12+ Language

The Broken, Bent Man

by Pan
PreviousNext

I don't remember when I first felt love for the broken man. Perhaps it was during one of our little conversations as I cleaned and he drank. Maybe it was when he fixed my car, or when he disproved my doubts by showing me the purest form of love. I'm not sure, but then again, I never was.

He was a regular at the bar I worked at. I don’t think that he knew what the term ‘sober’ meant, because he always had a slight slur to his words as he ordered more to drink. It seemed to me as if he was born with a bottle attached to his lips, but I didn’t know his life, so I had no room to judge.

I remember the first night I was working. He stumbled in, clearly already drunk. Eddie, the barkeep at the time, wasn’t surprised to see him. Or he didn’t seem to be.

The usual?” Eddie asked, leaning on the bar. The man nodded, and grumbled something incoherent that Eddie cracked a grin at. Then, the old man poured the man a drink and turned to tend to the two girls who sat giggling at the other end of the bar.

I was just cleaning tables then. I was a plain girl just trying to rake up money in any way I could. But the man piqued my interest, and I would have quit as soon as I had enough money to pay for the new engine my beat up Taurus needed.

There was something about him that made me want to know him. Maybe it was the fact that he seemed depressed and he was taking the easy way out-- forgetting. Maybe I wanted to see this man smile.

Maybe it was because he reminded me of my brother, who I had lost to brain cancer three years before. I was almost positive that I could understand this man, and what he had went through.

He returned to the bar every day after that. Though he was in a drunken stupor, he seemed coherent enough to make it in and out the door safely.

On the third night, I finally approached the dark haired man, with the excuse of cleaning the bar around him.

It was then that I asked him his name. He stared at me as if I had grown another head. “Ah, my apologies, I’m Hallie.” I smiled, “I’m the new busboy.”

He still stared at me. “You mean busgirl.” I smiled wider.

Yup.” I nodded, staring at his gorgeous green eyes.

I’m Jason.” He mumbled, offering his hand.

Hi, Jason!” I called, taking the empty shot glasses that lined the bar.

Thanks,” He mumbled, downing more of his drink. “Nice meeting you.” I waved it off, with a smile, and returned to my job. Eddie laughed at me from the other side of the bar, and I shrugged, slinging my rag over my shoulder.

I don’t remember much of the next few months-- Eddie serving Jason drink, and me casually dropping small comments to the man, who just snorted and shook his head at every time my mouth opened.

It was a Thursday that out routine was jolted out of place. News had reached me from Charlotte, the Owner’s daughter, that Eddie had had a heart attack and the Boss needed me to pour drinks while Eddie was recovering. The pay was good, and they would hire a temporary busboy while I poured-- I had done it before, and Eddie specifically requested that I fill in for him.

On my first night pouring, I spilled at least three bottles worth of alcohol on me. He stumbled in at approximately 9 PM, and stared at me. “Where’s Eddie?”

Out. I’m filling in for him.” I explained.

Jason stared at me, “He hurt or anything?” His voice sounded a bit worried, and his eyes bored into my skull, waiting for an answer as he sat in his usual stool.

Char says that Ed had a heart attack--” I started, pushing him back down when he stood up. “But he’s okay, so calm down. He’ll be back soon, within the month.” Jason frowned, and sat back down. We were quiet for a while, him staring at the beer in his hands and me occasionally pouring another drink for another customer.

Get me another beer,” He sighed, after a while. “I’ll let you in on a few secrets.” I nodded, and grabbed a mug, filling it to the brim with the frothy ale. I handed it to him, and he took a drink, grimacing at the taste. “Thanks, Hallie.” He mumbled. I nodded, leaning on my elbow. “Ed is my uncle,” he began, with a sigh, “Or really, he’s like an uncle. He helped me out of a slump-- after my wife died in a car crash-- and gave me a place to stay. He’s a great friend of mine.”

I nodded, “I understand. Ed’s a great guy, and I’m sure that it would break all of our hearts if he died. Hey! Jimmy, clean off table 5, there’s somebody else comin’ in!” I called to the busboy, who waved me off, a grin cracking on his face.

I’ll get to it when I get to it.” He laughed. I smiled, and turned to Jason, who frowned at me.

What?”

Nothing.” He sighed, swigging the drink. “I just think I’m going to go soon, is all.”

Oh,” I said, a little disappointed.

I don’t know, though.” Jason mumbled. “Ed’s all I got. He’s been all I got since.. hell, is it three years now? Four?”

I cleared my throat, opening a bottle of water. “How did it happen, if you don’t mind me asking?”

Drunk driver crashed into my car, we were on our way to a restaurant. It was our anniversary. Samantha was only two, dammit. And Helen looked amazing, just perfect in that dress.” he mumbled, lost in his memories. “And I looked over at her for a second-- just a second-- and then there was screaming and screeching, and the smell of burnt rubber.” His voice was a whisper, his dark hair falling in his face, shielding his eyes.

I’m so sorry,” I mumbled, wiping a few tears from my eyes. “I’m sorry for your loss. But who’s Samantha?”

Oh, god. Sam,” He sighed, “She’s my kid. She’s six, now. God, Hallie, I’ve been a terrible father, sneaking out when she falls asleep, leaving the babysitter, who calls me if she gets up.”

I nodded, “Jason, you’re just trying to forget the pain. I know how bad it hurts, my boyfriend in high school killed himself, and I thought it was because of me, so that’s haunted me ever since. I know you feel guilty for looking away, but don’t blame yourself.”

He nodded, finishing off his beer. “I think I’m going to head out now.”

Alright.” I mumbled, then thought of something. “I’d really like to meet her. Samantha, that is.” I told him as he turned shrugged into his coat.

I’ll introduce you sometime soon,” He said. I grinned, and ducked under the ‘flapboard’ -as I called it- and hugged Jason.

It’ll get better.” I told him before he left.

That was the day I realized that I wanted to repair the broken man.

It was a Tuesday that I saw him next, but it wasn’t at the bar. I sat in a donut shop, picking at the chocolate glazed doughnut. I only bought it so I could use the free internet. Why do they call it free internet if you have to be a customer to use it? It’s not really free, then. Why not call it ‘$1.99’ internet?

I was pondering these things when I heard my name being called. “Huh?”

Jason approached me, holding hands with a small girl, her dark brown hair separated into two ponytails. I smiled at him when I recognized him. “Hello!” The girl smiled.

Hello! Are you Samantha?” I asked, leaning down.

Yeah, but my friends call me Sammy!”

Oh.” I smiled. "I'm Hallie. "

She grinned, showing a row of white teeth, the front two missing. “You want to be my friend?”

I nodded, smiling. “Yeah, that sounds fun!”

She hugged me, then, and I stood up. “Going?” Jason asked, taking Samantha’s hand as she ran back to him. I nodded, sliding my laptop into my bag, and dusting my hands off on my jeans. I slung the bag over my shoulder and gave a quick hug to Jason, who returned it before I left, waving to Sammy and her father.

Over the next few months, I saw Jason more outside of the bar than I did inside. He seemed to be getting better- for Samantha's sake, I assumed.

It was one of these days that we met, I was in the coffee shop as always, and he strolled by, his hand laced in Samantha's. She waved to me as they entered the shop.

I smiled, and waved back, clearing a small space from the table for them. Jason pulled the chair out for Samantha, and she sat there, giggling, as she clutched a small bear to her chest.

I smiled at the girl, and she smiled back, flashing her teeth. She had taken to calling me 'Auntie Hallie,' which was okay with me, seeing as I considered Jason a brother to me. He would never replace Joseph, but Jason was still dear to me. "Sammy, you are by far the cutest little girl I've met."

"You're cute, too, Auntie!" She smiled, her dark hair falling in her face. I reached over and brushed it away, kissing her forehead in the process.

A few minutes later, Jason returned with another doughnut for me, one for Sammy , and a cup of coffee for him. "What are you ladies up to?"

I shrugged, "Sam is just too cute." He nodded in agreement.

"Auntie, at school, they asked us what we wanted to be when we grew up! I told them that I wanted to be a doctor." Sam told me, biting into her doughnut.

"Oh? You want to help people?"

"Yeah! I want to make people's boo-boos better!" She flashed me a huge smile, the doughnut making her cheeks puff out. I chuckled. "What did you want to be?"

I bit my lip, thinking. "I always thought that I would be a writer," I admitted, "That's why I'm always here, I use the internet to publish little things I've written."

"You've never mentioned that before." Jason remarked. "I thought you were just browsing through Facebook, or something."

"You've never asked."

Jason nodded at that, "I never really cared. Have you even finished college?"

I shook my head in response, swallowing a lump of doughnut. "I didn't have enough for tuition. But I want to graduate. I just really want to explore the world, first."

Sammy looked at her feet, a sad expression on her face, "Are you gonna leave me and Daddy?"

"I don't... I don't know." I mumbled, "I don't know what I'm gonna do."

We continued eating, the atmosphere full of tension.

"What will you do if you leave?" Jason asked after a few moments. "Where would you go first?"

"Portland, to visit Joe's grave, then to my mom's. We have a bit of catching up to do. I haven't seen her for.. what? Three years?" I spoke, half to myself, half to Jason. "I would just travel, see places I've always wanted to see, use them as inspiration, probably write a novel. Or two."

He nodded solemnly. "Will you ever come back?"

"It depends," I replied, not looking at either of them, "I'm still not sure that I'll even leave. My car is still broken, and I can't take a cab all around the country."

"Do you want me to fix it?" Jason offered, "I used to be a mechanic, before the accident."

I didn't know how to respond, "I don't want you to feel like you have to." I mumbled, sipping the coffee in front of me. "You don't.. need to."

"I gotta take care of my little sister," he chuckled, "We'll swing by and look at it tomorrow." He promised me, swallowing the last bit of doughnut. "Sam, you done?"

"Yep!" She nodded, "Are we going now?"

"Yeah, sweetie. We'll see you tomorrow, Hallie." Jason replied as he helped Sam into her jacket.

"Bye, guys." I mumbled, picking up my own jacket, and pushing my chair in.

Jason kept his promise, and they showed up at around 3 PM at my small home. I allowed them in, and Sam ran to the living room where the TV played Spongebob Squarepants. I took Jason's coat, and put it away, then led him to the garage. My Taurus sat in the almost empty space, the hood dented, and the tarp that was covering it almost completely removed.

He pushed up his sleeves, and popped the hood. "Do you want something to drink?"

"What do you have?"

"Tea, Soda, water, coffee..?"

"Tea will be fine," He replied, "do you have any tools?" I pointed to the corner, where a medium sized toolbox sat, years of wear and tear apparent. I had gotten it from my mother when Joey died.

I left the garage, and passed the living room. "Sammy, do you want some tea?"

"Yup!" She called, her large eyes stuck on the TV. I shook my head, and entered the next room, grabbing three glasses and filling them with ice, then pouring the sweetened tea into them.

"Sammy, did you guys eat before you came over?"

"No, Daddy said we didn't have time to!"

"You hungry?"

"Kinda. Can I have a sandwich?"

I called back a 'yes' and began preparing sandwiches. As I repeated the rhythmic process of placing meat, cheese, then lettuce on each of the sandwiches, I lost myself in my own musings.

I shook myself away from my thoughts and returned to the kitchen, calling to Samantha. "Lunch is ready, go get your father!"

I heard the patter of her feet on the floorboards, and after a few minutes, she came back, tugging her dad along.

"You didn't have to--"

"Yeah I did," I started, pushing the sandwich toward him. "Eat up."

Samantha dug into her food happily, and smiled at me, her mouth full of food. "These are good."

I smiled at her compliment, and started eating. Jason kept his eyes on me, as he ate. "Did you figure out what was wrong with it?"

He shook his head, "Not yet, but I was getting there. It's not just one thing, but a couple."

I made an, 'ah' face, and pushed the tea toward him. He took it and drank it happily. "Thanks."

"No, thank you."

My eyes drifted over to a picture that sat on the table beside Samantha. "Who's that?" Sam asked, pointing at a younger version of myself, back when Joey was alive, and I had red hair.

"My brother and I." I replied, reaching for it, a sad smile on my face. Jason's lips twisted to the side, "I really miss him sometimes."

"I'm sorry," Jason mumbled, "were you two close?" I nodded, feeling tears well up in my eyes.

"He was the best brother ever. But after he found out about the cancer... He... He started drinking. He taught me how to mix drinks before we lost him, and he became a shell of his old self. For a while, I hated him. It was as if the Joey I knew died when he learned about the cancer, and there was just this.. this shell with his face. I felt like he just stopped caring about me, he stopped loving my family. And he was engaged to a girl-- Oh, God. Lana. I haven't talked to her in a while. Joey just broke off the engagement- he didn't want to marry her just to make her a widow three months later." I said, tears sliding down my face, staining my grey T-shirt. Jason looped his hand in mine.

"I know the feeling of loss, Hallie.. After Helen died, I lost myself to drinking. I didn't see the light, I wanted to die, but Sam, she kept me going. She showed me the light. And you... You made me happy. You made me understand that there are more people out there. She'll always have a special place in my heart, but so will you. And after you leave, I'll still feel you there."

I nodded. "I decided to go to Chicago for a few years." I mumbled. "It's halfway across the country, but... But I need the break."

He nodded, and Sam started crying.

"But.. Don't worry. Don't cry.” I mumble, feeling tears sting my eyes. “I won’t get yet..”

Sam looked at me, tears filling her large eyes. “Wha..?”

I still have to fix the Broken Man.”

Thanks for reading ^^

~Pen

Comments & reviews · 8
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

User avatar
Ciblio
Comment

Ugh, I don't know what just happened. Sarah's computer's getting on my nerves. I wrote this long, nice review, but it glitched, or something, . I don't wanna rewrite it. (/._.)/

User avatar
Ciblio
Comment
User avatar
Ciblio
Comment
User avatar
Ciblio
Review
Ciblio wrote a review · Fri Jul 11, 2014 4:40 am

Your post wasn't bad. It really spoke to me, because I feel as if I'm invisible. Like I'm hidden from the world, watching the others have fun, while I rot in the shadows. You truly have intelligence, and I just love that you made it a free verse. NO rhymes involved, which helps the reader focus on the point of the story. Now I am you, and you are me, so let's work together in harmony. Hahahahahahaha, see how I did that? I rhymed. I just need to make points because I wanna make write more. Why the heck does posts cost 250 points? Actually, why the heck does posting cost points? We should just be able to post freely, and review if we want to. Anyways, nobody's going to see this, because I'm going to delete it RIGHT after I submit it. xD I love the variations in the lengths of your lines. I have a hard time reading poetry with excessively long lines, or ones that are too short. It still flows quite nicely, in my opinion, but I also agree with the other reviewers that you could use less commas, rearrange some lines and exchange a few words that seem out of place. For example, you could swap "not even affected" with "unaffected" and "not able" to "unable" in the last line. Hey there, first off I'd like to say I enjoyed this. Really, I mean it. "I can feel myself fading- Every single piece of me." You start off great, and it draws you in, while drawing out emotion. I love this! The next line: "Every detail, just disappearing, slowly, into the darkness' I personally I like this line. To help with the flow though it would be good to break it apart and write it like this: (At least it's what I'd do). "Every detail, just disappearing, Slowly, Into the darkness" Though it works either way, and you of course being the author get to choose this. The same can be said about the next line: "Once I'm gone completely-- once the dark world has fully consumed me--" Instead you could try: "Once I'm gone completely-- Once the dark world has fully consumed me--" The next thing is the line: "Not even affected by my disappearance." To me it seems a little chunky. Though again, this is another author preference. And honestly it's fine either way. Its the same for this line, it slightly disrupts the flow, and I feel if you could break it apart, to reword it, it would work with the flow better. Again, this is not necessary. "And I see my reflection. Nothing but another shadow. Lost in the darkness. Not able to be found. And I feel myself not just alone, but gone completely." This part, I just love, love, love. I really like how it sounds as you read it out loud. I can really relate as well, but yeah, I Just love it. I really loved this whole thing, and really I'm interested in you work now. Thanks for sharing this. Hi Shine, a quick review on your poem here. I have seen a lot of poems about the darkness, but even I have tried to write it down (but failed). Well, straight to the point here! I love it when a speaker trying to convey about how the darkness dominates the speaker with your own thoughts. It thus generates originality of the poem. I can feel myself fading- Every single piece of me. I like how you start the poem but somehow it becomes something that already looks familiar. The poem in fact tells about yourself that getting lost in the dark and not heeded by others. All of that makes a poem written in the tone of voice that seems sad and gloomy. The thing is, it makes the reader tries to rebel for not wanting to feel the feelings shared by the poet. It is full of emotion which should be balanced(excessive emotion). Sentimentality in a poem can end up feeling whiney, self-pitying, insincere, or sickeningly sweet, depending on which emotions the poet is overdoing. In your poem, you have this problem (I once do that on my first poem). So how to avoid a situation like this is not to express outright about what you feel. Just let the reader make their own conclusion. Lost in the darkness. Not able to be found. And I feel myself not just alone, but gone completely. Anyway, I really like this part. You really able to express your own idea in between you and the darkness. Good job! Again, I am not saying that you have a big trouble here. Just need to read more poems from a good writer to learn how they write their poem and practicing more and more, you will surely see the results soon! :) Keep writing! Kudos, cheers. Though this is sad, it's very lovely. It's written in a way that we the readers can relate, yet it is still personal to you specifically. Bravo on that. You've managed to draw readers in with the first couple of lines. This line here: "I watch their faces as they receive hugs from relatives. " I feel like relatives doesn't flow very well. It seems almost too formal for the rest of the poem. Maybe "loved ones," or something of the sort? "And I feel myself not just alone, but gone completely. " I absolutely l o v e this line here. Seriously. This was a perfect ending to your near perfect poem. The "gone completely" part, specifically. It's like I can almost hear the silence that follows that sentence. This shows you have some real talent. Keep writing!

Random avatar
deleted30
Review

Hi Pen! Lucrezia here for a review.

This was amazing! I loved every second. It was realistic, heartbreaking, and wonderful all at once. The flow was great; the character development was perfect; the wording was awesome.

Really, it was fantastic!

Yes, it is kind of the easy way out to describe how the MC looks by having them see their reflection in a mirror. But how you laced her backstory in when she sees herself was really clever and subtle and awesome. It told the reader more about her without it being too in-your-face, which I loved.

The ending was bittersweet and perfect. It held my interest the whole time, and was really just a lovely read. Honestly, well done. That's all I can say.

Nitpicks (and yes, there's a lot, but they're all stupid technical stuff and hardly matter):

“The usual?” Eddie asks, leaning on the bar.


Using "asks" here instead of "asked" kind of suggests a change from past tense to present tense.

I was just cleaning tables, then.


No need for the comma.

Eddie serving Jason drink


I believe you meant for drinks to be plural here instead of singular?

It was a Thursday that out routine was jolted out of place.


Our routine.

“Thanks, Hallie.” He mumbled.


No need to capitalize the H in "he." Unless Jason's God. He's not God, is he?

Sorry. My sad attempt at humor. Moving on...

She’s six, now.


No need for that comma.

“I’ll introduce you sometime soon,” He said.


Again, the H should be lowercase.

"I always thought that I would be a writer," I admitted, "That's why I'm always here, I use the internet to publish little things I've written."


Because of the comma, the first letter in "that's" doesn't need to be capitalized.

I just really want to explore the world, first.


Get rid of that comma.

"I gotta take care of my little sister," he chuckled, "We'll swing by and look at it tomorrow."


"We'll" shouldn't have a capitalized W.

"Tea will be fine," He replied


Yep—that H should be lowercase.

The girl who had an obsession with Unicorns


"Unicorns" doesn't need a capitalized U.

Samantha dug into her food happily, and smiled at me, her mouth full of food.


"Food" is repetitive here.

Jason kept his eyes on me, as he ate.


Take out that comma.

And... done! You may breathe easier. The bad part's over.

All in all, this is an incredible story. The dialogue and characters and emotion felt amazingly real. There's so many parts I liked, but one that particularly stood out was the beginning:

I don't remember when I first felt love for the broken man. Perhaps it was during one of our little conversations as I cleaned and he drank. Maybe it was when he fixed my car, or when he disproved my doubts by showing me the purest form of love. I'm not sure, but then again, I never was.

He was a regular at the bar I worked at. I don’t think that he knew what the term ‘sober’ meant, because he always had a slight slur to his words as he ordered more to drink. It seemed to me as if he was born with a bottle attached to his lips, but I didn’t know his life, so I had no room to judge.


That narration is so perfect and crisp and just amazing. It reeled me in right away and hooked me from the beginning. It's just so ridiculously well-written. That's all I'm gonna say.

Yeah. This was awesome. Please, please, please keep writing. Great work!! :D

*sighs* I have the 'H' and 'comma' problem a lot. Sorry xD
I still have to go in and fix a few things. Thanks for your input!

User avatar
Iggy
Review
Iggy wrote a review · Sun Jan 26, 2014 5:29 am

Hey Pen!

It was a Thursday that out routine was jolted out of place. News had reached me from Charlotte, the Owner’s daughter, that Eddie had had a heart attack and the Boss needed me to pour drinks while Eddie was recovering.


Two things are wrong.
1. I assume out should be our.
2. There's no need to uppercase Owner and Boss, since they are common nouns.

I started, pushing him back down when he stood up.


This feels unrealistic. Jason is obviously somewhat antisocial, and you describe how he grunts and mumbles whenever Hallie tries to talk to him, so why would she suddenly reach over a counter and shove him down? You don't do that to people you hardly know, especially when they come across as unpleasant and unfriendly. A better way to state this would be that she quickly rushed on to say that Eddie was okay or she attempted to touch him but stopped herself before making contact.

He helped me out of a slump-- after my wife died in a car crash-- and gave me a place to stay.


The double hyphens aren't necessary here. Not even a single hyphen, either. Since the part about his wife dying is on the same trail of thought, there's no need for an abrupt break. You can easily scratch out those hyphens and just let the sentence be, after a slight rewording. For example: "He helped me out of a slump when my wife died in a car crash and gave me a place to stay."

(Additional note: double hyphens aren't necessary. Just one will do.)

Jimmy, clean off table 5


In literature, every word prior to and including ten is spelled out. Everything above ten can be either spelled out or simplified with the actual numbers. So change 5 to "five."

I know how bad it hurts, my boyfriend in high school killed himself


Replace that comma with a semicolon.

He pushed up his sleeves, and popped the hood. "Do you want something to drink?"


This makes it sound like Jason is talking to himself. Break it up so we know it's Hallie talking, not Jason.

What happened to Hal The Freak? The girl who had an obsession with Unicorns


Such tiny nitpicks, but "the" doesn't need to be capitalized, nor does "Unicorns."


Okay, so! Wonderful story, here. I really liked it. It wasn't too cliche, and I just loved the way you narrated the story, introducing Jason and slowly weaving along, allowing us bits and pieces of who he was and how he acted. I think the character development was one of your strongest elements in this, since you took it slow and didn't automatically force these two together and having Hallie want to fix him on sight.

I think the ending was a bit cheesy and fell rather flat from the point you were trying to get across. In the end, it seemed like Jason didn't need any more repairing; he didn't even seem broken anymore. He stopped drinking and he had his daughter and now Hallie to help keep him happy. Having Hallie state that she needs to keep fixing him really wasn't the ending I was looking for. I was thinking more of a "I can't leave yet. I have you two to worry about. However will you survive without me?"

Other than that, wonderful. Very well written. Seemed rather lengthy at first, but I enjoyed it. It was a pleasure to read. :)

User avatar
Gravity
Review
Gravity wrote a review · Sun Jan 26, 2014 5:09 am

I saw the title of this story and I thought it was really interesting. I was pleasantly surprised to figure out that Hallie and Jason were not romantically involved.

I have a few nitpicks.

The Joseph thing is confusing. You mentioned him in the beginning but then you brought up a dead bf from highschool that Hallie had who killed himself, so I thought the dead bf was Joseph, not the brother. I also didn't like the way you made the ending. I thought it was too confusing, and Hallie only suddenly brings up Chicago. I also wish you would have described more of the time that Hallie spent getting to know Sam and Jason. I get that Jason stopped drinking for Sam, but you never said what really sparked the change. Was it the conversation with Hallie? What did Hallie say to convince him to change? If Jason has had Sammie for four years since Helen died, why didn't he quit drinking before that? etc. etc., you get the point.

I absolutely love Sammy's character. She is probably my favorite character out of all of this. Throughout the story, you kinda drop Ed. He has a heart attack and BOOM! Gone! I miss him Pen, bring him back to me. I want to know what happened to Ed, and whether or not Hallie quit working at the bar. Hallie mentioned that she would work there until she could get her car fixed, but after she sees Jason at the cafe, all thoughts of the bar went POOF! They disappeared.

Other than that, I loved your descriptions and I thought you developed your characters well. I also like the beginning of your story. Your writing style is awesome, and you had a strong beginning that had me hooked. This was a wonderful piece, bravo. Keep Writing! I look forward to seeing what else you have written on YWS.

-Gravity

User avatar
eldEr
Review
eldEr wrote a review · Fri Jan 24, 2014 4:29 pm

Hey there! Isha here for a review. :)

First off, I must say that, for the most part, the writing in this was pretty excellent. It flowed well, and the voice was strong, but I do have a few writing nitpicks, and then a few story-based things to say.

For starters, the amount of times you said "man" in the first half of this story was a little ridiculous. Even after Hal knew Jason's name, she referred to him as "the man". I'll show you what I mean via quotes, here:

"The man nodded, and grumbled something incoherent that Eddie cracked a grin at."
"But the man piqued my interest,"
"Maybe I wanted to see this man smile."
"I was almost positive that I could understand this man"


All within FIVE paragraphs. Which wouldn't be that bad, except for the fact that the paragraphs are only a couple sentences long each. :P So every three or four sentences, you've got "this man" or "the man", and it's cluttered and redundant and just not that nice to read. Most of these could be changed to "he" or "him". And then, after she knows what his name is, you've got it again:

"Eddie serving Jason drink, and me casually dropping small comments to the man"


This "the man" wouldn't be so bad (it could work quite nicely, actually, since saying 'Jason' twice would be a little awkward), except for the fact that you have it so many times previously. This was actually my biggest problem with the whole story, writing-wise.

As for storyline and plot and characters, I had a few things to say to that, too.

Firstly, the mini-scene where your narrator's looking at herself in the mirror. Just a few things about that:

1) Having characters look at themselves in the mirror and then describing every detail of their face and body is a pretty cheap move. It's overdone. All new writers, it would seem, pull this one to get around the "character description" roadblock. Honestly, we don't need to know ever detail of what she looks like. Hair colour, eye colour, that's probably plenty. If there's anything remarkable about her that we SHOULD know about, then bring it up in a more creative manner.

2) This scene was entirely unnecessary. It doesn't tell us anything about the character except that she grew out of an ugly phase, as most teenagers do, and that has nothing to do with the story at all. It doesn't develop her, it doesn't shed any light on her, or anyone else, or on the story. I didn't like it at all.

And- okay. So here's the thing about "fixing the broken man." I've always had problems with stories like this. Problems with when people have their characters develop friendships with other characters for the sole purpose of "fixing" them. Firstly, it gives the reader the idea that people CAN fix other people, and they cannot. Only the broken person (and God, if you believe in one or many) can make the decision to fix him/her/themself.

Secondly, it's an extremely unhealthy, shallow reason to forge a relationship, a friendly or romantic one, or otherwise. The connection is, and you can argue this all you want but it's entirely true, entirely fake on the "fixer's" end, whereas the "fixee" thinks that it's real. It's also a tad bit arrogant on the part of the "fixer," and- yeah, I don't like it. Plus, it's really, really overused in the media and the arts already. Someone walks in for the sole purpose of fixing someone else, they succeed, and then they live happily ever after with some messed up, mangled bond, and that's not how it works.

Jason is a charity case, essentially.

Also, I don't know about Jason, but I would personally be offended by that last line of dialogue. "I still have to fix the broken man." It's a tad bit patronizing.

Your voice was good. Your writing style and your way with words is excellent, but I disliked the premise of the story. It has a lot of potential to be something awesome, but it'd be even sweeter if she walked into the relationship because she liked Jason. Because she thought Jason was interesting. Not because she pitied him and her pity developed into curiosity and a sense of charity.

Overall, though, excellent job and keep writing,
~Ish

Hi Isha! Thanks for your review, and I have a few responses: I know that I used the term "man" a lot, but really, I had written it differently before-- before the character had known the man's name, so when I changed the order up, I forgot to change those. It's pretty redundant, so thanks for calling that to attention!
Next, I agree that even though she wants to fix him, it's more than that-- I think I mentioned that he reminded her of her brother who died, so she liked him, loved him even. So it's not like she's like, "Oh, let me fix this and leave." Also, I had written another scene where she ended up leaving and returning because she needed Jason and Samantha. I decided to remove it because I thought it was unnecessary. But, if it makes it better, I can re-add it?
Finally, I really didn't like that scene with the mirror, either, I think what I was thinking about at that part was, "Okay, I'll make this a bit longer and add a point in here," then I forgot what it was. So yeah, that part is pointless, and I thought I deleted it before I posted it.



All hail the mighty Glow Cloud.
— Welcome to Night Vale