Hi MJ! Wow, I really enjoy reviewing your works, haha. It's the demon goddess and your supreme ruler here for a (hopefully) quick review!
You know all of that jazz about me changing my review style, right? Yes? No? Either way, it's still good. I have recently crowned myself the Bebas Queen so I'm going to use that font a lot, okay? XD
Anyways.
Grammar:
Again, your grammar is brilliant. In this section I usually just do nitpicks and possible typos for you XD There is no "Other" section because it isn't needed.
Grammar - Mechanics:
I.. I mean no harm
Usually, when there's a stammering situation, the word in question that is stammered is separated by a dash and not several periods. The periods mean a pause in the middle of a sentence or a trail-off, not a stammer. I noticed this several times, but I will not point it out.
O King
"O" is spelled "O'."
perfefct
Mechanics typo
Heir of the Moonlight chapter 2
In the title, "chapter" should be capitalized.
Otherwise, you're good!
Grammar - Dialogue:
Step this way, please." the general led Lieutenant Aplex
"the" should be capitalized. It might be a typo, but whenever there's no tag sentence or if it's a proper noun, the first word after dialogue MUST be capitalized. I know, I know, I'm lecturing, and I do know it's most likely a typo, but still. Just a friendly reminder
his son.”
You put a quotation mark at the end here but not at the beginning.
Otherwise, you're good!
Plot:
What a welcome surprise from last chapter! This time I definitely was NOT bored. One moment, Thomas was in his bedroom, the next he's in mysterious woods in a different universe? Interesting, and it caught my attention for sure! Good job!
You could have grabbed my attention a bit better than "Thomas awoke in the woods" but otherwise, that's all of my critique for the plot for this chapter! I am very nitpicky about hooks and things like that, so that's probably why, haha.
Setting:
You could have done a bit better describing the woods. I live in a heavily wooded area, so I imagined it to be like that, but it could easily be a forest like in Sequoia National Park, which is a lot different than the woods around here. So you could have put, instead of "some animals," some specific wildlife to give me a clue on what general region he is in, or at least what type of climate if you want to keep his location a secret Like, if you put that there are monarch butterflies, that ticks me off that he's either in a northern Mexico to southern Canadian type climate and ecosystem, or if you put that it was muggy and there were colorful birds in the trees, that would tell me that he's in an India-type climate/ecosystem.
I love going on about the nature stuff in stories. It just interests me, haha.
Character(s):
Thomas:
Pretty much the same as last time. A well-rounded character, but an ordinary teenager.
However, something confused me. He was taken to a strange man who thought he was his son in rich clothes that claimed to be a king and Thomas just slept there and accepted the fact that, even though he wasn't the prince, that he didn't speak up. I'm sure that he was greatful for the king's hospitality so he didn't want to reveal this just yet, but I would have spoken up if this situation had happened to me.
Lieutenant Aplex:
Aplex is a very stereotypical army commander. This bothered me a little bit, especially since he kind of reminded me of Crystal a little bit. Is Crystal the stereotypical army commander? Crap.
Anyways, I actually found him quite funny. I say keep the stereotypical-ness, since he made me laugh (God, he is just like Crystal) and that I think there should be a FEW stereotypical characters in your story
The general:
On the contrary, the general is more laid-back than the Lieutenant. Shouldn't a general be more battle-hardened and yell-y and gruff than the lieutenant? Instead, the general spared Thomas's life and allowed him to see the king immediately, even though Thomas could very well be a thief with an uncanny resemblance to the king's son. Just saying.
The king:
I really doubt that a father would be this subdued when it comes to seeing his son again. This was one of the very few parts that I didn't find believable in this chapter. I would make the king more excited and maybe even a little eccentric so the general won't be surprised the king is acting this way. Take Asgore from Undertale, for instance. When there was a possibility that he would have a child again, he stopped fighting you and decided to adopt you (and then that's when Flowey came it. Bastard.). Asgore was always a bit eccentric and a big fluff-nugget according to the other monsters, so it wouldn't be surprising that he did that.
Just an example
PoV:
Same as last chapter. There IS no PoV, so I won't put it.
Otherwise?
No, I don't think any of the characters are worth mentioning. The characters above all have obvious flaws - Thomas's was stated in the previous chapter, the lieutenant is gruff, stubborn, and hard on his soldiers (judging from the fact that they are all whipped into shape), and the general is too laid-back, it seems.
Believability:
I think I covered all of the things that aren't believable already in the Character's section, so there's nothing that I need to put here.
Clarity:
This was very clear to understand what was happening, except for the one part about how Thomas saw a path and then a road (like what whatchamacallit mentioned), which I noticed too, but that's an easy fix. Nice job on that. There are a few works on here that aren't the most clear.
Engagement:
This is where you seem to have the most trouble. You are just telling, not showing. That's the main thing about the chapter. I don't MIND the tell-but-no-show thing, but other readers might, and I'm reviewing this for all readers.
If you include some foreshadowing, like I said in the other review, then I would feel more engaged and need to put more THOUGHT into reading, which is an activity that I extremely enjoy doing. You can easily make it very subtle so only the closest readers would figure it out, and I'm a close reader and I didn't see that. All it takes is one or two words.
Maybe if you "broke the 4th wall," so to speak, once in this chapter, it'll send the reader reeling if they know what that term means (breaking the fourth wall is when the character/narrator says something about the readers). I've read several comments on Tumblr and Wattpad on stories in which characters broke the fourth wall that are like "WOAHHHH DONALD TRUMP COME AND FIX THE WALL" and stuff, so you'll know that the normal readers quite like and are engaged in fourth wall breaking.
Overall:
This is a lot better than the last chapter! This has gotten me interested and I can't wait to read what happens to Thomas next, and if he's the "Heir of the Moonlight" or not. Hopefully Chapter Three will be a breeze too, haha.
Give me your soul,
Squire Kara R. Stevens of KotGR.
and
Points: 15630
Reviews: 364
Donate