rip

by Shimmer

Published March 24, 2006

In Old Poetry

PreviousNext

I really like this. Nothing else to say, I guess. Just good work..

-*Shimmer

Comments & reviews · 3
User avatar
xanthan gum
Review
xanthan gum wrote a review Review · Mar 25, 2006

Self-piteous and cliche ridden? Perhaps. But who isn't? And I believe the way that Brad writes such overrun themes transforms it into something a bit more. Actually, on a truly outside perspective view, all of his poetry (and many of the critics, I am sure) is much like this.

Wow. I've never defended somebody before.

Moving on -

because my hand you will always have, and my voice
you will always hear.

although grammatically correct, this was awkward. just..rephrase it or something. please.

User avatar
ZanyPlebeian
Review
ZanyPlebeian wrote a review Review · Mar 24, 2006

This was written technically well, but not terribly originally. I did see a fine number of cliches in it, though they didn't make me hate the poem. I would have to agree with the above poster that it does come across as quite self-piteous. Overall, I would just attempt to clean out some of the overdone "I love you" stuff.

Brian

User avatar
Firestarter
Review
Firestarter wrote a review Review · Mar 24, 2006

so I'll stay up
all night and write an inconsequential poem
you will never read.


Uh, Brad, come on. That was self-piteous.

I found it teeming with cliches and well, self-piteous. Maybe you were trying to grovel for sympathy in this poem, because the image I got was of you begging of your knees as I read this. While some parts were good (I find it ironic I look my best when I feel my worst) the last stanza I would totally change. The "I need you, I love you" bit ... just no. Express it in a different way.



He who knows only his own generation remains forever a child.
— Cicero