So, uh, hi, Pix. Ita here to review, since I haven't reviewed anything properly in a while.
I will take advantage of this piece to discuss about your characters, call it my little Foedus ad Rayahae , ahaha.
My first impression, I'll be frank, was, 'ugh, not another Rayah novel.' Really, though, I get she's your favorite and archetypal character, but, it seems all your stories are always about Rayah. Always. When the character isn't named Rayah, she seems to be a weak copy of this character. Who comes off as a tad boring, really -- she's a superpowerful demigod but at the same time your average teen, blah blah. Though, this may just be my tainted impression of her, since I've seen her pop around everywhere, usually in a one-liner in some chit-chat on YWS. And on that note, Willing Suspension of Disbelief allowed, the chance of Poseidon, Poseidon of all gods, conceiving a child with the goddess Aphrodite? There's a pretty slim chance of that happening, if you've read Percy Jackson you'll know what I mean. Now, maybe the daughter of Ares and Aphrodite, yes, that'd be more likely and more interesting, seeing as the two gods are pretty much opposites. Then again, it's your novel, you do what you will with it. Keep in mind this is just my opinion.
On a broader note, it seems Rayah, and all your characters, are just pure teen angst, fused with a fantasy element because gods are cool, coalesced into one borderline Mary-Sue. They have troubled parents, their lives are hard and tragic, blah blah. I quote this as my example
. Yes, teen angst sells, but if it's done well, which it rarely is because usually angsty teens are writing it, and not somebody that can dissect and present the genre in an original way. So, you may want to try toning down the angst, trying for a different character, maybe. And I agree with TLT on this, the 'prologue' in the beginning isn't necessary. Show, don't tell. That's important. Show us Rayah's 'troubled life'.Most stories end with two people falling in love, then getting married, and then having as many flawless children as you can imagine.
So, yeah, to recap -- diversify, play around with different types of characters, and for the love of god, no more stories which revolve around the same character and plot, only they have different names. Please. You can do better things than that, I'm sure.
And, as for the chapter itself, well. If somebody that had no idea who Rayah is and the myriad events surrounding her (I'm sure you could start a wikia on just her life), would they, after reading this, continue to finish the novel? Well, they might, but, what I'm trying to say is that this just doesn't cut it. You don't grab our attention enough. Have you any idea how many PJO-style novels there are out there? Far too many, is the answer. Not that that's necessarily a bad thing, I'm just saying, they need that extra little kick to make them stand out. Which this is lacking, but never fear, it could be remedied! Furthermore, there's really not a lot of description in this. Wait, nope, there's none at all. Because, your target audience (or most of it) already knows what Rayah looks like, has already RPd with her in Mount Olympus. Others -- like me -- have no idea what she looks like and no idea what Mount Olympus, in your novel, does, and this chapter hasn't exactly helped. So, remember, not all who read this know what you're going on about.
Now, onto the grammatical nit-picks. Congrats, there actually weren't any major typos here I could spot!
But, to nit-pick, here are some things that could be edited:
“You seriously think it’s that easy, Rayah? I’m already on the third warning. One more and I won’t be able to leave my house for good,” He says.
That's a comma there, no need to capitalize 'h'. This mistake is made multiple times. Like here
, and yet you don't make it in other places, like hereHe reveals a baby Pegasus and I practically faint, running to it and hugging it like it was my own.
“His name is Gus. He can be a pain in the a*s sometimes. Just…ugh,” He mutters.
. Formatting error, or...? Also, the fact you censored ass made me chuckle. Swear-words aren't usually censored, unless that's another formatting bug or something similar.“S’just…Hermes thought it was funny to give me a little babysitter,” he mumbles.
I shake my head at him and just walk off and to my house back in the city part of Olympus.
WHERE is the description???
But hey, apart from the above, this isn't one of your worst pieces.
Hope this helped~
Ita
Points: 30323
Reviews: 289
Donate