Young Writers Society

Unfortunately, I've only read the first version of this because frankly I couldn't be bothered reading something twice and trying to spot the differences. Sorry, I know it makes me sound mean. So you may have fixed the critcisms I'm about to give already.

First off, the bad things. A lack of plot, for a start, which I know hasn't been fixed in the revised version. We're given the basis for a solid story (good character, decent setting, etc.) but unfortunately the basis isn't good enough. I want something to make me keep reading. For example, where is the man going? Why is he going there? And what will he do when he gets there? You get the idea...
Also, the piece seems to be all atmospherics. Sure, this is nicely done, and we can feel the tension and the darkness etc. but that's about it. You need something more then just dry atmosphere. Like energy for example, or just make something exciting happen. Don't rely on atmosphere.

Now, the good things. As you're probably tired of hearing, your details are brilliantly thought out and well observed. You take simple things and make them crisp, clear images. Well done.
And speaking of images, this piece is full of them. I'm somebody who thrives on the unusual and bizarre and there were moments in this story that I lapped up with relish. Bravo.
Oh, and good use of location, by the way. I was given a good sense of the man in his lonely house, watching TV, all by himself. A nice touch.

Overall, the piece was well written and very, very, readable. And who knows, you may even have fixed the problems I noticed.
Well done,
TF.

Thank you all very much for your criticism. All I can really say is that I thought the story up as more of a description than a real story, but then that really isnt what I should have been doing.

I'll redo what I have written so far, cutting back on the telling and try to do more showing. I'll also try to work the conflict I had planned into this initial scene so that it is more gripping.

Hopefully I will be able to rewrite this over the weekend but if not I'll have it written by next week. Either way I hope that all of you will give me your opinions on my rewritten piece.

Thanks Goldie, Misty and Claudette all your suggestions are much appreciated.

REVISED VERSION

A man sat on and old and faded green armchair, his dull brown eyes fixed firmly on the television before him. On the floor, next to the chair, a book lay sprawled open. The page showed a strange black and white picture. Large swirling storm clouds dominated the picture. A lighting bolt issued forth. Dimly, in the distance, a yellow figure was cut in half by the bolt.

The man, bored by the program, nervously tapped the side of the chair. He drummed out an uneven rhythm on the arm of the chair. The action movie before him reached a crescendo of violence. He gazed on, unseeing. There was a sudden crack of thunder, followed by the patter of rain drops upon the roof. The man’s head twitched to the side. For a moment he focused on the specks of rain that appeared on his second story window, before hurriedly spinning back to face the television.

During that brief twitch his eyes had focused on something. By the window there was a low wooden table, caught between washed out brown curtains. A white cloth was draped over it. On this table was a wooden pen holder, full to the rim. Not unusual in itself, but the composition of the pens seemed to tell a story. The pens, a mixture of blacks and bright yellows, had been painstakingly arranged. The yellows forming a zig zag, a lighting bolt, starkly contrasted to the black around it.

The man suddenly heaved himself up. He strode the four paces from his chair to the window, vehemently yanking the curtains close. With a swipe of his hand he overturned the jar of pens, spilling them out onto the floor. He realised his mistake and hunched down. Frantically his nervous finger tried to rearrange the fallen pens. Another roll of thunder stopped this flurry of activity and with six long strides he was rushing down the wooden stairs. He reached the bottom, a small nondescript bathroom to his left. On the right was a grim kitchen, dark and lifeless.

He passed straight by them, heading for the front door. He purposely didn’t glance at the assortment of pictures on the wall. Two pictures were of jagged lighting. But one, one stood out from the others. The picture from the book was framed between the two other pictures. He paused to grab a weather stained yellow anorak, eyes cast down. As he pulled it on there was an ominous tension. He reluctantly pulled the door open. His yellow figure looked out of place, outlined against the outside grey. Above dark storm clouds swirled, brewing thunder. A bolt of lighting erupted from overhead. The door slowly swung too as the unknown man disappeared in a flash of blinding white. In the silence the lock clicked shut.

The man [comma] seemingly [s]enamoured[/s] enamored by the program [comma] was nervously tapping the side of the chair, drumming out an uneven rhythm.

The action movie before him reached a particular crescendo of violence [comma] but he gazed on, unseeing.

The man suddenly heaved himself up and strode the four paces from his chair to the window, vehemently yanking the curtains close.

and with another 6 long strides he was rushing down the wooden stairs.

The door slowly swung to, the unknown man disappearing as the sudden flash of light dimmed.

Ok, so there are clearly a few things at play here. 1) an old man likes to watch TV, 2) he is obsessive compulsive, and 3) there is a thunder storm going on outside. These details can certainly be in a story, but in themselves, do not make up a story.

SOME THINGS YOU DID WELL

I was very clearly able to picture this in my mind's eye. The man was a certain figure in my head, his house, his television, his blinds. You are clearly an articulate girl with a good vocabulary, which is always grand. It's nice reading somebody with real talent. Also, as Goldie said, the man (ergo, you) clearly knew your way around the house.

SOME THINGS TO WORK ON

You need to break up your sentences, make them more stattico. All the same length sentences get very dry, very boring, to read. Also, your overuse of adjetives is horrific. Show, not tell. You need not tell me about the jammed up table with the lightly worn washcloth and the zigzagged pens with the washed out curtains all in the same sentence. While the description is good, you can easily overdo it. And you do.

ALSO~

Where is your plot? I looked, but didn't find it. It seems like you have a solid character and setting, though, and perhaps the plot will follow? I saw a clear obsessive-compulsive component in your man.

OVERALL

This was entirely not-unpleasant story to read. It did not give me a headache or bore me or cause any cringing or premature graying for stress at trying to fix the grammatical ruin. In fact it was quite nearly good. Fix the over-use of adjetives and you're really onto something. I hope you will let me know when you continue this?

Thank ya!

~Misty

Nicely done!

The details are thorough. You feel as though you know your way around the house. The mood is well told.

I've a small suggestion. Just a teeny one. It seems that here and there in your paragraphs, the sentences are all the same length. Why not try breaking it up? Some long sentences, some short? It would add even more punch to your writing.

Good job! Keep it up!

Goldie