Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
So the plot thickens! That boy in the photo wasn’t her brother, but the family’s painter. Maybe even the sister’s friend or boyfriend. Could it be that he is the reason the girl is trapped in her own house and can’t find her family? Or is something else? I enjoy this story so far. I’ll check out the third part tomorrow.
I hope that you will have an amazing day and night.
Unfortunately, this is the second time Thing is typing this out. Its first draft got swept away by a misguided sweep of its sticky fingers. I told it it would have to retype it because I would like to keep my reputation as a tortoise. So, here it goes to work again.
Thing tells me it discovered blood and slimy liquids on the red carpet. We decided the people of this household wash their floors with soap and blood. An odd combination I daresay.
It also told me about a mysterious girl who is staring up at a image of her family. And if we did not make a mistake in our careful observations, we believe the painter himself is in the painting, crying. Based on the fact that Thing reported that the image on this boy is also in the older sisters room, I am led to think that this is the older sisters boyfriend. But why is he crying? I would think that with eery brush stroke of his, he is locking away more of his sweetheart into a painting where she will be safe from whatever calamity her little sister is going through right now. Perhaps the entire family but the little girl lives in that painting. But why? Or was it that the painter knew that he would soon be separated from his girlfriend by the sudden death of one or the other of them? Are the girl's family actually dead or can she just not find them in this gradually intensifying mystery? That would be quite sad. Indeed.
I can only tell her to avoid the garden mentioned somewhere here. Because right outside the door might be THE VAMPIRE ROSE-LIKER SODA SUCKER AND CHIP DESTROYER!!! But perhaps she will be okay...if she hasn't drunk any soda within the last 24 hrs. But considering the old-timeyness to this piece, one could infer that soda was not even invented yet. *Sigh of relief*
Keep well up on that high hill you own, tend your Roses, and drink your soda...just don't hurt this poor little girl who lives up there with you.
-THING
Hello! This is a random weirdo here to give you a short review.
This is very interesting (and scary!) story, and I can't wait to see where it goes! I wonder who her family is and why they're not with her? Who's the painter and why was a picture of him in the house, especially surrounded by blood? And why can she hardly remember anything? What's going on here?
One thing you could improve on is your detail. There are a lot of good descriptions, and a fair amount you could work on. Here's an example:
This isn't bad, and you don't have to change any descriptions to make it interesting. But you could make them better. For example, instead of saying they were beautiful, try using more detail. What color are they? Do they interact with the sunlight in an interesting way? Does the pattern remind you of ocean waves crashing against the coast? Instead of saying "so happy", maybe you could write overjoyed or thrilled or joyous.
I can't wait to see what will happen in this mysterious house! I wonder if she'll be able to exit, or even find the entrance. Perhaps there will be a hallway that goes on forever, no matter how much she walks. And sorry about the length, I'm afraid I didn't have as much time as I would have liked.
Don't forget to take what you like, and forget the rest! Keep writing!
I appreciate the feedback!
Hello Rose,
Once again, I am back to review a well-written work from you. You set the tone of the work right off the bat, a dark tone. The narrator feels lost and the reader meanders through the tale with her, and the pictures reinforce that image. The flow is excellent and the story itself is riveting. I hope to read more of it going forward.
There are some flaws in the grammar and paragraph structure that bear visiting.
The first paragraph is a strong start, setting the mood immediately, and it flows well. But the fabric of the piece starts to fray in the second.
There are few area where this paragraph could use help. For starts, it is a pretty massive blurb of text. It would definitely benefit from being broken up into small sections. I'll break it up a little bit just to give an example.
Just breaking it up a little makes it instantly more readable and improves the flow.
The next area that could use a bit of work in show vs tell. Showing is when you describe an action and telling is when you just say "a thing happened". Both have their uses and can be overdone. You overdo it on the telling.
Try to write this sentence again but this time use description.
It's vivid and it's real. This is in my voice, not yours, and you'll need to rewrite it. But this is the difference between telling and showing. When you want people to feel something real, when you want them to panic with your character, you have to show them the suffering of your MC and let us live it with them.
A pointer I was given years ago was, if you aren't sure about a sentence, read it out loud. If it flows well verbally, it probably flows well on the page as well.
Keep writing! I hope to see a lot more from you on the site.
Christus Rex Est,
Pickled Chrissy
I love the spooky vibe of this book 5 stars its so well written and it would be lovely to see more work from you and it feels as if the narrator died and im wondering whats next it also had so much emotion poured into it I've gotta say you’re one of the best authors I’ve seen so far on this platform and i love the addition of images to your story to create more of a mental image good job
Hi there!

Thank you so much for your feedback! It means a lot me.
I'm glad you liked the story.
-Rose
https://rosewriting12.blogspot.com/