a significant experience, and write about it in a narrative form. it took me literally 3 months, 4-5 hours a day working on it, with nearly 8 different drafts. i got an A on it..but i don't think that i deserved it. i would like that if anyone has any comments, criticism, and help to make this better, that you would post them. no matter how harsh, i need to improve. thank you. enjoy.
________________________________
The Heart Shatters
"Dustin, over here!" The sound of an angel's voice calls me over as I step off the sun bleached-yellow school bus. The sound of her voice is deafening. I struggle to catch my breath as I spot her in the crowd of elementary school children. There is a slight breeze blowing, keeping me from her. I stand, trying to find a clear path to this shining angel, my light in the world. The sky is overcast with shining gray clouds, threatening to abandon their stockpile of rain on the world. We have only minutes till class starts, I need to hurry to her. I push past the throng of students hurrying to meet up with the only thing that matters in school, friends. I reach her. This feeling in my stomach now only too common.
As we walk over to the play ground, I reflect on how we met. I remember walking into the kindergarten classroom, and being only five years old, I was very nervous about it. My mother there beside me telling me I would make lots of friends was not comforting to me…what are friends I wanted to ask. Throughout that year, I came to know one person in particular. Wendy Rosattie. The meeting was nothing special; she was just another student in class. Until we had to do a project together, making links out of strips of paper, I had seemed to have no interest with being her friend. Our links got pasted together by "accident." From that time on, we were inseparable, seldom one away from another. We would play together during recess, and after school, I would find myself at her house more than my own—her house was right down the street from mine.
The time flew by, and we kept finding ourselves in each other's classes, first grade, and then the second. Third grade came around, and again we sat next to each other. By this time, I had turned eight, and it did seem the feelings came early. I soon discovered I liked being around Wendy for reasons I couldn't explain. The feelings didn't go away, and I soon discovered what it was! I had a crush on my best friend. It was new to me, so needless to say, I didn't know what to do. I kept it to myself; after all, girls had cooties. Though, that didn't stop me from playing with her all the time before that.
Well, today is Valentines Day, and I had decided a few nights ago that I would tell her how I felt. What harm could it do? As we walk the playground, I try to bring up the nerve to do it…after all, it is the day of love…even if this is just puppy love. The bell rings. She takes off quickly for class as I follow a bit disgruntled. We take our respective seats, and are soon given paper on which to write a Valentines card for the other students. Mine is a blue heart shaped paper that folds in half at the seam. Wendy loves blue. I seize my pencil as my hand trembles, and I write. I write my heart out, as best as I can. That note would turn out to be the first and last love letter I would ever write.
When I finally finish, I sign 'Your secret admirer.' I look up at Wendy. Her head still down, her hand moving across her paper, wiping away the stray paper scraps. My mouth opens in a vain attempt to get her attention, to tell her I have a gift. The bell rings.
The class is dismissed, and Wendy grabs her money, and takes off for the lunch line. I hold onto the letter, grabbing my usual PB&J sandwich, and leave to eat. I sit at one end of the long row of tables. My friend Dylan sitting with me to my left. Wendy, for some reason, isn't sitting with me this time. She is on the other end of the tables with her friend Ann. The butterflies in my stomach start to go into a frenzied flutter. I look over at Dylan, and quietly ask him to give the letter to Wendy. He agrees to. I watch as he strolls over as if what he held was nothing important, he is so confident. I'm so envious. He leans over, hands her the letter, and comes back…simple.
Eternity passes by slowly. Suddenly Ann pops up in front of me. She asks if I had written the letter. My stomach does a ten eighty back flip. My cheeks become rosy red as I acknowledge that I had written it. Ann just grunts, and walks away, back to Wendy. I look over at them, and it's obvious that Ann is telling Wendy it was me.
Our eyes meet with anticipation, nausea. There is no sound, I'm deaf. Not the sound of kids playing tetherball, or the noise of mindless chatter among those who sit eating at the tables. It is just me and those bright, empty, hazel eyes. I'm certain that my face is showing my anxiety at this moment. Her eyes show nothing; absolutely nothing. I don't know what to make of it, but I would find out too soon. As suddenly as the fly sees the frog's tongue before it is devoured, her hands tear the words of my heart in half, devouring the fly, my heart. As an ice berg melts one drip at a time, my heart was beholding its own melting into nothing. A glacier cutting through a hillside as my heart breaks with the words on that page.
Then, her hands took the two pieces, and rip it again, and a third time. God, my eyes want to move away, to stare into nothing, to examine my heart, the damage that I could only feel, but I can't move. I am stuck in her grasp as the note that bore my all; being ripped. She looks away, severing the contact. It is as a trance is lifting. She tosses the note in the trash can, and I sit petrified, immobilized with my mouth open in shock. How long have I sat here, trying to pull myself together, gather my thoughts? The next thing I remember, I'm chasing her down. I am frantic. I walk right over to Wendy and ask why she did what she did. I don't understand what just happened. She is the only one that can explain it to me. There is just one problem with that! She's not saying anything. She turns walks away onto the playground, leaving me standing confused. The bell rings.
Ten years later, I reflect on what happened that day. I had never been given any kind of explanation. And after ten years, and many classes with her, I have yet to hear her voice. She has not said a single word to me since. I don't know what happened. But since then, I have never looked at a woman the same way.
Love is an emotional tornado. You are sucked in by it, and eaten up if you don't guard yourself. The only way to escape it is to lie low, and pray to God that you are not taken for the ride of your life, because it's just a runaway train to the heart, shattering it.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Sorry this took me so long to get to, I slightly forgot >_<
Till isn't the word, you mean until, or 'til.The comma before friends would work better as a colon [:] the underlined sentence is a fragment.
the semi colon should be taken out, I think it should be, "my all was being ripped,"
I liked it, it reminded me of my own puppy love ^_^
I only had one problem, and that was with the narration. I think the problem is due to it being in first person; you are overwhelmingly introspective, and doing a lot of telling about feelings and such, which really ruins it. And at the beginning, you narrate/tell the story, and it ruins it in the slightest. The story its self though, is good. The voice was mature for the story, making first person, again, a little off. But you are writing this ten years later, which you state in the closing, so overall it works.
The closing reminded me of a song I know:
Love is a wild animal
You fall into its trap
It stares into your eyes
Spellbound when its gaze hits you
Best of luck--hope I helped.
thank you for the help. kitty15, you do awesome work. i am using many of those changes. and Alainna, and you as well. thank you for pointing out many things such as the repeats. i will definitely make sure that i change it up so that it all fits better. your critiques have been priceless.
I haven't forgotten about you! Ok, the easiest way is for me to just throw comment into the body of text, here, so I will! Different colors are just for fun
And because I'm easily amused. Also, before I start, I may go and change tenses, because that really bothered me. You used present in the first part, and the second, and the first was in the past. Thus, it didn't make sense in my head at first.
"Dustin, over here!" The sound of an angel's voice calls me over as I step off the sun bleached-yellow school bus. The sound of her voice is deafening. I struggle to catch my breath as I spot her in the crowd of elementary school children. There is a slight breeze blowing, keeping me from her. I stand, trying to find a clear path to this shining angel, my light in the world. The sky is overcast with shining gray clouds, threatening to abandon their stockpile of rain on the world. We have only minutes till class starts, I need to hurry to her. I push past the throng of students hurrying to meet up with the only thing that matters in school, friends. I reach her. This feeling in my stomach now only too common.
As we walk over to the play ground, I reflect on how we met. I remember walking into the kindergarten classroom, and being only five years old, I was very nervous about it. My mother there beside me telling me I would make lots of friends was not comforting to me…what are friends I wanted to ask. Throughout that year, I came to know one person in particular. Wendy Rosattie. The meeting was nothing special; she was just another student in class. Until we had to do a project together, making links out of strips of paper, I had seemed to have no interest with being her friend. Our links got pasted together by "accident." From that time on, we were inseparable, seldom one away from another. We would play together during recess, and after school, I would find myself at her house more than my own—her house was right down the street from mine.
The time flew by, and we kept finding ourselves in each other's classes, first grade, and then the second. Third grade came around, and again we sat next to each other. By this time, I had turned eight, and it did seem the feelings came early. I soon discovered I liked being around Wendy for reasons I couldn't explain. The feelings didn't go away, and I soon discovered what it was! I had a crush on my best friend. It was new to me, so needless to say, I didn't know what to do. I kept it to myself; after all, girls had cooties. Though, that didn't stop me from playing with her all the time before that.
Well, today is Valentines Day, and I had decided a few nights ago that I would tell her how I felt. What harm could it do? As we walk the playground, I try to bring up the nerve to do it…after all, it is the day of love…even if this is just puppy love. The bell rings. She takes off quickly for class as I follow a bit disgruntled. We take our respective seats, and are soon given paper on which to write a Valentines card for the other students. Mine is a blue heart shaped paper that folds in half at the seam. Wendy loves blue. I seize my pencil as my hand trembles, and I write. I write my heart out, as best as I can. That note would turn out to be the first and last love letter I would ever write.
When I finally finish, I sign 'Your secret admirer.' I look up at Wendy. Her head still down, her hand moving across her paper, wiping away the stray paper scraps. My mouth opens in a vain attempt to get her attention, to tell her I have a gift. The bell rings.
The class is dismissed, and Wendy grabs her money, and takes off for the lunch line. I hold onto the letter, grabbing my usual PB&J sandwich, and leave to eat. I sit at one end of the long row of tables. My friend Dylan sitting with me to my left. Wendy, for some reason, isn't sitting with me this time. She is on the other end of the tables with her friend Ann. The butterflies in my stomach start to go into a frenzied flutter. I look over at Dylan, and quietly ask him to give the letter to Wendy. He agrees to. I watch as he strolls over as if what he held was nothing important, he is so confident. I'm so envious. He leans over, hands her the letter, and comes back…simple.
Eternity passes by slowly. Suddenly Ann pops up in front of me. She asks if I had written the letter. My stomach does a ten eighty back flip. My cheeks become rosy red as I acknowledge that I had written it. Ann just grunts, and walks away, back to Wendy. I look over at them, and it's obvious that Ann is telling Wendy it was me.
Our eyes meet with anticipation, nausea. There is no sound, I'm deaf. Not the sound of kids playing tetherball, or the noise of mindless chatter among those who sit eating at the tables. It is just me and those bright, empty, hazel eyes. I'm certain that my face is showing my anxiety at this moment. Her eyes show nothing; absolutely nothing. I don't know what to make of it, but I would find out too soon. As suddenly as the fly sees the frog's tongue before it is devoured, her hands tear the words of my heart in half, devouring the fly, my heart. As an ice berg melts one drip at a time, my heart was beholding its own melting into nothing. A glacier cutting through a hillside as my heart breaks with the words on that page.
Then, her hands took the two pieces, and rip it again, and a third time. God, my eyes want to move away, to stare into nothing, to examine my heart, the damage that I could only feel, but I can't move. I am stuck in her grasp as the note that bore my all; being ripped. She looks away, severing the contact. It is as a trance is lifting. She tosses the note in the trash can, and I sit petrified, immobilized with my mouth open in shock. How long have I sat here, trying to pull myself together, gather my thoughts? The next thing I remember, I'm chasing her down. I am frantic. I walk right over to Wendy and ask why she did what she did. I don't understand what just happened. She is the only one that can explain it to me. There is just one problem with that! She's not saying anything. She turns walks away onto the playground, leaving me standing confused. The bell rings.
Ten years later, I reflect on what happened that day. I had never been given any kind of explanation. And after ten years, and many classes with her, I have yet to hear her voice. She has not said a single word to me since. I don't know what happened. But since then, I have never looked at a woman the same way.
Love is an emotional tornado. You are sucked in by it, and eaten up if you don't guard yourself. The only way to escape it is to lie low, and pray to God that you are not taken for the ride of your life, because it's just a runaway train to the heart, shattering it.
This piece was very emotive and it was that that kept my attention the whole way through.
You mention her voice twice, very close together. I suggest you scrap one (the latter) as you mention it later.
Again your words are repetitive; which is OK, but from your other descriptions it's obvious that you could be a bit more ambitious.
Exclamation mark seems out of place.
Expand on PB&J please because us English aren't that quick on abbreviations such as that!
I like this!
Very poetic.
I loved this last paragraph, it's a great ending to the piece.
Overall, I like your style of writing and it works well. I can totally relate to you (at least yours didn't get burnt....may have been 5 years ago but still hurts!!!!!) and that's what makes it so captivating.
Have you shown this to Wendy? May change things if you still know her...
All the best,
Alainna
xxxxxxxxx
This piece is full of raw emotion and I found it really easy to relate to what you was feeling because you described it so well. I do have a few pointers though...
Other than that, it's very good and I'm sure you deserved the grade you got and deserved it double after what you've been through. Have you tried to talk to her since? I can half relate to your experience because I lost a best friend once but we weren't close in the same way you two seemed to be. I think if you make a few changes to this piece it can be even better and if you ever do a re-write I'll be glad to read it. Hope some of this helped,
Heather xx