Published September 20, 2006
*Locked*
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Trident: Thanks, I hate the typos *kills typos*
Well, I read the first part a while back and commented on it. I just read through the rest. I'll just comment on the earlier ones that I thought the moving statue idea was absolutely brilliant.
This crit will be mostly on the last section.
Isn't this how we all tell a person's personality? Replace that line with something else that show how Monessa prefers personality over appearance.
You have some changing viewpoints there. Since this section is supposed to be in the view of Monessa, you shouldn't have it change to Miss Prudent. Have Monessa catch Miss Prudent watching her.
What news is this? Was it in the story earlier and I just missed it? Or do you plan to reveal it later on? Otherwise, I think we have the right to know what made her so agitated.
This sentence is unnecessary and kind of dull anyway.
What does "sat a cushion of air" mean?
I would conjoin these sentences. The magic statement better be important later, otherwise cut it.
The second sentence is sloppy.
Well, it looks like it's coming along well. I'll be interested to see how the next installment turns out.
Bookebrithil: Thanks for reading, I'm glad I was able to create the world and not have too much 'info dump'. If you have any other comments I'll appreciate your post.
hmm... I was happy about the fact that you introduced this new world, and its culture in such a short space, but it didn't seem crowded. um... Yeah, great story!
Shafter: Thanks! That tree sentence has been edited XD 'aforesaid' was about the mage because I just mentioned them and didn't want to use 'mage' again.
I've never read the Earthsea Trilogy so I'm not sure what you meant there.
I do love the violin but I've never played it. Thanks again!
Wow-- I just read part one of your story, Myth, from Monessa's point of view. It's awesome! You quickly set up the fantasy world (with aeroplanes! Who knew?) I love the first sentence; it really drew me in.
I'm going to read the next part soon, but in the meantime, I found a few nitpicky things you might want to look at... that's my job around here, it seems.
This sounds like the tree has a telescope in its hand.
This puzzled me. "Aforesaid" pops off the page: "Fancy word-- look at me!" I took it to mean the first of the two listed-- humans, that is. Confusing!
This is almost exactly like the Earthsea Trilogy by Ursula K. LeGuin. I'm not sure if it's possible to change, or if it's enough of a fantasy cliche that you can get away with it... I don't know.
I love this description. Don't know why, I just do.
Yay, violinists! Yay!!! (Bet you can't guess which instrument I play.
Anyway, hope this is helpful in someway, and again, great opening scene!
Cheers! ~Shafter
(Editing)
Gry: Yay! I love it when critics point out the little things, I always seem to miss them out when it comes to my writing.
*
sited = placed I didn't think that was awkward but I'll think about editing it.
I meant to write they copied the style, I missed out a few words.
I've often seen it without a period, plus Word doesn't accept it with the period.
I added the Name/Oracle right after the 'mage uniform' so as to give a little background to the mages. It clearly didn't work but I'm working on that.
Thanks again for the help, I missed out most of the stuff. As the writer I kind of got carried away as I know what's going on and didn't realise readers weren't aware of the world I'd created.
EDIT: Feel free to tear apart everything posted.
I'm sorry, Myth, I only got to the first chapter so far, so please forgive me. Very intriguing I must say, only a few suggestions.
Erm, kinda awkward wording here…maybe it’s just me.
“sited”=confusing, how can a stage be sited? It’s probably some vocabulary word I just don’t know, but still
We come abruptly out of Monessa’s memory of the set-up to this, it feels a little…shall I say jerky?
Do you mean that they copied him despite the style being out of fashion or that they followed the current fashions? If they did neither, and you’re just mentioning that they, too, had primped in front of the mirror or whatever, then please loose the dash.
Missing a period after “Mr” I think
Kinda confusing wording here, when you said “aforesaid” I thought you meant humans and got confused—please clarify. Also, “uniform” should be “uniforms”. Oh, and just a note, perhaps make the “while the humans were in ordinary clothing” a separate sentence—emphasizes their inferiority or plainness or whatever it is you’re trying to get across here
This just comes totally out of the blue—no transition into why we’re suddenly talking about Names and Oracles. Some set-up would be nice, and if you could do a tad more showing than telling that would also be appreciated.
“the”
Again, kinda comes out of the blue. I understand you’re trying to build up suspense and questions about who/what/where and all that, but too much non-information can make a reader just give up. Maybe throw us a few more tidbits, again, showing rather than telling, preferably.
Good description, awkward wording. Maybe “because Cecilia, the lead singer, had a hypnotic voice that…” or somesuch
Brows generally crease with frowning, you don’t have to tell us. Do keep the right eye thing, though, that’s unique
It took me a couple readings to realize you meant that she stopped paying attention. For a moment I thought she literally zoomed out of her tree, as in flew away. Please reword.
“more than anything else”
Run-on sentence and awkward wording
Again—confusing wording. Maybe some more punctuation would help, I couldn’t tell where an idea was starting or beginning and got lost.
“work out”
It sounds like you mean M. disposed of the woman in the lake! Lol, simple mistake, just please clarify. Also, had M. dived down to make sure the necklace is still there? If not, then maybe, “To her knowledge it still lay at the bottom, unwanted.”
(Editing)
Sureal: Thank you for reading!
I didn't want to go into too much detail what the background of mages and their magic was, I need help on that.
I like what you've written so far
. I especially like the characterisation - all the characters feel distinct.
I'm not too sure what critisms to make - so far the story is rolling along fine. I suppose we could maybe have a bit more insight into the background of magic and the mages.
RS: Thanks for taking the time to read through.
1st part:
I didn't want to go into too much detail what the world looked like. I tend to give too much description most of the time and this happened with my old piece of OP, I concentrated more on what things looked like rather than the story and got no where. As I am editing C1 I will think about giving a vivid picture of the world.
2nd part:
The general idea here was to get Sebastian's point of view but still more change is needed once I start rewriting.
3rd part:
I wanted to show what Monessa was up to while Sebastian was outside. This is the most important scene and I guess I did do somethings right. I think I'll change the end of Sebastian's entry to make it clearer to understand.
Once again thank you for pointing out what others missed. If anyone else has something to add I'll be grateful.
-- Myth
1st part:
Uhh, well, I'm really not sure what to say here. The writing seems rather simple, yet this isn't a negative factor, not really. There just doesn't seem to be enough description. You only say what's relavent to the character at hand, and don't really bring the world alive at all. I get a good sense of who the characters are for this point in the story, but I can hardly see the world. With this taking place in an alternate modern day earth (at least that's the implication I got with the micophone comment), you should bring London more to life. My mind kept thinking it was a fantasy world and had to keep pulling myself back to the fact that it was an alternate earth.
I think it would sound better with that "and" there.
2nd Part:
Again, you seem to focus to closely on the main character and his immediate area. You did do a good job with the second and third paragraphs, but I still don't get the feel of the scene. Put in a few things irelevant to the story to put a little natural life into the story. Broaden your view away from the characters a bit.
Other than that, I can't think of anything else to say.
3rd Part:
I think you did a better job of giving the ambience of the scen than in the previous parts. I also enjoyed your descriptions. However, wasn't she talking to Crook outside as the clown was walking to her? You go from there to inside the oracle's tent with the scene already started.The transitions seems weird, and a little jarring. It's almost like the second part didn't even happen for all they connect. You need to look at that transition and rework it, make it smoother at least.
Other than that, I liked this scene.
If you need any clarifications on anything, as I am often not all that great at explaining things, just PM me. All in all, nice work.
(Editing)
(Editing)
Aeroman: Welcome to the site again! I see your already getting to work by critiquing.
By the way. What did you mean by reversal? Do the names of your characters not gove them a sort of 'power'?

Snoink: Oh my God! Snoink commented on my work and liked it. *dies happy* I've never really been taught how to write a story, from an early age I always wrote this way so I guess its a gift.
Jak: Another new member! Welcome, greetings, salutations!
Thanks for commenting guys. I really appreciate it. Now I'm determined to continue.
You have a very good way of ordering simple words to make them sound really effective. I loved reading it so keep up your good work!
I read this before, but I didn't comment. And I reread it again and still didn't comment. And now I feel guilty. XD

No, seriously, I love your style. It's so simplistic and pretty. You use lovely words, changing your verb forms often to create a constantly moving story that not only moves from the action but just by the words dancing on the screen. And that's a gift that I rarely see, so I commend you for that.
Also, the way you portray your ideas is quite pretty! I like the idea of the mage being nameless. It's quite funny (and enjoyable) for me to see this since, with my story, it's the exact opposite. Names are a sign of power, and I never thought of names being something else. This story delighted me with that reversal, but it was written so subtly that it didn't pound it into my face or anything... I liked it quite a bit.
So yeah. You have an absolutely lovely style and I adore your writing. Keep it up girl!
You wrote that very well, I enjoyed reading it a lot and I have no complaints. Keep up the great work!
Wings: No complaints at all?
Phorcys: Yup. I've been working on it for a very long time and hopefully the fortune-teller scene will still serve its purpose.
Trident: Eek! That was me being lazy. I couldn't find a way to write what it was like, I may rethink that part.
^ Thanks for taking and interest and reading! I hope to have a positive feedback once the next part is posted. I'll add why the mages have their real names hidden in the above post too, just to clear things up.
-- Myth
Nice and flowing. Cryptic, yet informative. Nice job. One suggestion:
I don't know if I like the word "clear" there, as it doesn't really give her voice much description. Vibrant, unmistakable, unmatched... something that will give it an even better quality.
A much improved and much more interesting first scene to Oracles possession Myth, I liked this and it kept me interested in teh world throughout. Plus It was much more clear than the first installment.
Wow, this is wonderful. I loved it! Very interesting, I can't wait for you to post the next part! I don't have any complaints.
Thanks for the compliment *beams*
I like to go for traditional stuff and most books I have read usually have wizards/mages with birth names that they keep hidden as a name is precious and is part of the character. So if a name is revealed the enemy has a slight power over the mage, etc.
Further comments are welcome before the new part is posted.
How do you write so well? Nice job Myth!!
There was only one thing I had a question about and that is why did the mages hide their name? Besides that though it was very good!