Val: 5

I woke up early the next day, feet tangled in the sheets. Minutes later, I was alone in the kitchen, bent over a bowl of Honey Oats. Mom was in the shower. Bage was asleep. Eating breakfast alone had become ritual over the past few weeks; it felt like my family and I were always forced to maintain separate schedules.

It was seven o'clock in the morning, and your girlfriend knocked on the door.

I tugged on the doorknob, and door swung inwards. Alena was standing on the porch. Like always, she looked unfathomably pretty; her white-blond hair was pin-straight, and fell just below her shoulders. Her skin was unblemished, and her scarlet nails tapped against her lower cheek. Magenta lipstick complimented her brown eyes. Her dark eyebrows were waxed and arched. My first instinct was to smile at her. She smiled back. She was wearing a floral jumper with shorts that rode up so far, I almost mistook her outfit for a bathing suit.

She was perfect for you.

"Alena," I greeted, feigning surprise. Her morningly visit was not abnormal. She’d been making more trips to my doorstep of late, whether with the newest gossip or a cup of coffee. She would often offer to drive me to school. She craved all aspects of friendship, and she needed to have me at her disposal for all hours of the day.

For some reason, the very sight of her dragged my heart down in my chest. "Hey."

"Hey!" She rushed forward and threw her bangled wrists around my neck. I hugged her back.

"What's up?" I asked, folding my arms and allowing her to follow me into the kitchen. I resumed where I had left off on my Honey Oats. I was still wearing pajamas. Alena seemed undeterred by all of those facts.

She smiled widely, beginning to run a hand through her hair, and then stopped mid-rake as if she was wary of ruining her hairdo. "I told Jet on the phone—I don't know if he told you—but I got a job." Her voice rose in pitch over the course of the sentence. It was a squeak by the time she finished. She bit her lip, anticipating my reaction.

Shock had jumpstarted the time of my reaction. With a moment’s delay, my face lit up. I jumped from my seat. "Alena!" I swept her into another hug, and then pulled back immediately to grab her hands in mine. "That's great!"

Part of me was just relieved that Jet and Alena would no longer be arguing about money. I hated seeing him mad, and lately—despite my love for her—Alena had only been a nuisance to his budget. She was Jet's little sister, but she wasn’t little any longer. I was glad she'd finally gotten around to growing up.

"It's in modeling," Alena told me, her voice jittery with elation, "Abercrombie & Fitch." Her expression faltered. "Well, if I get the job. It’s a big if. There's a party Saturday night, where I'll be introduced to the guy that'll be working with me, or whatever, and then we'll do a few practice shots. Filming me and everything." She was suddenly overwhelmed and ruminative. She was pacing the tile floor. "It's so prestigious,” she fretted. “And I'm gonna need a dress. And—“

"Alena," I interrupted. She looked at me, flustered.

I placed my hands on her shoulders. I could feel her relax with my touch. "You’re beautiful,” I insisted. “You're gonna be amazing."

Relief graced her face, smoothing the worry-vein above her brows. "And we can get you a dress, no problem." The corner of my mouth curved in a smile. "As a matter of fact, I think we oughta arrange a shopping trip."

A glimpse of excitement passed behind her eyes, and the light winked out almost as abruptly as it came. "But the party's Saturday,” she said. “It's already Tuesday."

"I can take time off work," I reasoned. Taking time off of work wouldn't be ideal, but I was willing to sacrifice a fraction of my income if it meant Alena would stop haggling Jet for money.

"That's really sweet of you, but I'll have to order a dress online. Chris and I are going out." The excitement was back. "He has something for work tonight, a football game tomorrow, and then he told me he'd take me out for the rest of the week." Alena suppressed a grin, and now ran her hands through her hair, forgetting the possibility of ruination.

It took me a moment to realize that she was talking about you.

"God, he's something else," she told me, not bothering to stifle her urge to digress. Her mind was elsewhere. "He's sweet, and charming, and boy, is he hot. Every time I think about his eyes, I melt." She leaned her elbows on the tabletop. She closed her eyes, and inhaled deeply, as if in a dream. Then her eyes opened again. "I think he's the one.”

I was at a loss for words. Again, your keen methods of deception impressed me. Your casual mention of the ‘work’ you were going to be preoccupied with tonight, your slip of a lie, your tenacity to appear as something you weren’t. Whenever possible, you ensured that everything you said contained at least a vague semblance of the truth. That, I think, is was what irked me the most. It was often hard for me to find the proof that you'd lied at all.

Shortly thereafter, Alena left. She offered to give me a ride to school, and I reminded her that I could drive just fine, to which she grinned and claimed that I couldn’t say she never did anything for me.

She told me she'd let me know when she found a dress, and then she sauntered out the door.

School was hell that day. I daydreamed of 100 meter–dashes in Physics, my ear pressed to the desktop; I tapped my finger on the underneath of the desk and imagined the rumble of the bleachers as I sped around the rust-red track, as if airborne, kicking up rubber, kicking up rubber, kicking up rubber.

Economics. Mr. Norton was a quiet rambler. Kelsey McGuire tapped my hand with her pencil, a gesture she often used to get my attention. Her petite figure hunched in her seat. She whispered softly. "So.”

"What?"

Norton droned on, his lecture becoming the background to our conversation. My notes dwelled on my desk, unwritten, and I could hear you and David Miller suppressing laughter at the back of the room.

Kelsey blinked at me. "You keep looking at Chris Mahoney," she told me. "You think I haven't noticed?"

My cheeks heated, and I felt a blush creep onto my face. Had I been looking at you?

"You on a revenge kick, or something?” Kelsey asked. She gazed at me through the lenses of her black-rimmed glasses.

I cleared my throat. "I'm still pissed, if that's what you mean."

"I'm sure Jet and Chris can handle their own problems. They're big boys.”

Nausea festered in the pit of my stomach. I felt septic. Exhaling, I leaned in closer. I told her to remind me to tell her something after class. Unlike you, I did not like keeping secrets.

Her eyes narrowed at me suspiciously. She crossed her legs, clad in acid-wash skinny jeans. She nibbled on the end of her pencil; it was a habit she acquired shortly after her sister left for law school. Anxiety was her Achilles heel.

"Okay," she said, drawing out the ‘y’.

"Girls and boys," Mr. Norton chastised. His blue marker froze mid-stroke on the whiteboard. "Quiet down, please."

His eyes flitted to Kelsey and me, and then at the group behind us. I used the opportunity to glance behind me. Your chair was flipped backwards, forearm resting on the seat-back. David was making Chinese footballs with his notepaper. Robert Hayworth stretched over the desk in front of him, handing something to David. You were hiding something in your desk; your phone, I surmised. Alena sat on your other side, palm cradling your elbow. She craned her neck over your shoulder. Your eyes rose to meet Norton's gaze, mouth mid-smile.

You saw me. We made eye contact for the briefest of moments. I hastily looked away, turning back around in my seat.

"Yeah, girls," you teased to our backs, grin in your voice.

"Yeah, girls," David echoed.

"That's enough," Mr. Norton said coolly, returning to the notes he’d been scrawling on the board.

With much chagrin, Kelsey cast a wayward glance in my direction. Later, it said.

After class, I left hurriedly. Kelsey scampered after me, toting her books in one arm. Jet, who had English across the hall, emerged and walked over to meet me. I kissed him on the cheek. "Hey, you," I said, smiling.

He smiled back, entwining his fingers through mine. "Hey. How was—what is it, History?"

"Economics," I corrected. "It was okay. Same old. Mr. Norton tries to keep order in class, but fails miserably."

“I blame it on the herd of cows at the back of the room,” Kelsey said from behind us. She sidled up next to me. “They talk faster than they chew.”

"Hey there, Kelsey," Jet said, nodding.

"Hi," Kelsey replied. Then, looking at me, “Kos, what was it you had to tell me?" She pushed a lock of hair behind her ear. My heart skipped a beat.

Jet watched me nonchalantly, awaiting my answer to her question.

"Um," I stammered. My mind fumbled for a quick lie; enviously, I marveled at your ability to do such flawless improv.

"I was just gonna tell you that I joined Yearbook,” I answered finally.

Kelsey did a double-take, and then laced her elbow with mine. Her voice rose with excitement. "You did? Really? When?"

I cleared my throat. I was nervous, and could nearly feel perspiration seeping through the fabric of my shirt. "Yesterday,” I replied. “Ms.—uh, what's her name again?"

"Zennia. Ms. Zennia."

"Yeah," I covered, "yeah, well, she told me to type up senior profiles during lunch. I'm officially a member, I guess." I managed a smile, glancing at Kelsey. She didn’t seem to be buying it.

"But, you weren't at the meeting after school," she countered, brow knitting suspiciously. "And Ms. Zennia didn't say anything about a new member." She fingered her chin as if in thought. "To think of it, I don't remember any of the papers for the profiles even coming in."

Jet observed the conversation. Kelsey was staring at me. Anxiety rebelled like tin soldiers in my stomach: shooting, crying, blood, war. "Well," I said, a bit too quickly, "a few of them must've come in, because she gave me nearly ten to type up. And I had work. I couldn't make it to the meeting."

I smiled furtively, shrugging. Shooting, crying, blood, war. I prayed for her to believe me.

After what felt like a lifetime, Kelsey shot me a good-natured grin. "We can be co-editors, if you keep with it till next semester,” she offered. She bumped my shoulder. The soldiers in my stomach retreated, as if allowing me a brief breather.

I smiled in return. The three of us entered the cafeteria. Jet was the first of us in line, was the first to leave for the lunchroom. Once I had finished spooning ketchup on my chicken patty, I pulled Kelsey aside.

I glanced around. "Why are you acting so weird?" Kelsey persisted.

"I didn't join Yearbook," I muttered, lowering my eyes.

Her eyebrows rose slowly. "What d'you mean?" Her expression contorted suddenly, as if coming to a revelation. “And why the hell did you lie to me?”

"Do you promise not to tell anyone anything?" I asked, raising my eyebrow. Her eyes searched mine. “There’s a good reason I lied to you. I’ll explain, if you promise you won’t tell.”

"Sure," she relented, her tone leveling. "I promise."

We moved to the corner by the salad bar. An aroma of olives, tomatoes, and onions wafted beneath our noses. As we huddled together, some douchebag with a plate of salad jostled Kelsey’s shoulder, sending her extra quarters flying towards the slick tile. “Watch it,” she told the douchebag, who bit back a laugh.

“Asshole,” I called after him, and retrieved her quarters from the floor.

“Thanks,” Kelsey said. “I’ll get you next time?”

She and I had made a deal last year. It held that if somebody wronged one of us, the other had to step up and defend them. Normally, we took turns. She technically owed me one.

“Don’t worry about it,” I said, knowing that anything I said would fail to deter her. There was nothing that could separate either one of us from the other.

Without further ado, I explained everything. From the first text you sent me to the plans we had to meet at your house later that night. It felt good to tell her the works of what had been going on. To lift a bit of the weight. You were too big of a secret to keep.

Kelsey's eyes widened at every word. At the conclusion of my speech, her hand rose to her mouth. She began to nibble on the white of her nail where the teal polish had chipped away.

"You know why a guy asks a girl to his house, right?" she asked skeptically.

"I thought of that,” I told her, snorting. I picked a fry from my plate and ate it. “But I dunno. This feels different. It seems like he has good intentions."

Kelsey barked out a shrewd laugh. "Chris, ‘good intentions’? Did you honestly just say that?" She shook her head, like she'd had a sip of whiskey that was stronger than expected. It took me back to the party; your drunken stupor, Alena kissing just beneath your navel. Over and over, like that was the best spot for kissing. I snapped out of the memory.

"I thought you were more perceptive than that,” Kelsey said.

I blushed, fearing that I was being ignorant. Were you about to have me fooled?

Kelsey stirred the ladle in the ketchup absently, making a whirlpool. Other students approached and cast resentful glances in Kelsey's direction, likely with the hope that she'd step away from the condiments. Kelsey did, walking back over to where I was standing. Suddenly, I remembered the time. Jumping a bit, I retrieved my phone from my pocket and clicked it to life. 11:51. Nearly ten minutes into the lunch period.

"I have to go," I told my friend.

I jogged away. I was late to meet you.

"You're at Yearbook if he asks, right?” Kelsey called after me. I shushed her and nodded. I poked my head back into the cafeteria to thank her, but her attention was already recaptured by Robert and David, who had just reached the end of the lunch line. Your cronies. Kelsey was friends with the two of them.

I made a dash to the old preschool classroom, skirting past the janitor with the Braves cap. When I arrived, I barreled through the door, plate bobbling dangerously in my hands. You were standing right inside the door, awaiting my arrival. You bounced on your toes. My momentum carried me forward, and the chicken patty soared from my plate and towards your white T-shirt.

I inhaled sharply. With the reflexes of a cat, your hand shot out in front of you and snatched the sandwich from the air.

"Whoa!" you exclaimed. "Christ, first you show up late. Then you try to ambush me."

I was too shocked to speak. You took my plate from me gently. My forefinger brushed your pinkie. You didn't notice. The smushed patty dropped from your fist and onto the plate. You surveyed the ketchup spread across your palm. I was blushing.

"Sorry," I choked out. You looked at me from the tops of your eyes. Cocked your head and smiled a little, like a puppy.

"You're lucky I'm quick on my feet,” you told me. You handed my plate back. "Not sure if you wanna eat that after my hands’ve been all over it."

I dumped the plate’s contents in the trash can. "It's bad for business, anyway," I claimed. "Besides. They're nasty even without your germs."

"My germs make it better," you said.

"Let's not get ahead of ourselves."

We sat down at our regular table. You whipped out a copy of the Game Plan, which looked more like a playbook than anything by now. X's and O's were like a second language to you, and it reflected in your simple handwriting. You felt the need to circle things and underline them multiple times, and were constantly making maps of sorts. X's littered the paper. In your book, erasers didn’t exist.

"Is that where the treasure is?" I asked you once, placing my finger in the center of an X you'd drawn in the corner of the paper.

"No," you said, laugh a quick rumble in your throat before you went on to explain. "It's where Subway is." Your hand moved to adjust the paper. I saw where our fingers might have touched, and hastily pulled my hand away.

"I know where Subway is," I told you, frowning.

"Yeah, well I forget things sometimes. I have STML."

"You're just saying that," I insisted.

"Nah, I'm serious." Serious. Another word I didn’t think you knew how to epitomize.

You gnawed on the lip of your Pepsi can, brows furrowing. You stared at the Game Plan in contemplation. It was strange to watch you think; you were somehow more vulnerable when you struggled with your thoughts. It was strange to see you when you weren't in control. Your legs drifted slightly apart, kneecaps poking from underneath the hem of your shorts. You were wearing low-backed Adidas shoes. Your left heel tapped ever-slightly on the carpet. The back of your T-shirt was caught in the waistband of your shorts.

I averted my eyes as you shrugged on your jacket. The bell rang. "Oh!" you exclaimed suddenly, snap-clapping. "Guess what?"

"What?" I asked, feigning disinterest.

"Guess what I got?" you asked. When I looked, you were wearing a goofy grin.

"What?" I repeated.

"Oh, it's so good," you raved, "so good." You were rifling through your backpack.

"What is it?" I demanded.

"New cleats," you told me, unsheathing a pair of neon-yellow Nike shoes with spikes. "Nobody's gonna sack this quarterback with these babies runnin' the turf." You shoved them into my hands. "Look. Smell 'em. Don't they smell good? Hot, aren’t they?"

I blinked, holding them away from me before handing them back to you. "They're bright enough to blind the Queen of England," I stated.

"Well, Westmore is a bunch of princesses. They'll probably run off the field crying.." The corner of your mouth curled in a smirk. You drew your arm back, and pretended to throw your shoe like a football. It slipped from your hand, and you hastily caught it.

"Princesses, huh?" I asked, watching as you messed with your cleats.

"Yup," you reiterated, "We're gonna beat their asses tomorrow night." I glanced at you, smiling a little.

"C'mere," I ordered, lifting the edge of the table we'd been sitting at. "Help me with this." You came over beside me, picked up the entire table, and stowed it beside the bookcase. Again, I watched as you did it, searching your eyes. I still hate you, goddammit, don't you remember? I feared that if you didn't, the feeling of hatred would fade from existence and I'd find it as easy to forget as you did.

Comments & reviews · 4
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

User avatar
Carlito
Review
Carlito wrote a review · Sun Jan 29, 2017 4:47 am

Hello again! :D

She was perfect for you.

And why is that? Is it due to her appearance? Personality? Is this Val’s way of trying to shut down her own feelings about Chris and the fact that they’d actually be perfect for one another? ;) (I will not stop pushing this until it happens.)

Her morningly visit was not abnormal.

Adverbs  (Also, “morningly” isn’t a word).

"God, he's something else," she told me, not bothering to stifle her urge to digress. Her mind was elsewhere. "He's sweet, and charming, and boy, is he hot. Every time I think about his eyes, I melt." She leaned her elbows on the tabletop. She closed her eyes, and inhaled deeply, as if in a dream. Then her eyes opened again. "I think he's the one.”

I’m curious to know more about Val and Alena’s history. It was already mentioned that it’s common for Alena to just show up, but is this kind of honesty or these kinds of declarations normal for Alena? Has she ever alluded to feeling this way before or is this out of the blue and surprising for Val to hear?

Shortly thereafter, Alena left. She offered to give me a ride to school, and I reminded her that I could drive just fine, to which she grinned and claimed that I couldn’t say she never did anything for me.
She told me she'd let me know when she found a dress, and then she sauntered out the door.

I’m curious to know how Val responded to Alena’s proclamation. If I laid that kind of confession out on someone and they just stared at me mute, I would assume they either didn’t support me or didn’t agree with me and neither would sit well. And since Val LIKES CHRIS, I’d be very curious to see how she navigates these waters.

"I was just gonna tell you that I joined Yearbook,” I answered finally.

I feel like she was planning on telling Kelsey something else but chickened out when Jet was there. I’d be curious for some of her thoughts at some point before this moment to show us what she was planning on saying so it’s clear that this was not her intention and she’s still trying to protect herself.

"But, you weren't at the meeting after school," she countered, brow knitting suspiciously. "And Ms. Zennia didn't say anything about a new member." She fingered her chin as if in thought. "To think of it, I don't remember any of the papers for the profiles even coming in."

Oh this is too good. I was wondering when she would get caught in this lie. I feel like it’s pretty hard to fake that you’re in yearbook… Eventually this is going to catch up to her…

"Do you promise not to tell anyone anything?" I asked, raising my eyebrow. Her eyes searched mine. “There’s a good reason I lied to you. I’ll explain, if you promise you won’t tell.”

I’d be interested in a bit of inner monologue about why she feels this intense need to tell someone the truth, and why she chooses Kelsey for the job. This is a big secret and could be big consequences if the truth were to get out. Is her conscious already weighing on her? Is she just too excited about the plan? Does she need to tell someone so she can validate her feelings or so this can start to feel real?

"You're at Yearbook if he asks, right?” Kelsey called after me.

Calling this out seems like a pretty good way to out a secret. They’re in a lunch room, anyone could hear this and make assumptions about what she’s talking about.

We sat down at our regular table. You whipped out a copy of the Game Plan, which looked more like a playbook than anything by now. X's and O's were like a second language to you, and it reflected in your simple handwriting. You felt the need to circle things and underline them multiple times, and were constantly making maps of sorts. X's littered the paper. In your book, erasers didn’t exist.

I like this parallel to the X’s and O’s that were mentioned in the preface. I know she was doing them then, but since that event happened after this event, it’s like a precursor for how she would think to or know how to do that.

"Yeah, well I forget things sometimes. I have STML."
"You're just saying that," I insisted.

What does STML stand for? I would include a line here where she has him clarify what it means and then “you’re just saying that…”

I still hate you, goddammit, don't you remember? I feared that if you didn't, the feeling of hatred would fade from existence and I'd find it as easy to forget as you did.

It’s cute that she still thinks she hates him ;)
Has she justified why she’s doing all of this if she hates him? (I’m pretty sure she has, but still). My evidence that she likes him but just doesn’t want to admit it stands.
And what are her reasons for hating him? The history and beef involving her boyfriend and the fact that he has a reputation and she likes him but shouldn’t? I suppose that’s enough good reasons :p

I appreciate that you show another character in this chapter and start to show her relationship with a friend. I'm wondering if there will be any consequences for her decision to tell this friend about Chris. I get wanting to get the secret off of her chest, but does she have any reservations about doing so? Does she fear anything going wrong, or does she 100% trust her friend?

I'd also be curious to see some of Val's thought processes about Chris during their conversations. Especially when they're talking about something or finishing up a conversation and he switches into talking about sports. I think Val has already made it clear that she's not super into sports or super interested in sports talk. I'm wondering if Chris is aware of this and simply doesn't care and finds it fun to annoy her so to speak by always talking to her about sports, or if he's just blissfully unaware. (I'm sort of leaning towards option one :p). But I would love to see more of how his words affect her in the moment and what she thinks of what he's saying in the moment.

I'm tired, so I better stop there, but I'll be back to finish tomorrow! :D I'm still very much digging this story. The plot isn't anything revolutionary and nothing terribly crazy is happening, but you draw your reader in with the quality of the prose and really, you don't need a super complex plot to make a good story. I kind of like that you're keeping things simple and you're sticking to the truly important parts of the story.

As always, let me know if you have any questions or if you want feedback about something I didn't already mention, and I'll see you soon! :D

Thanks so much again!

While I don't like to spoil too much ;), Alena is definitely very extroverted and open, especially to Koskia (who Alena considers to be her best friend). They have a longer history, seeing that Alena is Jet's sister, and Koskia and Jet have been dating for awhile. So, honesty and being straight-up is definitely common between them. Especially on Alena's end, since she likes to talk a lot more. This will most likely become more obvious in later chapters.

There's much work to be done in terms of revealing my characters intentions. Hopefully I can deliver.

(Also, I know I've said this before, but the little fixes you mention are super helpful as well. I might not always call attention to them in my responses, but they'll be life-savers when it comes to editing. :))

Super glad you're finding the reviews helpful! :D And I can definitely see that with Alena - that's she's just naturally more extroverted and open about her feelings. I'm a lot more like Koskia in that regard and keep things to myself which was probably why I was like why is she doing this :p

User avatar
reneehope
Comment

I feel like this guy is going to be her undoing and I can't stand it but can't help back and sit back as I watch it unfoldddd. Also. The "her Achilles heal was anxiety" was so good. You do so well. Okay... onto the next chapter :)
xx
Renee

thanks so much! <3

User avatar
Rydia
Review
Rydia wrote a review · Sun May 29, 2016 10:12 am

It's review day so I came here to give you a hug (and maybe a review...)

Specifics

1.

I twisted and tugged on the doorknob, and opened the door.
Has it been previously established that this is a stiff door? This seems a bit odd if not because having both twisted and tugged makes it sound like the door was a lot of hassle to open but then you don't follow that up or tell us that the character now feels frustrated. If there's no significance to the twisting and turning on the doorknob then this sentence would be more effective if combined with the next - 'I opened the door to Alena standing in the hallway.'

2. I'm not sure why Alena's eyebrows furrow when the main char smiles at her and yet she then smiles back. Eyebrows furrow when someone frowns so that struck me as odd.

3.
Her voice rose in pitch as she talked further along in the sentence.
This is awkward. We don't think of talking as sentences generally speaking so maybe 'as she talked more' or even 'her voice rose higher the longer she spoke'.[/Quote]

4.
She clenched her fists, biting her lip, anticipating my reaction.

Surprise jumpstarted my reaction-time, and real elation flooded into my blood.
This is awkward too. It feels like a very delayed reaction because you've told us twice that he's going to react. Instead of telling us, just cut straight to the reaction.

5.
Alena left soon after, telling me that she'd let me know when she'd found a dress, and that she would stay if she wasn't afraid that Jet would come back and yell at her. For her sake, I didn't tell Jet about our visit. We left for school a half-hour later; Jet always said that early was 'on time' in another language.
This gets very telling. Instead of this, you could have that line of dialogue from Alena and then lead into 'For her sake I didn't tell Jet...'

6.
My stomach was roiling with nausea. I exhaled, leaning in closer to her. "I have to tell you something, but not now." Kelsey's eyes narrowed at me. She crossed her legs. She was wearing gray skinny jeans. She nibbled on the end of her pencil eraser, furrowing her brow at me, as if I was hiding something. I am was hiding something.


7. Alena's the same age as the main character? I got the impression she was the younger sister of his friend but you've probably established earlier that the friend/ roomate is older than him or that they're university students or something. I just thought I'd mention it on the small chance you hadn't.

8.
I snorted, crossing my arms. "It isn't like that. I mean, it seems like he has chaste intentions."
I'm not sure that people really use the word chaste, particularly teenagers. Maybe it's an American thing?

Overall

I really like the use of second person here, it has that lovely feel of 'something big has happened or is going to happen and this is how it went down' and it really pulls the reader in and focuses our interest on Chris.

I think a little more description of their surroundings would be nice. I think I missed the point where they moved from the cafeteria to the library or there's a bookcase in the cafeteria?

Other than that, this flows pretty well and you've got a good grip on the characters.

All the best,
Heather

User avatar
Toboldlygo
Review

Hey, there! Happy review day! Toboldlygo here to do a quick review of this work. :)

So first thing I want to say is that you've done a fantastic job of creating a world where the characters are relatable, like-able, and interesting. I found myself engaged in their world and caring about them and their lives. That's not always an easy thing to do, so well done!

One critique I have, however, is that the story is very confusing. By the end, I gathered that Koskia (the name of the main character, I think?) is thinking, and her thoughts are directed towards a guy named Chris. But it took a while to figure that out. I'm not sure who Chris is or what her relationship with him is. I also don't understand who Jet and Alena are. It seemed that Alena is Jet's sister and Chris's girlfriend? But I also gathered that Koskia is Jet's sister, so wouldn't that make Alena Koskia's sister, as well? But then, why was she knocking at the door? Also, does Chris live with them? That's what it seemed in the beginning. The relationships between the characters are really confusing and I don't really know what to make of them or how to interpret them.

Anothing thing is that I don't know what the ages of these characters are. In the beginning, they talk about rent and money and jobs as though they are young adults, but then they're in what seems to be a high school environment, and then they're suddenly eating lunch in a pre-school room? Are they in elementary school? And why are they allowed to just walk into the pre-school room to eat? That seems a little unlikely to me. It almost seemed as though they were aging backwards through the story.

The other thing I noticed is that your writing style, while very engaging, is a little confusing at times. You have dialogue that sometimes seems vague as to whom it's between, and there are times when actions and thoughts make it confusing as to whom she's thinking of. I think there could be more clarity there.

Overally, great job! Happy writing!

Toboldlygo :)



Be careful or be roadkill.
— Calvin