Okay, Bob. I've read this a couple of times now (it needed it, believe me) and I'll probably read it a couple of more before dragging you into a conversation about it. For now, I'll just give you a few thoughts.
Accessibility: We've talked before about being concise and taking out extra words, but in some cases I think that you edge towards an extreme, where all accessibility to the reader is lost. Don't drag us down with descriptions-- leave some breathing space, occasionally, whether it be to place emphasis or allow for rhythm, give us some room. Right now, the meaning seems to hang on every word, and while that can be a truly excellent thing, I think that it becomes extremely dense. Don't make us fight for it every single time. Yes, being forced to think is wonderful, but being able to enjoy words is as well.
Imageries: You have some lovely things in here. You really, really do. However, at times I have to wonder-- do you need it all? I'm quite infamous for fleeting images that need expanding, so maybe I shouldn't even touch this subject but I feel like at times you've passed things over with just the lightest of touches and other times have fallen into expansion while bringing up other just-barely-there things in those expansions. Be careful. This is where it gets dense, and people get lost.
Now, again, I love this. You emulate others' styles very well while keeping your own tone and language, which is a wonderful skill the have (still think you're like Kirby in that respect!) and I think that this piece itself was great. I was able to follow it (after the second reading or so xD) and I do think that it's understandable, but I would recommend anchoring yourself more in your poetry. Just a thought. I'll have a more coherent one in the future.
Points: 719
Reviews: 562
Donate