Hello friend!
Here to give this wonderful short its second review!
Per my interpretation, this was a really great and quite introspective short story!
A young man named Carlos is experiencing quite a bit of trouble in his life. Having grown up poor, he had to turn to selling drugs and stolen items to make money. However, this is not the life he wants to live. It isn't what makes him feel good. So, he decides to try his luck at the church. And lucky for him, he gets the guidance he needs to do better in his life.
This was really well done and seemingly motivational!
If I could offer any sort of advice, it would be related to your dialogue throughout the story. There were a few parts where you didn't quite do it right...
One example is when you said,
“I wish I could have made things better” I thought to myself as I headed down towards tenderloin street in San Francisco.
There should be commas between dialogue and speech tags, so something like this would look more like...
“I wish I could have made things better,” I thought to myself as I headed down towards tenderloin street in San Francisco.
Another dialogue mistake is in the second-to-last paragraph. Since everything was being spoken by Carlos, it all could have been within the same quotation marks, except for when speech tags were added.
But if you wanted to keep it all separate, you could make it look more like...
“Please grant me truth in my life and heal my pain.
"I suffer just as much as the people I see every day, and though I never ask you for help I hope you can help me now.
“Show me the truth oh Lord, and raise me from hatred and vice.”
But, obviously, these are just suggestions, and it's always up to the writer, so please take this criticism lightly and know that I mean nothing negative by it—only trying to provide a somewhat useful critique.
If I had to pick my favorite part, it would have to be related to the way you showed all of Carlos' inner conflict throughout the story! You showed how much he wanted to be a better person, even though he couldn't really because of his situation, in a really creative way!
The first thing that stood out to me in relation to Carlos' inner conflict appears when Carlos was looking at his old ID photo, and you said,
I didn’t recognize the same person that I saw in my I.D. photo, even though they captured my face and lips in perfect detail.
This did a fantastic job of showing how much certain work can change someone and, in this case, even cause them to not see themselves as themselves. Carlos is looking at a picture of himself, but he's so disconnected from who he is that he doesn't really recognize it as himself at all. It's just someone who exactly looks like him. This little tidbit did wonders at showing how a certain lifestyle can make you feel detached from yourself, so kudos to you for writing it this way!
Another thing that caught my eye in regards to Carlos' inner conflict came a little later, when he was outright questioning all of his decisions in life. You said,
“Why am I living like this?”, “Why are things so bad yet so good in other ways?”, “Why don’t I give to the poor as often as I should?”
This is the perfect picture of Carlos' inner struggles... He's questioning himself and everything he's done, wondering why he's not better, which ultimately leads him to finding his way.
The way you showed that inner turmoil can lead you to do great things to fix yourself was really well done, and it was a wonderful message to send to your readers! You did a phenomenal job with the theme of this story!
Overall, this was a really great short story! I had a lot of fun reading it and really enjoyed how you showed Carlos' character! You did great work here!
Thank you for taking the time to write and post this, and I hope this review is of some use to you!
Goodbye for now! I hope you have a magnificent day (or night) wherever you are!
Points: 39462
Reviews: 151
Donate