Chocolat

by Lauren

Published August 10, 2008

This user has been banned and her works removed from YWS.

Comments & reviews · 6
User avatar
StellaThomas
Review
StellaThomas wrote a review Review · Aug 14, 2008

I remember hearing such good things about this book, and I was really looking forward to it, and then I found it... disappointing.

I think I was expecting too much of it. I mean, it wasn't a bad book, but it most certainly wouldn't rank amongst my favourites. I was expecting it to be a whole lot better. You know the way when something's built up it's bound not to be as good as it's made out to be?

And I really didn't like the Lollipop Shoes either. The café was cool, but the new MC, Zozie or whatever her name was really annoyed me. I thought the friendship between Anouk and the boy who hung out in the cemetry was cool, but Anouk's situation with being bullied in school and stuff I found unlikely and unoriginal. And Pantoufle...

I don't know, they just didn't appeal to me...

-Stella x

User avatar
lady lazarus Comment
lady lazarus commented Comment · Aug 13, 2008

Mmmm I want to read now :]]]

Random avatar
andimlovegalore
Comment
andimlovegalore commented Comment · Aug 13, 2008

Why would she make changes like that? Pretty weird... I don't think I'd mind the POV changes too much but when they start changing names it's just odd.

I agree though, sequals are often disappointing. Not always but... quite often.

User avatar
Lauren
Comment
Lauren commented Comment · Aug 11, 2008

I think it lost some of its spark, to be honest. Vianne was trying to be normal, and this time there were three characters narrating: Vianne (now called Yanne), Anouk (Annie) and Zozie, which meant the characterisation was focused enough.
But sequels are always disappointing.

andimlovegalore wrote a review Review · Aug 10, 2008

I LOVED chocolat when I read it. I was a bit disappointed that they took all those lovely references to magic and all the great frenchyness out of it or the movie (although the movie was good too). I haven't read the sequal yet...I keep meaning to but it keeps slipping my mind. Was it as good as the first one? Her writing style was beautiful, I just loved the way her voice sounded...



I think Amelia Earhart wants you to get some ice cream.
— SilverNight