Published!
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Nicely done. A fitting end in my opinion. A few suggestions: watch using the character's names. I noticed you use them often which can get repetitive and and tiresome.
Watch your word usage, You added ly to the ends of at least two words that didn't need it. It makes it sound odd and disrupts the flow of the story.
The characters retained their personalities through the entire story. It was easy to tell who was who as eah had different thought patterns and speech habits.
Having the captain question what they were doing was nice but his over all conclusion to accept orders was a bit dissapointing. The way you set it up it seemed like there would be a more avtice roll to his thought process. His insult to the IU undermined his original thoughts as well.
Well done. I offer the best of luck in your publication ventures.
Well, I've edited this portion of TOFAB and posted the alternate ending which turned out to be infineatly better than the ending I had before.
If you'd like to track my publishing attempts for this story click here
Thanks for reading!
-Kylan
Really? The ending was good? I don't know... To me something is missing... I mean, it's great that I've got a thumbs up on the end, but I'm thinking of adding a little more. ShadowTwit, Clau, I'll send you guys the alternate ending when I finish writing it. Thank you both so much for reading!!!
-Kylan
Very good ending! And good story; enter it, get it published, go the whole hog! Would Sig Saur have the SIG capitalized though? I've never seem it written like that. That aside, this ws very good, if political.
oh, ew, just say, "Glowing red"
yoi, This was good in the first chapter, but now it is just annoying and repetitive, and sure it makes Ali look like a nut case, but it also makes me want to scream because I already know you are the damn hawk! haha.
Sometimes peoples thoughts are in italics, and sometimes they aren't. Maybe you just forgot to add the code, but for the record, either italicize them, or don't.
write out what ever SAM is. Because as an ignorant reader, I have no idea what that is, so you make the reader feel dumb, which isn't good. You can say SAM later, but at least once explain what it is. Don't be too technical, people will get confused and turned off.
put these together
as far as we know, there is only one other seat, so this seat is closest to him, in relation to what? basically, cut the -est.
again with the technical terms, I didn't know this was a gun until I saw "trigger guard"
Hm. That was the end? I think I'm disappointed...
Your writing is so good that I'm disappointed it was wasted, so to speak, on a story that needs more. This was a good story, but past the first chapter, I wanted more. More conflict, more of me caring, more something. Now I see the story centers around Ali, and his oddity for killing, I assume? But the way you go about that it's just annoying, like I said before. We know that already. It's not like writing about a murderer who is crazy, then you can have them do something once, and we understand they are crazy. You can go deeper into it with their actions. But Ali's actions speak less.
Don't get me wrong, I did enjoy this, but I was still disappointed in it. It was a good climax, I hadn't expected that, but it certainly wasn't what I wanted. What about the other board members? How did they react?
Everything was good. I would lie if I said I didn't enjoy this and that it wasn't well written. But I wanted more. It just didn't satisfy me, in the end. I certainly think you could get it published. I'd suggest to you how you could satisfy me more, but honestly, I can't think of any way. I think the problem was is that I thought this might be a suspense novel, with a business aspect of oil fuels in it. Instead, everything just happened [mostly] as I thought it would. As I knew it would, and as I was told it would. That's why I only enjoyed the first chapter, and perhaps when Ali betrayed Mark. Otherwise, I already knew what was happening before it happened. Not too interesting, hm?
And the scene with Mark dying just didn't catch me. Perhaps because I didn't care for Mark? So his death didn't upset me. That's the only reason I could fathom.
But really, not bad writing! So don't be put off by my rambling ^^