Hiya! It's been, like, six years since I read Lord of the Flies, and to refresh myself, I went ahead and read the synopsis on Sparknotes so I can give you a proper review. To my understanding, it seems like this is an alternate ending in Jack's POV instead of Ralph's, and it was indeed interesting!
I'd first like to point out that I decided to read the synopsis about halfway through reading the story. Since it's been a while since I read this book, I actually couldn't remember what scene this was talking about, nor did I know why Jack was out for blood. I realize later that it was a thirst of power, but I didn't realize that early on. So my suggestion is to make the motive more noticeable and apparent at the beginning, as well as give details to the leading events of why he's doing this.
Speaking of details! At the beginning, sensory details are a must. How did it feel when he pushed down Ralph, his nemesis? That part seemed rushed, especially since he's being antagonized by Jack. What about when the fire burned down the forest? Was it hard to breathe? Did it smell like an overwhelming amount of, say, food that was in the oven too long? Did the scorching ashes in the air burn his skin? Did his heart drum against his skin, powered by adrenaline? Details like these really make the story breathe and come alive. There was one particular part where you did an excellent job of this:
He ignored the uncontrollable flames just feet away from him, ignored the cacophony of sparks around him, even ignored the slew of ululating sounds that pierced the mountainside above him.
Basically after this part, you did a great job tying both emotion and action into the story so it flows naturally without feeling rushed. However, it was mostly action in the beginning. Add more details and emotion (i.e. the thrill of things burning or the thought of killing Ralph, or the power that swelled in him that he felt like he had utmost control) and it will really add more color and encourage the reader to read on. That's why intros are very important, because if a reader isn't captivated at the beginning, they probably won't continue reading.
Last but not least, a line from the story that I really enjoyed:
Even his thirst for the salty taste of blood became inconsequential, and it was replaced by one desire: the desire to survive.
Overall, this was a nice twist on the original story. I think you did a great job on this; I hope you got an A on this assignment! I loved the end when the realization hit Ralph, and all he can do is sob at what he has done while the flames engulf him. Truly haunting.
I hope this helps! Keep on writing -- I'd love to read more.
Cheers,
Carina
Points: 10085
Reviews: 147
Donate