The ceremony was beautiful. A photo of a young and healthy Adam Garret in pastor’s collar had been placed by the coffin covered with white orchids; a photo in which he smiled like no one had seen him smile for the past year. Through the sound of tears, and sniffles, of relatives and close friends; as the organ began playing the melody of “Time To Say Goodbye” by Andrea Boceli, the younger brother didn’t cry—not because he held anything back, but because there was no precious connection or bond severed that day. Adam Garret these ten years had already been dead by sentimental means.
He had not joined the company for coffee afterwards—instead he had caught the closest S-ban from Dennewitzplatz. He bought a ticket from the machine by the station and stepped onto the escalator. Halfway up the track-platform he met an elderly woman in fur-coat who asked him to help her carry her luggage downstairs. She spoke in German at first, and then said “I need—uh, help wiz’ zé bags.”
Down the escalators again, she grabbed her baggage and thanked him, but soon turned around.
“Lang lebe der Regenbogen!” She said holding her arm raised in salute.
How she accurately assumed him for a queer he did not know, and paid little inquiry of thought. Perhaps it was the suit.
He looked out the oval windows of the doors as the train left Alexanderplatz. The autumn sunset shining along the industries of the city gave it a golden crust; the metal ledges and concrete glistening in the moment like the relief of some ordeal affirmed by the outer world. Berlin had never seemed so beautiful.
The white motel room was austere, with four bunk beds along both walls, even though he was a single guest. He spoke in his cell phone as he entered and placed the card key into the electricity socket.
Back at the train, near the end of his line, the ticket inspectors had knocked him awake. Apparently he had forgotten to stamp his ticket through the machines by the platform and had to pay forty Euros. He tried to explain that he was a tourist and hadn’t known any better, and offered himself to step off the next station. They looked at him callously. “No,” they said in choir,“wha’z that gonna help?—I’z too late naow!” Apparently the good old fascism has not left the culture yet, he thought while walking up the lobby.
“No, I know that!” He said into the phone. “But I still had to pay. Yes, I know I didn’t have to, but I lost it—they caught me off guard.” He slipped out of his polished leather shoes and sat down on the bed, still suited.
“Yes, it was beautiful. Well I spoke to her, but I sat next to my cousin. She and dad were at the front row. I didn’t cry.”
He bit his lip over the last part, looking at the receipt of forty Euros ill-spent.
“The plane leaves Frankfurt tomorrow at noon,” he said. “I’ll be in Wisconsin by midnight. No, I won’t be traveling with the others. I’ll call you from New York, okay? I’ll see you soon. I love you too. Bye.”
He put the phone to recharge, and removed his black jacket. He opened up the window, had a smoke and tried reading a little.
Eventually he put the book aside and went to the little make-up table by the foot-end of the left bunk bed and picked up the envelope. It only said “To Mathew”. He had received it from his mother the day before and had not opened it yet. His brother had wished to send it to him personally a couple of months ago from the hospital. He had refused to give their mother the address of his fiancé, Al Heath.
Perhaps out of boredom, he gently tore the rim and pulled out the paper inside. His brother always had beautiful handwriting, as opposed to himself. He looked out the window, and stood looking for a long time before he sat down on the bed again; his heart beating. And he read:
“Hi, Mathew.
I assume you know why I’m writing you this letter. The doctors say that the cancer has spread.
The chemotherapy is taking its toll, and by the time you choose to read this, I don’t know if I’ll even be there to answer for these words. When we were kids you used to say I had a fat ass, well you should see it now. I’m not doing very well.
I won’t ask for undeserved sympathy, but lying here in the hospital bed, I like to think that we had a good childhood together, right? What happened next, I can’t rationalize by words. I guess that’s why you’re the writer and I’m not.
I’ve come to terms with whatever vow you’re taking, and I’m sorry that it won’t mean much to you by now. But let me make my last point clear.
Through this lonely harsh cold, we conquer, we devour, we fuck; we live. And at the end of the day, all we get is this one go; one shot at life. Remember man; be sincere, stay loyal, tell the one you love how you feel. But never, ever, forget where you’re from—‘cause when you do, you’re a long way from home.
I love you. I wish things had played out differently, and I wish you were here with me now.
My heart, Adam.”
He held the sheet in one hand; his other covering his brow, sobbing in the blonde light, the receipt of the fine still pinched between the letter and his fingers.
The sun silently slipped away beyond the black silhouettes of German suburbia, like an eavesdropper stricken by guilt; as if to let the cold night pass quickly upon some whim of empathy not expected to be appreciated.
And night came, and night passed, and in its trail; all history written.
THE END
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hey man!
I flipped through your work and stumbled upon this. You have a great writing voice, keep it up man!
I especially liked the playful, almost easy-going tone of the prose, and of course the very emotionally charged letter at the end. I especially like how you make the reader understand the nature of the brother's conflict without really explaining anything to us.
Really well done!
Thanks man! Had some trouble with the submit button?
Hello, PeanutPhoebe here for a review. First off, like I told someone else just yesterday, I don't appreciate the cussing. I'm a Christian, and God's Word says not to do so. But on to another topic. You did pretty well with paragraphs. I like your descriptions, they were simple, yet informative. I think the beginning was a little bit abrupt. Hmm...what else to say?
Oh yes, when the lady speaks in German to him, I would say right after something like "Meaning such and such". That would definitely help, since I was a little confused where you got the word queer. Good job, and Keep writing!!
Lady Celestia, the Glorious Knight
Thanks for the review!

I'm sorry, but it looks like me and your God won't be getting along very well, in that case.
I decided not to translate the German, because for one: it's rather obvious what she is saying, and two: it felt cheap, and like a waste of words because of reason no. 1.
She says: "Long live the rainbow," which is a reference of course to the colors of the Pride-movement.
All the best!
hey there.
I read this story a few days ago, but didn't get a chance to reply until now. one of the things you'll hear people say in writing workshops is that you have to find your "voice." after reading this I have to say that if you haven't found your voice yet, you are very close. the tone of the writing seemed very thoughtful yet well-tempered, quiet in a way but not so much as to leave the reader feeling like something is lacking. it reminded me of a collection of short stories I read recently titled The Theory of Light and Matter by Andrew Porter. I suggest you read it if you get a chance as an example of the range and depth this kind of voice posses.
the only major complaint I have with this story is that it seems incomplete, like there is something more that you wanted to show us but you felt like there wasn't enough room. I didn't understand the relevance of Matthew being gay or how the German woman was able to intuit that. I also didn't understand why the two brothers had become estranged. you don't need to give us every single detail, but just a little bit more information would be enough for the readers to figure it out for themselves.
other than that I thought it was very well done and I look forward to seeing more of your work in the future.
take care,
Hi there! Thanks for the review!
I wish you all the best.
Since I tend to write short stories of say, perhaps 3000-7000 words, I wanted to try and minimize the use of words down to a 1000. I had this idea floating around for a while about two brothers in conflict, and where the resolution of a conflict reaching the surface when it's already too late, and one of the brothers are dead; hence the letter.
It's up to you to decide exactly how and what happened between them, because it's not really important to the morale of the story.
Adam Garret was an American pastor working in Germany by the church of Dennewitzplatz, which is an American Church in Germany. He has excommunicated his brother for being gay, which the woman in fur-coat communicated to the readers, and the fact that Adam Garret was a pastor by noting the collar he is said to have in the funeral photograph. I actually hoped people would catch those and create a connection.
While I agree that it is condensed, I like to think I that I still managed to leave behind the essentials for the reader to connect the dots themselves, but I guess that varies from reader to reader.
I am very flattered by your kind words.
Hello!

Wow, this is a very nicely written and touching story. The end was so sad yet touching to me that I teared up a bit. I especially liked your description of the sun in the end. I almost felt bad for the brother because I was in business too.
What I found confusing was the part about the old woman making that comment about the the brother. I know that this has been mentioned already. But could you give a little description as to what the woman looked like when she told him that? I thought it was good and I imagined her smiling, but I got confused for a second about how she looked.
One little teensy-weensy mistake I will point out. You say this:
"Perhaps out of bore..."
It's [boredom]. It's not that important though because I understood what you meant.
Great story. I really liked it.
Haha, thanks man. I must've outsmarted myself, because I actually didn't catch until now. Corrected it, though.

I'm glad you took it to heart! I really am.
All the best!
Hi Lebensborn,
It's a very nicely written story. I enjoyed reading it a lot.
Did you make the elderly lady comment on Mathew's sexuality so that, later when when the writer declaims his fiance to be someone called Al health, we are not confused?
I don't feel there was any other reason for putting the elderly woman there. Or maybe you just put her there to distract Mathew from the task at hand: getting the ticket stamped. I don't know, I'm a terrible reviewer.
I think the story is of perfect length and the descriptions are really beautiful.
However, I personally think the letter could've been more subtle (not that there's anything wrong with it), I just feel it reveals too much. You are bold to use sentences like: Through this lonely, harsh cold, we conquer, we devour... without sounding sloppy. Which is admiring.
Best wishes,
Puck.
A short but very touching story. You build your way up to the point, and once you reach it you drive it right in. The woman with the luggage making that comment, coupled with the 'pastor's collar' photo at the funeral helped make an early connection. It was easy to see what had caused this conflict between brothers, and while the ending was sad, you at least let us know that an understanding had been reached. Very well done.
The only suggestion I would make is to give readers just a bit more background in the beginning. For example, why is the funeral being held in Germany, if he is not German? That's about it, though. Good job.
I agree. The thing was I was trying to hold the word limit back to about a thousand words, just as an exercise of precision. It kind of bothered me that I cut so much on the back story, but I left one clue: there is only one church in Dennewitzplatz, and it's in fact an American church that teach the holy scripture in English only.
How that connects to the fact of the brother being there is up to you; perhaps he chose it himself, perhaps out of marriage. But nonetheless, I very much appreciate the feedback! And the criticism is legit, but it was an active choice, at the very least. Whatever that's worth.
Ah, okay. That makes more sense now. Perfectly understandable.