WHAT IF LUKE SKYWALKER HAD GIVEN IN TO THE DARK SIDE AND OBEYED THE EMPEROR’S COMMANDS?
“Take your father’s place and become my apprentice!”
The words echoed around Luke’s head as he lay there in disbelief of what he had just done… only minutes ago, he had resisted to kill his father, Vader, and given him self over to the Emperor. His fear and anger had taken over him, and he had gotten to his knees and simply said ‘yes’.
The simplest word for the most complicated situation a Jedi knight could ever come across. But ‘Jedi’ no longer applied to Luke’s current situation. He was on the path to becoming a ‘Sith Lord’. Damn it.
His father was off in medical care getting a new robotic hand connected to his arm, and Luke was sat in his chambers. Luke was aware that his friends had failed to destroy the Death Star and had retreated, currently assessing the situation. Should they destroy the Death Star with Luke in it, as the Emperor’s new apprentice?
He didn’t like it very much himself, but he had feared the survival of his friends and everyone he loved. That fear had consumed him, and in the spur of the moment, yes had escaped his lips unconsciously.
What would Leia think? Would she be frustrated with Luke? Of course she would! She had every god damn right to be! Luke had been weak; the fear of loosing everything at once had blinded him. He’d had no real awareness of his actions at the time, and Luke felt incredibly ashamed.
“Luke?”
Vader’s call disturbed Luke’s thoughts, and he sat up and motioned for the door to open with his hand.
His father stepped into Luke’s chambers and he assessed his son with brief concern.
Vader feeling concern… how stupid!
“I’ve been thinking – well… we’ve been thinking – that it’s time you started your training. That you started your path to becoming an incredible Sith.”
The words were like poison. Luke couldn’t believe he was hearing them; he wanted to escape! To leave this place and be back home at Tatooine when everything was so simple and so un-complicated, before he had bought the droids that had led to the death of his family, before everything!
Biting his lip, Luke nodded and cursed himself in his thoughts for being such an idiot.
“Your thoughts betray you, Luke,” Vader sighed. He observed Luke once more and started towards the door. “We’ll be seeing you shortly in the Emperor’s lair.”
Luke nodded and felt a surge of relief as Vader left his room. He gathered his sith robes, new light saber and just happened to leave his common sense behind as he exited his chambers and made his way to the lair.
He hated this. He hated the way the droids acknowledged him, how the storm troopers looked at him and how the general crew of the Death Star observed him with a hint of hate and fear. He did not want to be feared. He did not want to be all-powerful.
He had joined against his will, and that made it so damn obvious he was going to be useless to the Emperor. Luke would not be a perfect asset to the Empire like the Emperor envisioned. Luke would be a stubborn and all-round disappointment for them (that made Luke slightly smug).
His legs had taken him to the lair quicker than he thought, and before he knew it, he was stood before the Emperor.
“Accessing your anger is the key to you becoming sith, my young apprentice,” the Emperor hissed as he looked upon Luke from his throne. “Wield your weapon, and I would like to see you unleash your anger on these useless droids we captured.”
The Emperor pointed over Luke’s shoulder towards the droids. Luke turned to face them, and felt his body go numb with ache and pain as he heard the familiar cries of his beloved companions being pushed towards Luke.
“Master Luke! How happy I am to see you. You’ll be able to rescue us straight away, get us out of this terrible place.”
Oh no…
“Ouch! R2 don’t do that! What? What was that you say? Master Luke has turned to the Dark Side? Sometimes I wonder if I’m translating your words correctly.” C3PO turned to face Luke and began shuffling towards him. “You’re going to get us out of here aren’t you?”
Luke gulped.
“Unleash your anger Luke! Your hatred towards me and your father, unleash it all on these droids!”
He grabbed his weapon.
“Luke, whatever are you doing? Ah yes! You’re going to destroy these incompetent enemies and save us! See R2? I told you Luke would get us out of here! Dark side… ha!”
The red of Luke’s light saber glowed.
“Good.” The Emperor cried, raveling in the enjoyment of watching Luke Skywalker destroy his beloved droids.
“Why on Earth is your light saber red, Master Luke?”
Beep beep beep.
“He has not! I’m sure there’s some logical explanation R2. Right Luke?”
I’m sorry, thought Luke as he stopped just a metre from C3PO and R2.
“Do it!”
“My goodness Luke. What are you planning on doing with that treacherous thing?” C3PO waved his arms about in surprise as Luke raised the light saber above his head.
Think of your hatred towards the Emperor, just kill the droids and get it over and done with. Now! Don’t think; it’s the only way. Just… do it!
“Master Luke, I ⎯”
Luke cut him off, brought down the light saber, and saw the reflection of his demonic gold eyes in C3PO’s metal body, witnessing the end of a heroic Jedi Knight and the rise of a dark and powerful Sith Lord.
I’m sorry Obi-Wan Kenobi, I’ve failed you.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hello

Interesting idea, and I like how you have put it all together. There are some bits of the story I would have done differently, but I guess yours works too
I thing that Luke would need stronger reasons to join the dark side, you could have modified the main story of the movie a little bit more. For example: Make someone in life danger, and he could only save him bi joining the dark side (Sidious is taking someone hostage or something), but then, a chain of events leads him to stay, and make him kill Vader, just so things could be more messier in his mind. But that's just how I would do it maybe.
Also, I think that Vader wouldn't call him to begin his training, I think that it would be better if it was a droid or someone who isn't important.
Hey MysticalBlood!
) Also, in this sentence: "I’ve been thinking – well… we’ve been thinking – that it’s time you started your training." I don't think it quite fits Vader... he's not really like a sentimental father type, and that's almost the feeling I got.. But other than than, I think this was a great piece; definitely keep writing, you've got a lot of skill and potential for a writer!!! I look forward to reading other great stories!
Being a Star Wars fan, this piece really interested me; it's a really interesting idea! I won't critique spelling errors and whatnot, just the story:
What I liked:
I liked the idea in general, and your imagination and story-weaving. It's really cool to think about "what if", and I thought it was great that you could change a story and be able to envision what could have happened. You're off to a good start when it comes to describing the feelings of a character, for instance:"Luke turned to face them, and felt his body go numb with ache and pain as he heard the familiar cries of his beloved companions", so great job with that. I also liked the ending statement; it was a powerful punch at the end of a sad/epic point of the story.
Some pointers:
Some of the characters weren't quite themselves- C3P0 mostly... I don't know that he would be quite so clueless (although, yes, he is in general clueless
Vet
Well i was sure i rated it for teenagers, but the website has changed and gone all weird and stuff so i don't know. But thanks anyway! And yeah, vader is kind of suppose to sound like that. Gah, it's ok to love SW. I LOVE IT SO MUCH.
Hi, I'm #FF4080 ">Shooting Stars! I know I'm a girl and it may be a little weird, but I have always loved Star Wars (I haven't wanted to admit this to anyone). I've watched all the movies almost a million times... ugh. #40BFFF ">Yeah, everyone has that nerdy side to them.
Anyway, right as I saw "Star Wars: If Luke had Gone to the Dark Side" I immediately clicked on your story. To be honest I thought it wouldn't be very good, but you proved me wrong. I think this was very well written, but here's two things I didn't particularly love:
1)
This is Darth Vader speaking, but I feel like it isn't. Darth Vader here sounds unsure of himself almost. He's supposed to be radiating power and confidence.
2) You used the "d" word a few times. I know it may not seem bad to you, but I hate it when writers use cuss words. Especially since some people are kids (like me) browse this site, we don't want to see words like this. I know this isn't anything like some, but just keep it in mind.
#FF4080 ">LOVED THE LAST LINE! Great job and KEEP WRITING!
---Shooting Stars
That was really good!
I'm a hardcore Star Wars fan, so this was rather refreshing! I think that Luke should have killed Vader though. But that's just my opinion! Good job! 
Ah thankies! I couldn't bring myself to kill of Vader though, i love him too much :'D And yes it was supposed to be funny, thanks so much for the reviews guys!:D
Hey MysticalBlood,

is good. It really seals off your writing well.That was funny. I'm sorry if it wasn't supposed to be, but I laughed for the most part of it. Which, don't get me wrong, was good. You generally want a reaction, right?
Although, you did the end really well, which serious-i-fied it all up nicely. I stopped laughing then
Your dialogue is really clean, not too excessive and not too short. You made it clear who was speaking and you had enough informative background writing so that I knew what was going on.
Your last line, and I quote:
Allover, I found it entertaining, which, yeah, is a good thing!
Well done!
NightWriter x
Hey Mystical! Dogs here with your review today! I don't know if i should have but I found a lot of this story really funny and then I realized at the end that It really wasn't funny *sigh*. You have done very well at capturing the war Luke is waging inside of himself and his rejection towards his father. When Luke said "yes" to the emperors will I really was expecting more to float around in his head. What was it that really caused Luke to say "yes" to the emperor? Why did he say it? What caused him to do it?

Finally on a plot based point would Vader die now because he isn't the sith's apprentice anymore so by extension he would have to go because a Sith can only have one apprentice... Anywho If i were you I would suggest that maybe you change this up and make it into a comedy. I would absolutely love that but totally up to you of course
This was pretty good and I really liked it, Keep up the good work!!!!
TuckEr EllsworTh
This is great! I always wondered what would happen if he turned... You did a great job showing it!